in breakaway she seemed kinda skinny-ish but for MD she is more chubby and it suits her more IMO. which one do you prefer?

I liked how she looked in the SUBG video, her hair and body were both perfection... but people don't stay perfect for long.. so i shall say she looked her best/ most natural in the BTHE video... i think she let herself go by the time she reached the Walk away video and now she is just looking a bit chunky.. but that's what making money does to you lol! she still lokks fantastic anyway! it'd be nice if she lost like a stone but it doesn't matter!

But her abs in the Walk Away video, they were smoking hot! :wub:

 

Now in the Never Again video... she's fully clothed and she shows her chubby arms as well. So she has let herself go a lot since Breakaway. -_-

She looked best in the Walk Away video IMO. She was chubbyish when she won American Idol though and for Breakaway album, she seemed to lose quite a bit of weight, but now she has gone back to normal, rather than gone bigger, which I think is good.

i think kelly being the way she is now sets a good example to other people who are chubby/fat/spotty whatever. i think shes saying im chubby and im still famous. you dont have to change yourself to become famous or to become somebody that you think people will like. and so for that i say HATS OFF TO YOU KELLY

Edited May 5, 200718 yr by Joao Filipe

Which Kelly Clarkson are you talking about?

Because the fabulously talented American Idol winner Kelly Clarkson is not now or has ever been chubby.

In the 'Never Again' video, she has a white suit on and it shows her stomach. If she were chubby, she wouldn't have shown her stomach.

I think it's great that she's not a size 0, but there's no way she's chubby.

And even if she was, Kelly is all about the voice, not the image.

Work that double chin girl:

 

http://buzznet-00.vo.llnwd.net/media/jj1/2007/02/kelly_clarkson_nascar/kelly-clarkson-nascar-03.jpg

 

Only joking :P She looks great no matter...

Kelly seems to have a chubby face rather than body as such.. she is much smaller in real life, however

Chubby

I like her both ways, weight is not an issue..she has a great voice and that is what matters. :)

I agree with OYS, weight isn't an issue.

She has never been chubby really, it's just her bone structure.

I preferred her skinny tbh, although imo she was never skinny as such - just slim and toned. She looked a lot better then ^_^

She's never been skinny and she has never been chubby,

Her face does look chubby, but her actuall body is very curvy, like the Since You Been Gone vid for example

I agree SUBG was her best look. I don't think she's what we'd call "chubby" in normal-person context, but for a worldwide star, she is. But, she still looks pretty great! I was suprised when I met her how thin she was to be honest, I think, as a couple of people said, she does have a chubby face, so you assume the rest is :lol:

 

I think she looks better in the middle or slightly bigger in all honesty. She's just someone I'd never want to see deathly thin, I'd cry and give up.

 

For some reason I hate it when people bring up Kelly's weight because most of the time she gets stick for actually looking like she bothered to eat, when that's just what's normal and how it should be!

^^^ Great comment, she's had a lot of critism over the years over her weight

Who cares if she's chubby otr skinny? Does it matter?

SUBG/BTHE were her best looks imo

As I said in the other thread, I don't mind a bit of weight, but I am just one of these people who prefers skinnyness ^_^