Adam

Show Me deserved top three x

Whoops I didn't read the rules, I only voted Nicky lol. Top three would be Nicky, Gigi and Widow, but Widows definitely benefits from the moves and performance alongside it..

I hope so too, four new songs is so little! the book is okay, I really quite like Oh My God though!

Decency bias definitely strong but I don't DISLIKE any of the recent ones who made it. Vanjie is a fun entertainment entity but doesn't really deserve that high for me. Same with Pearl. I do like Kim and Yara but for this is a weaker five than the five below it, And considering who we lost in that set I can't believe we lost another in Shangela, who I adore. People outside this forum will think us mad lol

I agree with most people that I really didn't want any of them to leave, they all brought something. It was especiallly so because my favourite was Heidi, who arguably was the most in line to leave, and my least favourite Widow, and how can you deny the absolute POWER she wiped the floor with them in the challenge with.. Heidi - an absolute angel, so hilarious, wasn't convinced on her entrance as it seemed very copied from Mercedes? But I was expecting her to bomb the runways after what she wore to enter, but I thought both fall and spring despite the problems were great, so was the dress in her main runway just not the head up. But so much potential ENERGY. Nicky - the biggest surprise, her fall look was DIVINE, she coped well enough for me in the girl group and her confesssionals I thought were superb, Mayhem Miller and a lemurian lol. Crystal - I'm not sure on the fully pink or orange face make up BUT I really appreciated her creativity and thought she was adorable, especially when she said she was known as the dancing diva lol. Gigi - I wasn't sure about her and she has such striking features that it's hard to look soft but I really like that she seems to have much more depth than your average fashion girl. Her RedOne moment in the lipsync make me scream. Jackie - SO hot and I think going a long way, that said, I am not that sold on her retro looks. Her fall one showed promise but I thought the spring one was quite basic? Defiiitely potential though. Brita - I think in it for the long run too, but did nothing this episode that was WOW. I do think she has a good energy but if any of them has to leave off the back of that I would choose Brita, Widow - I found her quite abrasive in her boy chats but no doubting that performance, and even if the lipsync was too much, she's made her mark fully. I didn't mind her beige look but I thought the Missy one was so bad, lol. My top five looks 01. Nicky - fall look 02. Gigi - spring look 03. Crystal - fall look 04. Nicky - runway look 05. Gigi - entrance look

A few absolute powerhouses falling there! Surprising. I get why Aja took a jump, I liked them a lot on AS, but realistically not top thirty.

I fully Stan so expect high scores 07.5 If This Is Love 10 Up (Radio Edit) 08 Issues 07 Just Can't Get Enough 09 Work 08.5 Forever Is Over 08 Ego 10 Missing You 09.5 Higher (feat. Flo-Rida) 09.5 Notorious 11 All Fired Up, honestly perfection 09 My Heart Takes Over 06 30 Days 07 What About Us (feat. Sean Paul) 08 Gentleman 08.5 Disco Love 09.5 Not Giving Up 06.5 What Are You Waiting For?

I really like it, its imperfect but catchy af

Yeah I didn't get Saara from it at all, nor from Splish Splash, and I've seen Saara multiple times!

You say bitterly, and maybe, but why would he pick somebody has told him there's no chance? (And absolutely no shade to her for doing that, I just don't know why you'd then expect him to keep her), surely even if the other option was a 1% shot for you, that's preferable!

I don't want Mercedes back but fully agree on that Work Bitch lipsync she absolutely killed it.

I think she's very simple though. How has she not realised that if they never had the chat then she would have done exactly to Rebecca what Rebecca did to her? I don't really like either of them but it was good drama. I think they'll just about keep Sophie. And she will stay.

Yeah no Courtney's voice is... nowhere near as pleasant.

Tati and Alexis are my favourites here, both are solid with great moments. Sasha I do think was solid throughout her season but never made me LOVE her. Val has her moments but I've never got the total hype with her, and Cracker at times actually made me uncomfortable with how stilted she is... though I do see potential there.

I voted for Jess in the dates vote if that means anything.

As a huge fan of Saara, I grew to love Hamish, he still even turns up at her gigs. It's hard to feel like he was the problem.

Let Me Down Slow is actually really solid.

Completely agree. The weakest of the new ones but still nice.

How come a song from 2016 (Miss You) has ended up on here?

Yasss I love Alec, he hasn't released a bad song, Mind Is A Prison was gorge. I was at his London gig too, or one of them, so solid.

I love Shuga but that is definite recency bias! Completely agree she shouldn't have even been close to bottom that week though. Robbed. Naomi I got a new found love for on AS, she was so sharp and funny in a way I didn't see before. Violet going this early is a surprise, I too was shocked at the time as I thought Ginger deserved but even though she's not my cup of tea I do appreciate her more with time. Tammie is just bonkers but fun.

THE SONGS: 07.0 A Moment Like This 10.0 Miss Independent 07.0 Low 06.0 The Trouble With Love Is 09.5 Since U Been Gone 11.0 Behind These Hazel Eyes 09.5 Because Of You 09.0 Walk Away 08.0 Breakaway 07.5 Never Again 05.0 Don't Waste Your Time 07.0 Sober 08.0 My Life Would Suck Without You 08.5 I Do Not Hook Up 10.0 Already Gone 08.0 Don't You Wanna Stay (w/ Jason Aldean) 08.0 Mr. Know It All 08.5 Stronger (What Doesn't Kill You) 10.0 Dark Side 08.0 Catch My Breath 07.5 Don't Rush (w/ Vince Gill) 08.0 People Like Us 10.0 Underneath the Tree 07.0 Wrapped In Red 08.5 Heartbeat Song 07.0 Invincible 08.5 Second Hand Heart (w/ Ben Haenow) 08.5 Piece By Piece 08.0 It's Quiet Uptown 10.0 Love So Soft 07.0 Christmas Eve 08.0 I Don't Think About You 07.0 Heat 09.0 Never Enough 06.0 Broken & Beautiful

I definitely think some voters are just picking their favourite as opposed to who won the lipsync! Of all the ones on the list you can attribute an actual winner to the lipsync, Monet beat Trinity HAAAANDS down. Those I think were worthy of a double Shantay the most: Sharon & Phi Phi and Eureka & Kameron... I really don't think Eureka is given enough credit for this one, she puts her whole self into it.. the moment she SMACKS the ground is pure I Want To Stay Energy Those I think worthy of a double Shantay but I could pick a winner: Alyssa v Tati (Tati was the winner for me though), Brooke & Yvie (Yvie won because I didn't expect it of her) Those I think worthy of a double Shantay because they were both same level not because both were exceptional: Monet & Manila, Raven & Juju, Shangela & Ben - difficult one because Shangela had all the ideas but Ben just copying her was comedy gold, Those I think one person should have won: Monet beating Trinity Roxxxy beating Alyssa Darienne beating Ben Farrah beating Cynthia And I feel like Eureka and Aquaria might have been a double Sashay if it wasn't the final. Carmen and Yara I don't remember well enough.

I'm so surprised at Alyssa. But not sad. She definitely has something but I always think she is overrated Nina is an excellent queen, as is Courtney, Monique is far less polished but very likeable, and Ongina is one of my faves. Bring her back!

Yeah those three are all pretty great in their own way. Chi Chi was so sweet on All Stars, and I'd definitely like to see the other two return, particularly Peppermint.