Ashley did sing live at the concert.

 

Haters just that made that ridiculous thing up.

 

I'm not a "hater" (ugh I can't stand that word), I've got nothing against the girl (and I'm not jealous either which is usually the next response).

 

I'm just stating a fact. She didn't sing live at that concert, at least not the HSM songs anyway.

Ashley.

 

I never did like Vanessa, she seems very snobbish.

I think Monique has the best voice, but my fave is Ashley.

I would say Vanessa.

I'm not a big fan, so forgive me for getting some names wrong! I think the guy who plays Ryan has a good voice, although it can get annoying. Same with Vanessa, although she's clearly talented. I've still to see proof that Ashley Tisdale can actually carry a tune, but I'm not a fan of her voice anyway

 

Zak has a very pleasant voice I think. It still baffles me why he didn't sing in the first movie as the guy who sang his voice was very irritating!!