Jump to content

Featured Replies

right, I've spent the last half hour downloading all of the songs, just Latvia left to get now!!! Will listen to them all and update my rankings :D
  • Replies 485
  • Views 25.6k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • Author
I've got all of them since saturday :kink: The 2 month marathon has begun!
I'm listening to them in alphabetical order by song name and am on Et Cetera by Ireland...absolutely excellent :o :wub: I have also so far really enjoyed Denmark (obviously), Azerbaijan and Romania's entries...Belgium, Ukraine and Hungary were ok, Serbia, Bosnia-Herzegovina and the Czech Republic's songs didn't interest me :(
  • Author

Bosnian entry don't interest me this year. Last year's one was absolutely fantastic to be honest! :wub: Ukraine is ok but far worse than 2007 and 2008 :wub: Interestingly, I like Czech Rep. song this year. Gypsy theme has always been one of Russia's best obsessions. Loads of Russian soaps and movies are connected with/tells us about the gypsy culture.

 

AVEN ROMALE!

Turkey - verging on good, very generic

France - too complex for ESC, but a good song

Belaurs - dire, had to turn it off before the end

Norway - incredible :heart:

Cyprus - I love the studio version! hated the live performance that I heard about a month ago, put me right off wanting to listen to it...

Switzerland - so original for ESC, could be a huge radio hit...they'd better qualify with this, it's brilliant!!! I'm so fed up with Switzerland missing out every year with brilliant songs

Moldova - love it, very typical of modern Eastern Eurovision entries but that's no bad thing

 

I'm listening to them in alphabetical order by song name and am on Et Cetera by Ireland...absolutely excellent :o :wub:

 

Woah, not a lot of people like it! :o It's getting slated on youtube and various ESC sites. :(

 

Woah, not a lot of people like it! :o It's getting slated on youtube and various ESC sites. :(

What?! :o Et Cetera is fabulous! :wub: Definitely the best Irish entry of the decade...

Have the final versions of every entry been released yet? If so, could someone direct me to somewhere I can get them all at once? ^_^ (by PM, of course)
What?! :o Et Cetera is fabulous! :wub: Definitely the best Irish entry of the decade...

 

Yeah, comments on Youtube are like "it's $h!t, cheap and tacky" and it's scoring very low on the ESCtoday charts! :cry:

 

 

  • Author
Having listened to Et Cetera in HQ I must agree that it's a good song. A grower in my eyes.

carrying on where I left off last night:

 

Turkey - verging on good, very generic

France - too complex for ESC, but a good song

Belaurs - dire, had to turn it off before the end

Norway - incredible :heart:

Cyprus - I love the studio version! hated the live performance that I heard about a month ago, put me right off wanting to listen to it...

Switzerland - so original for ESC, could be a huge radio hit...they'd better qualify with this, it's brilliant!!! I'm so fed up with Switzerland missing out every year with brilliant songs

Moldova - love it, very typical of modern Eastern Eurovision entries but that's no bad thing

Poland - alright, can't remember it 10 minutes later though...

Bulgaria - quite liked the music in this, the vocals weren't as good but it could certainly grow on me

Iceland - gorgeous ballad, really nice and hope it does well for them

Montenegro - my god!!! What a shock, my favourite Eastern song so far by a mile!!! top 10 for sure I'd say, brilliant disco pop

Spain - excellent, their best entry for many many years and performing last, it's GOT to return them to the top 10, surely!?!

Andorra - very pleasant...their best since 2004's brilliant and hugely underrated Jugarem A Estimar Nos...nice happy pop song

Sweden - fantastic, I'm no opera fan but this song is incredible...perhaps it's because she was absolutely stunning live and I'm biased though!?!

Slovakia - truly awful on first listen...didn't hear a hook, just screaching, by a man and woman...terrible

Croatia - can't understand the hype over this song...sounded boring to me and won't do well at ESC at all...if it goes to the final it will finish mid-low top 20 max

Finland - fantastic Eurodance, a bit like E-Type's True Believer crossed with Cascada's cover of Wouldn't It Be Good, but very good nonetheless

Lithuania - oh ok, I can sort of see the fuss over this song on ESCToday, the verses are really nice and the chorus isn't bad either...will be a grower

Slovenia - wow, very different for ESC...let's hope they don't get drawn next to Sweden in the final or it will sound like the 'classical Eurovision Song Contest'!!!

Russia - so many years on top and now this...terrible, hope it flops and if it doesn't I want answers as to why not!!!

Albania - didn't stick out hugely for me, but it's a hell of a lot better than some of the stuff they've sent in the last few years...good chorus

Germany - haha, you can always rely on the Germans to do something a bit different...not bad actually, quite Michael Buble...will flop though

United Kingdom - beautiful, very dramatic, stunning voice, performing 3rd from last...it's got to be our time to go top ten again, surely!?!

FYR Macedonia - hmm...not quite as bad as I'd imagined it would be...very 1980's - sounds a bit like the old Alvin & The Chipmunks show theme tune!

Armenia - went straight over my head...nothing special at all

Latvia - dire, dire, dire...at least Macedonia's similar song has a tune...this is just terrible, the worst so far I think

Estonia - not great...I don't think they will qualify again

The Netherlands - I know there's a new version of this and this is probably the old one...so cheesy and dated and will definitely fail to qualify, not that bad though

Israel - not bad actually, they almost always send something decent don't they

Greece - well they are finally doing something different for once...nicked Charlotte Perrelli's tune! by default then I really like it! Another top 5 finish for Greece!

Portugal - bland, did nothing for me

Chiara - lovely, another great song by her and will hopefully put Malta back into the top ten!

gooddelta's official ESC 2009 ranking: 18/3/09

 

Stunning

 

1. Norway

2. United Kingdom

3. Sweden

4. Denmark

5. Switzerland

6. Spain

7. Montenegro

8. Finland

9. Ireland

10. Iceland

11. Azerbaijan

12. Malta

 

Very Good

 

13. Greece

14. Romania

15. Moldova

16. Cyprus

17. Andorra

 

Good

 

18. Lithuania

19. Bulgaria

20. France

21. Turkey

 

Average

 

22. Ukraine

23. Hungary

24. Germany

25. Slovenia

26. Israel

27. FYR Macedonia

28. Albania

29. Belgium

30. The Netherlands

 

Poor

 

31. Estonia

32. Armenia

33. Portugal

34. Russia

35. Poland

36. Czech Republic

37. Bosnia & Herzegovina

38. Croatia

 

Atrocious

 

39. Belarus

40. Slovakia

41. Serbia

42. Latvia

  • Author

18/03. #1.

 

Pure ESC perfection

 

1. Norway

2. Israel

3. Croatia

4. Malta

5. United Kingdom

6. Sweden

7. France

8. Moldova

9. Iceland

10. Czech Republic

11. Bulgaria

12. Spain

13. Finland

14. Armenia

15. Switzerland

 

Very good

 

16. Andorra

17. Greece

18. Estonia

19. Russia

20. Serbia

21. Slovenia

22. Denmark

23. Bosnia & Herzegovina

24. Romania

25. Montenegro

26. Ireland

 

Good

 

27. Lithuania

28. Slovakia

29. Albania

30. Turkey

31. Germany

32. Hungary

33. Ukraine

 

Average (quite listenable)

 

34. Azerbaijan

35. Portugal

36. Latvia

37. Poland

 

Awful (not listenable)

 

38. The Netherlands

39. Belgium

40. FYR Macedonia

41. Cyprus

42. Belarus

 

____________________________

 

I didn't think i'd place La Voix that high :lol: AMAZING quality this year! :wub: Probably the best year of the decade for me personally so far

really, the general consensus is that it's a weak year for ESC :o it's pretty average for me, but there do seem to be more awful songs than the last couple of years

 

of course, my views are bound to change once the hype kicks in

  • Author
really, the general consensus is that it's a weak year for ESC :o it's pretty average for me, but there do seem to be more awful songs than the last couple of years

 

of course, my views are bound to change once the hype kicks in

Vice versa for moi :o Comparing to at least last year - this one has far better songs overally. I don't hate many songs, just Belarus, Cyprus and The Netherlands from the very beginning :heehee: Oh and Macedonian and Belgium-Elvis-in-the-building songs are super awful :( Where're you, Tamara, Vrcak etc and Ishtar (:wub:)

Vice versa for moi :o Comparing to at least last year - this one has far better songs overally. I don't hate many songs, just Belarus, Cyprus and The Netherlands from the very beginning :heehee: Oh and Macedonian and Belgium-Elvis-in-the-building songs are super awful :( Where're you, Tamara, Vrcak etc and Ishtar (:wub:)

 

I would be happy not to listen to about 10-12 of them ever again :lol: I love how all of Boyan's favourites are amongst my worst ones...it really is about cultural and personal taste over politics, and these huge differences prove it ^_^

  • Author
Sweden? :o

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.