July 25, 200717 yr I know I'm awkward but, it is such an emotive subject. Rating or comparing any of D's songs does always seem to get us into a fankle.
July 25, 200717 yr It is just so difficult. The only thing we could do is an either or and keep keeping one. We still wouldn't have the favorite but, it's a different way of trying it.
July 25, 200717 yr but wouldn't we still end up with a consensus which most people won't like because something they really love is languishing at the bottom? We could do a rolling either/or if most people wanted to. One way of keeping it to one main thread would be........Choice of two and first of those to 3 votes, goes on to take on another challenger maybe. Any track which defeats a certain number of challengers(3? 5?) goes onto the Darius bj album shortlist for which we could have a thread without comment which we just revive to add each song.
July 25, 200717 yr expert .....well volunteered :cheer: ready when you are......as long as you wont mind too many floods ....of tears :cry:
July 25, 200717 yr I think the general idea would be to put say Colourblind up against Dive In and get people to choose between them. Yes, that does mean making a decision. As soon as one receives 3 votes, let's say CB, it goes on to face another challenger eg Love To Love and the winner of that continues. An additional secondary part might be that if one song can beat several opponents it should go through to our bj faves list and later we could try to order those faves into personal charts or produce a tracklist for a bj faves album.
July 25, 200717 yr I was going to suggest we tried to avoid setting slow songs against upbeat ones, if that's ok.
July 25, 200717 yr eeeerrrr......eeerrmmmm......wellllll......okkkkayyyyyyyyyy I'm sure we'll try our best :cry:
July 25, 200717 yr That sounds good. I'm looking forward to objecting to the vote already. Well done BT
July 25, 200717 yr That sounds good. I'm looking forward to objecting to the vote already. Well done BT :cheer: :lol:
July 26, 200717 yr I'm just trying to think helpfully. Give it a try some time. No, don't. Don't want to start confusing me again. BT where are you? Come back and do an either or. Pam says you've got the list.
July 26, 200717 yr I'm not sure we need a list to get started. We just need 2 D songs to pit against each other. We do need to decide if the one knocked out is knocked out for good or can go back in the pile to face another song later. I think we should just keep pitting them against each other until we have a 3 times winner to go through to the new BJ list to be kept on a special thread until we need it again. Should a 3 times winner still be pitted against others until it's beaten and given 2 points, instead of one, for each additional win and its final score added to the BJ list. We have to decide if any songs are ineligible. Edited July 26, 200717 yr by Baytree
July 27, 200717 yr It'll hurt but, let's lose them for good. Then we don't have to do it again. We know we're not good at voting things out.
Create an account or sign in to comment