I know its been ages since the first poll ("When I Grow Up"), so here's the followup. Vote!

I love both but Kelly Clarksons for me!

Pink!!

Kelly Clarkson, might be a bit soon though i've not really gotten into Pink's yet.

 

You forgot "Call Me When You're Sober", surely that counts?

Both are brilliant but i've gone for Kelly.

I'm only choosing 2.

Kelly :wub:

love both tracks but i voted kelly.

 

Even though half way through the track she sounds extremely mellow dramatic like she is dieing or something it actually work.s plus the line "picked all my weeds but kept the flowers" just beautiful

Kelly Clarkson. PURE EMOTION!

I voted for Kelly Clarkson. I think its her best song along with BTHE. I've always like the song, but the end scene of the S7 premiere of Smallville with this song made me love it a lot more.

 

 

Pink - Sober easily

I voted for 'Sober' :kink:

 

Kelly got my vote I do like P!nk's, but Kelly's is BEAUTIFUL!

Pink's easily. Kelly's is $h!t.

Love both, but I love Kelly's more.

Shameless plugging :kink:

Visit the Kelly Clarkson forum to find out how Kelly's progress with the next album is going :w00t:

Kelly :wub:

Love both but Pink's edges it for me.

Kelly Clarkson, might be a bit soon though i've not really gotten into Pink's yet.

 

You forgot "Call Me When You're Sober", surely that counts?

 

This is a same title poll, not "songs containing the word 'sober' in the title".

 

I'll go for Pink on this one.

I voted for Kelly Clarkson. I think its her best song along with BTHE. I've always like the song, but the end scene of the S7 premiere of Smallville with this song made me love it a lot more.

 

OMGEEZ :o Thought I was the only one that found a new love for that song after that episode <33

P!nk's will probably overtake in time though for me.

Kelly Clarkson...and when I saw her sing it live, it literally sent shivers down my spine...same the same couldn't be said about the other awful tracks from My December :lol:

 

although I've only heard Pink's Sober once