i chose Amy...

Rihanna's 'Rehab' is good but Amy's a classic.

I'll say Amy, but really i like both songs on the same level

Amy's i hate her but everyone will remember hers Rihanna's will be forgotten soon.

I LOVE Rihanna's but I chose Amy's as it's the song that got me into her!

Amy without a doubt

Amy :wub:

I can't think of a good comparison but this question is quite ridiculous. Amy's is on a different level to this average song from Rihanna. Amy's may be a overrated but deservedly.

Rihanna's for me, I'm obviously in the minority though.

Amy and her $h!tastick song is the most overrated person on the planet. Back To Black is NOT a good album at all imo.

Get your own ideas :P

Rihanna's for me, I'm obviously in the minority though.

I'm with you... Rihanna :P

http://i249.photobucket.com/albums/gg219/AintNoOtherFan/Gifts/2n69f1u.gif

 

At even comparing the two.

Rihanna but I love Amy's too.