Jump to content

which best of will be you buying first? 17 members have voted

  1. 1. U2 v Oasis - the most essential CD Collection?

    • U2
      8
    • Oasis
      9
  2. 2. will you be buying both?

    • yes
      5
    • no - only U2
      4
    • no - only Oasis
      5
    • neither
      3
  3. 3. which release is more of a ultra cash-in for christmas?

    • U2
      16
    • Oasis
      1

Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Featured Replies

Posted

On November 20th Oasis and U2 both release new best ofs collections.

 

so will you be getting them?

 

and if you've got all the albums by Oasis and/or U2 how much of a fan are you? will you buy these as well?

  • Replies 21
  • Views 2.2k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • Author

Ohhh and yes....I've bought 2 copies of Robbies GH album because they had different covers :rolleyes: ;)

 

lets hope you dont get q over there and are a fan of all the acts on the cover.

 

thats gonna be an expensive month for you

Didn't U2 do TWO Best Of compilations just a few years back....? Have they been deleted or summat?? If not, just what the fukk is the justification for yet another one.....? <_< Island's coffers needing another cash injection are they....? :angry:

 

I do believe that this will be Oasis' first compilation/collection, so this is certainly more justified.....

 

But I will be buying neither.... I have U2's first four or five albums, that's frankly all the U2 I need....

  • Author

Didn't U2 do TWO Best Of compilations just a few years back....? Have they been deleted or summat?? If not, just what the fukk is the justification for yet another one.....?

 

dont think they have been deleated?

 

however dont know if its gonna be like the depeche mode one or a continuation of the 1980-1990 and 1990-2000 one. then again 2000 - 2006 thats a bit stupid, should have waited till 2010, unless they are gonna split up as bono has got a job as the new Pope :lol:

I am well pissed off with U2 about this Greatest Hits :angry:

 

They have only released 1 bloody album since there last GH <_<

 

It's just a complete cash in but WHY?? They don't bloody need the money :rolleyes:

 

Unlike Oasis, U2's record company certainly would'nt be forsing them to release this which makes it ever worse -_-

 

Oasis clearly don't want to release a Best of but are being forsed -_-

 

They are my 2 all time favoute bands but I think the Oasis is more essential cause it's their first best of whilst this will be U2's 3rd in a matter of years :wacko:

Been want an Oasis 'best of' for a while.

U2 seem to make to many tracks I would prefer not to hear over and over.

So Oasis for me.

 

It's just a complete cash in but WHY?? They don't bloody need the money :rolleyes:

 

 

Because they're essentially just a bunch of money whores at the end of the day, no matter what Bono tries to say otherwise.... I reckon you're right, somehow I doubt Island had to twist their arms too much....

 

Because they're essentially just a bunch of money whores at the end of the day, no matter what Bono tries to say otherwise.... I reckon you're right, somehow I doubt Island had to twist their arms too much....

 

Well yes, as much as I love their music and live shows, I do think Bono is money whore. I mean why else release a Greatest hits after only 1 album after the last <_<

 

But apperently Bono does'nt spend an awful lot of money out of his estimated £600 million fortune :rolleyes:

 

I respect them for not releasing their first best of untill 20 years into their carear but this is rather annoying -_-

im a bigger u2 fan than oasis but love both but i think the u2 is abot of cash in album considering they have already done 2 greatest hits in the last few years,this however is oasis first greatest hots release

U2 - it will contain two new tracks (but I will probably download the new tracks)

Neither - I have all their albums of both acts, so I will not be buying.

U2 - this is Oasis' first Best Of unlike U2.

Which will sell more do you think? :unsure:

 

I reacken Oasis but then again U2 will have 2 new track :unsure:

  • Author

Which will sell more do you think? :unsure:

 

 

id say oasis too

 

 

My opinion is:

 

Neither

 

Neither

 

U2

 

but I couldn't register that as a vote because you have to choose an option from the 1st part.

 

 

 

 

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.