Jump to content

Which Is In Your Opinion The Most Disappointing Comeback Single Of Recent Years? 141 members have voted

  1. 1. Vote For The Most Disappointing Comeback Single In The 2007-2008 Era

    • 2 Hearts - Kylie Minogue
      28
    • Gimme More - Britney Spears
      5
    • 4 Minutes - Madonna
      18
    • Headlines- Spice Girls
      59
    • Taking Chances- Celine Dion
      13
    • Touch My Body- Mariah Carey
      12

Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Featured Replies

  • Replies 84
  • Views 4.5k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

OBVIOUS: Headlines- Spice Girls

 

but madonna and kylie are bad aswell (though kylie had a great album)

 

why no janet?

2 Hearts.

 

AS IF Taking Chances could be seen as disappointing! :lol:!

 

Celine Dion's comeback was one of the best comebacks this year :wub:

 

Headline takes my vote

 

It was tough for me - I was torn between 2 Hearts and Headlice. In the end, I chose the Spice Girls, simply 'cos they called it "classic Spice Girls".
Quite blatently Floplines :P Although 2 Hearts is behind, its not a bad song just a bad KYLIE song.

Thankfully the leaked version of the Madonna single was about as representative of the finished track as a Heather Mills testimony in court. :lol:

 

Hence Kylie's bitterly disappointing comeback single gets my vote.

i agree with the majority too "headlines" spice girls....its dull, uninspired, syrupy generic bland pop like a naff b side from the 90s and rightly so it flopped and will never be played on radio again. i also didn't like "2 hearts" not kylie's style at all.
Difficult to answer. Mariah's new single isnt very good. Neither is Madonna's. Spice Girls song was rubbish and Kylie's comeback single wasnt great.
In the end, I voted for Madonna. Don't like her new song at all and was expecting much better following the excellent confessions singles.
I really don't get the 2 Hearts hate, I LOVED it LOL
It's because it alienated her core fanbase who prefer dance-pop, and because she's capable of SO much better.
Thankfully the leaked version of the Madonna single was about as representative of the finished track as a Heather Mills testimony in court. :lol:

 

:rofl:

Mariah Carey, Kylie, Spice Girls and Madonna's comebacks have been DIABOLICAL imo. Not a patch on their past tracks with two acts having to prance about in their underwear to sell the single and the other two trying desperatley to seem youthful and failing MISERABLEY.

 

Britney's and Celine's were AMAZING though and deserved to be much bigger (the latter more so).

Edited by coolnav

I loved 2 Hearts. =/ Still don't get why people hated it. Well, no, I do, because people are very narrowminded and refuse to listen anything outside one specific genre.

 

Still. -_-

Celines comeback was AMAZING and quite brave and her new album is great, I wish Taking Chances reached higher than bloody 40 in the charts, gosh that was shocking, people just won't allow artists to express themselves in every way, ok she was once a ballad queen (quite literally) but I'm loving her new image. The other songs are rubbish apart from Gimme More which I surprisingly liked! Spice Girls's song is shockingly BAD, they could've been successful again <_<

 

Celines comeback was AMAZING and quite brave and her new album is great, I wish Taking Chances reached higher than bloody 40 in the charts, gosh that was shocking, people just won't allow artists to express themselves in every way, ok she was once a ballad queen (quite literally) but I'm loving her new image.

 

Ur absolutely right CrazyCrazy. I think she's brave for trying new things and still remain true to herself. Look at the tour, it only just started and its very succesfull already.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.