Melancholia

I hate to think how they'll cut a 6 minute masterpiece down to 2 mins!

Honestly the lack of success could be karma for her ignorant behaviour the last year or so. Plus the song is bland.

So you find my comment "boring" but have no issue whatsoever with the one calling her "awful"? :rolleyes: and my comment stands the BIG pop culture moments are mainly remembered because of her, even now with the white clothing obsession she is in people's heads.

She's the reason they have the legacy. The most iconic moments were because of her!

It's the best Christmas song so it deserves to be played a lot at this time of year.

She was in the Trollied Christmas special in 2013 and had that one-off comedy called 'Life Sucks'

Here for Mariah to be #1 for the whole festive period tbh

Old topic, but no damn way could they have carried on. The group members themselves weren't in a good place and the public didn't like the new image and sound.

Good on Cliff. His fans clearly have turned out.

In 2016 she did the "Star Boot Sale".

A YouTube short of the Mama performance from a VHS-rip.

They do treat the fans like crap. I'm shocked at how badly they or their team have handled this whole year.

Rather have the Taylor track than the awful Meghan one. She seriously hasn't evolved at all since All About That Bass has she?

The Christmas merch they've put up is truly awful isn't it?

This is usually so those listening to the songs (the label) are aware that particular track is still in it's early stages and will have changes.

Geri is an incredible writer, even during the groups peak she wrote stories and was the main writer in their songs. Don't be so horrible.

She also sang backing vocals on the Mel B (was Melanie G at the time) b-side 'Sophisticated Lady'

One of the best pop songs released this year deserves a lot longer, I think. :P

Same and honestly Geri finally playing Wembley Stadium felt like closure and it was joyous. Glastonbury would be the big thing to finish with.

Yes please. Emma especially has done so many random things here and there, I'd be intrigued to see the timeline.

I've lurked this board a while and have noticed you do seem to stick up for their team a crazy amount. If you are just another fan, surely you could see the mistakes they've made and how poor the release was in every way? Yes the girls could've vetoed demos, but that's no excuse for the poor quality live audio or the lack of variation when it comes to the remixes or using fan created content for t-shirts/posters and the booklet! It's disgustingly overpriced, cheaply produced and lazily prepared. and "opened the vaults"... perhaps for Spice25, but for this era they clearly didn't. They haven't even used any of Christophe Gstalder's outtake album photoshoot imagery!!

Mel also featured on an ITV show 'Seven Days On The Breadline' in 2009