It's a crazy world when the serial adulterer and convicted felon is more popular in the midwestern bible belt than the married baptist former District Attorney.
Unfortunately, 90-95% of people don't care about policy when it comes to choosing who to vote for. They might care about the impact of policies after the fact- how much money they have, how public services function etc but ultimately when it comes to voting they want a good narrative with punchy soundbites, whether policies feature there or not is irrelevant, it just needs to sound good. There's no room for nuance in electoral politics, by all means parties should 100% should put all the nitty gritty details in paperwork and manifestos and the like, and expand on it in if asked in interviews, but people want to hear certain, simple, clear messages. As abhorrent as Trump is, he can do this remarkably well (building walls, deportations, ending wars - doesn't say how because he has no clue, but it's simple and cuts through) despite often being completely incoherent (especially recently) he's very brash and confident about it. Bernie Sanders was capable of cutting through the bullshit and offering people a real alternative, speaking to the needs of the people when it came to the things they cared about, he offered something both popular and effective- universal healthcare, better working conditions and higher minimum wage for example. I genuinely think if he had been selected in either 2016 or 2020 he would have won, and if we were living in the good timeline, we would just be coming to the end of an 8 year Sanders presidency that would have transformed politics for the better, not just in America but internationally. I've read "It's Ok To Be Angry about Capitalism" and genuinely, it's incredible- I strongly recommend. Sadly, we're here.
Harris had some good lines, attacking republicans for being "weird" (though that was more Walz, one of the best parts of the campaign), "not going back" was good, but all the momentum died before the summer did when she stopped. Calling Trump a fascist, while accurate, just feeds the narrative that the median voter has of "the left calling everyone a nazi" (nevermind such ideologies are actually on the rise but I digress)- and she didn't offer a meaningful alternative. The nail in the coffin was completely failing to distance herself from Biden, who has become increasingly unpopular with the left over Gaza amongst other things, and trying to cosy up to the right on immigration and promising to create bipartisan committees if she won, alienating the left and attempting to appeal to Trump leaning voters by going Trump lite on those issues.. but if they liked those ideas why wouldn't they just go for the full version? Trump ran a terrible incoherent campaign but it didn't matter, he offered "change" from the unpopular status quo and has an extreme core of cultish voters who would crawl through glass to vote for him to make their lives worse.
Frankly, Labour has a lot of the same issues as the Dems, they just got lucky that a) they weren't the incumbent party, the Tories were supremely unpopular after Truss' budget directly and obviously destroyed the economy and voter's confidence, b) they were viewed as the main opposition and therefore were the main opposition and c) Reform split the right wing vote because of our system, finally restoring the balance of the left wing vote always getting split between Lib Dems, Labour and Greens (and SNP in Scotland). LD and Greens also learnt to target seats really effectively instead of just diluting the left wing vote, leaving other seats open for Labour. Point is, like lots of people have said, Labour weren't popular, the main thing they had going for them was "not Tories" which isn't sustainable long term. I really hope that over the next few years they can not only improve things but learn to present their ideas in a way that really appeals to voters, or maybe another left wing party does and we get a coalition. That said, I don't see Badenoch winning any elections any time soon, especially with reform diluting the Tory vote, but then people said Trump was unelectable in 2016- you don't have to be competent to win. Side note, I remember when May was in when Trump was last time and the one time she said him retweeting Britain First was "wrong" and Trump had a meltdown in response, amazing how far they've moved over since with Badenoch now ecstatic at this result. May was hardly an inspiration but you really don't know what you've got until it's gone I guess, at least within the confines of that awful party.
If there is indeed an election in 2028 and the USA doesn't become an oligarchy/ plutocracy (well, more of one than it already is) the Dems should win in theory with Trump unable to run again as the only real figurehead the Republicans have, but 4 years is a long time and who knows what damage will have been done in the meantime.