Posted June 17, 200619 yr Exhibit A - Not Me, Not I Studio [flash=450,350]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ybbqPGSpYAA.swf Live [flash=450,350]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AAKw8WWGVXs.swf Exhibit B - Lost Without You Studio [flash=450,350]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lWFhtNq2EKw.swf Live [flash=450,350]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FlhPOI1RX6A.swf Exhibit C - Innocent Eyes Studio [flash=450,350]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hwbjO9IGhZg.swf Live [flash=450,350]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nekHgK7kfuE.swf
June 17, 200619 yr Author Studio every time for me. I've never been that keen on her live stuff (although finding clips for this thread didn't make it seem so bad :lol:)
June 17, 200619 yr Exhibit D - Born To Try Studio [flash=450,370]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=41BKNToPgb0.swf Live [flash=450,370]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rKScTGpQ33s.swf Exhibit E - Out Of The Blue Studio [flash=450,370]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iWwzdgIKtKM.swf Live [flash=450,370]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GWkWFvTYG8s.swf Exhibit F - A Little Too Late Studio [flash=450,370]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mhCAqvjmZYs.swf Live [flash=450,370]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b24MNB45x2U.swf Exhibit G - Almost Here Studio [flash=450,370]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oDXthcIBDPM.swf Live [flash=450,370]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8mHzZPeHTq4.swf The Controller
June 18, 200619 yr The version of BTT from TOTP you used as an example is the weaker of the two available TOTP versions. The solo version should have been linked as it completely destroys the over-echoed studio take. OOTB from Visualise is also a lot stronger than the emasculated TOTP version. NMNI should have been the one from Luna Park Melbourne with the LWY coda and the amended lyric. With AH Delta always seems to sing a slightly different melody live. It makes you wonder whether it's really her on the single. lol
June 18, 200619 yr She usually sounds better in the studio but with TWAO she sounded fantastic live and the studio version was a bit of a disaster imo :P Love, Kirsty xx Edited June 18, 200619 yr by Miss Analyst
June 18, 200619 yr how have u heard her live for together we are one? she hasnt performed TWAO live yet!
June 18, 200619 yr I went for Studio but I love live versions too :). Watching live perfromances on TV is not as good as the studio version...but if I was actually there experiencing the live performance I would probably prefer it to studio version :).
June 18, 200619 yr Author I really can't decide if TWAO was live or not. It was a stunning performance and I was shocked at how perfect it was, until I heard all the miming rumours, but even watching it back I think it was live as it was flawless if mimed. She's also denied that it was mimed...
June 18, 200619 yr Studio-her voice can be weak live at times (sorry). The studio versions are usually nothing short of breathtaking
June 18, 200619 yr I think that delta sang TWAO live apart from the big high note area but if she did sing it all live, well done delta it was great :D
June 18, 200619 yr I voted studio, but she is gr8 live, and yeah i really don't know if Delta sang TWAO live, like she didn't do the bridge live and....errr i dunno, bout the rest of the song, like I kinda think she didn't sing and distinct vocals live but only back up and thats why she was able to say she didn't mime....but Delta still is gr8, and she is the bst, so i don't really care!! But also i might just add to this already long post that Delta may not have been allowed sing live at the commenwealth because the whole thing HAD to go off perfectly but she would have if she could have! But i think only Delta knows......lmao
June 19, 200619 yr hmmmmmm im confused lol! i saw her in her visualise concert and she was incredbile LIVE!
June 19, 200619 yr i think with twao she sang it live but was overpowered with the background music/prerecorded. she would have been singing but all that was heard was the recorded version. which is not too bad because the games are very important and if she sang totally live (with out the safety of the pre recorded) she would have made a fool out of her self if she got nervs and sang out of pitch eg.out of the blue aria's performance..... i voted recorded, even though she sings wicked live. lnoe is better live.........
June 19, 200619 yr also i think her voice has become stronger after cancer/maturing. when she sings lwy now for example it is stronger and has a different sound to pre cancer. pre cancer delta was only 17 and her voice was 'weak' i didnt think so at the time but now i have heard her since she has become better
June 19, 200619 yr hmmmmmm im confused lol! i saw her in her visualise concert and she was incredbile LIVE! I find it hard to comment as I've never seen her live in concert and its hardly the same basing it on live recordings as you don't feel the atmosphere of being at the concert...
June 19, 200619 yr Author I've always found her weak live and she never seems to flex her voice. MI at Visualise I thought was very poor as she didn't sing the bit where her voice goes all high and squeaky and I thought it was very pantomime-ish which made it worse as it's quite a serious song
Create an account or sign in to comment