i love mel live andi hope she releases a live cd

i love mel live andi hope she releases a live cd

 

Mel C has a live dvd out resently!

 

I do love the two preformances Emma did of 2 become 1, i have seen them before! I wounder what would of happend had she had the guts to release it as a single......

I must check out and see if i can get it and see how much it is

I must check out and see if i can get it and see how much it is

 

i think it is about £13 in HMV stores, it includes an acoustic set and a set with the full band. It's in with all the other consert dvds. I really should get myself i copy....

Is it all acoustic??

My fave's Mel C, than Emma, Victoria, Geri and Mel B.

Is it all acoustic??

 

Nah, there is an acoustic set and then a loud set which has a full band, it is ment to be very good

I would like the full on loud set ove rthe acoustic

I like Mel B the least by FARRRR -_-

 

And the amazing Melanie C is of course the best vocalist :D

do u mean mel b as a person or singer???

Person, i just cant warm to her. Her 'singing' on some of the spice tracks was quite good, but her solo music was just god awful.

out of them 5 performances you posted i would say singing wise it would go like this :

1.Mel C

2.Victoria

3.Geri

4.Emma

5.Mel B

 

But Generally i would say its like this :

1.Mel C

2.Emma

3.Mel B

4.Geri

5.Victoria

 

Either way though Geri is my fave, and she can sing and has the most distinctive voice!

i would say

1 mel c

2 emma

3 mel b

4 victoria

5 geri

Im starting to like Victoria a lot more lately! If you forget the act she puts on for the media and you see her in interviews, shes a really nice person <3

hm i agree!!! She has the best style too ! I think my fave is Posh now and then close 2nd is Geri :wub: who used to be my fave!

 

Vocal wise posh was good singing IOU (david looked cute)

Geri was average and we all know mel C can sing :P

Edited July 4, 200718 yr by Shaun

Quite amusing how most people have got Geri near the bottom of their lists, and her vocals on that Parkinson performance aren't even live!! They were definitely pre-recorded beforehand.

 

This is the closest video on the net to Geri actually singing live. It was eight years ago, she sounds like she is singing along to herself on the single, and she has tons of backing vocalists, but her live vocals are in there somewhere.

 

Edited July 12, 200718 yr by Peter30

Posh is definitely the best person imo. She's a great laugh in interviews, and even recently when Moyles mocked her in a phone call about her boob jobs she took it really well and laughed along with him. As for the best voice, I think I like Emma the best, her vocal performance on Let Love Lead The Way is brilliant.

i dont mind posh but mel c will alway sbe my fave