One, and I like the Mary J Blige version too! :o

i liked mary j blige one 2, there wasnt anything wrong with it! :D

i liked mary j blige one 2, there wasnt anything wrong with it! :D

Well a lot of U2 fans seem to despise that version :(

i know, i think its just because mary j is the opposite music style to U2,

 

she hip hop, R n B, U2 are Rock.

 

:cheer:

One is an absolute classic song and it is NOT meant to be sung all high and whiney like Mary does it. It's like Mariah bloody Carey. :rolleyes:

 

Some songs should just be left along by female singers who sing in that manner -_-

Edited August 14, 200619 yr by Scotty.

Right -_-

Right -_-

 

Glad you agree :wub:

Of course I do :P

A tie :o

 

With or without you is so much better :wub:

I voted With or without you B)

 

I always thought One was my favorite but i changed my mind ^_^

 

I bet you did :rolleyes:

I bet you did :rolleyes:

 

I can't beleive you dislike With or without you :o

 

It is one of the best songs ever recorded :wub:

 

Even better than most Robbie songs :o

I bet you did :rolleyes:

 

I DO have an opinion of myself -_-

 

:o I never said I dislike it!!!!

I know it's a good song but not the best....

with or without

 

Mary J Blige verison is better that the orignal

with or without

 

Mary J Blige verison is better that the orignal

 

What!!! No way, it was ok! but not better :angry: :o

It changes from day to day but today it is With or without you

 

The Mary J Blige "One" is fuking dire i might add :puke2:

with or without

 

Mary J Blige verison is better that the orignal

 

 

 

:o :o :o :o :o :o :o :o :o :o

One, but both are music classics :cheer:

Both are cracker tunes.