i reckon rihannas to tell ya the truth

Kellys new song is rubbish compared to the old stuff

and rihannas is ace

A Girl Like Me didn't flop though

Exactly :unsure:

Kelly Clarkson has to release a much better second single to do as well as Rihanna i think so on the basis of the lead singles i'll say Rihanna!

I think Kelly has decided to take a risk with her new album - it seems. Everybody keeps having a hissy and whinging about how it's nothing compared to 'Breakaway'. :rolleyes:

It seems after that was such a mammoth success she's decided to not make an album as mainstream and hopes it will do well off the back of the previous record. Not saying its a good move but fairplay to her for trying. :P

 

I honestly think Kelly will have a #2 album and Rihanna will make the top 5 but both will sell about 500k in total.

Kelly Clarkson's of course! I can see it easily surpassing 3 million in America and going more then double platinum in the UK...even though that will still look bad in comparison to Breakaway. I think Rihanna will do her best yet on this though!

After hearing Rihanna's I hope it's hers, fantastic! But of course I haven't heard Kelly's yet