Jump to content

Alcohol_Prone

Members
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Alcohol_Prone

  1. A campaign to have another song at No.1 isn't wrong, but for people to blatantly break chart rules by downloading the same track dozens of times, use vouchers/promotions that they are not entitled to, those from OUTSIDE THE UK being able to influence who gets the UK No.1 by downloading as well, people going into shops and sabotaging sales of another product by hiding/covering it up - THIS IS ALL WRONG. FWIW, I don't actually like The Climb and would prefer something else to be No.1, but if the amount of people who actually pretended to give a f**k had acted in a manner which complied with chart rules then there wouldn't be a question of who was No.1 - the result would be guaranteed. And the Facebook campaign has been all above board, has it? If the commercialist aspect is what you're getting at, this one campaign isn't going to change what supermarkets stock, or what radio stations play. These are far greater issues on what controls the charts.
  2. You could say the same about the people who jumped on the RATM bandwagon and decided it was the song they were going to buy, even though they hadn't heard it. It was more the name of the band and the nature of the campaign rather than what the song sounded like.
  3. Bookies Paddy Power is now offering 2/1 on ANY OTHER act for No.1 amidst fears that Joe and RATM will be pulled from the chart.
  4. Surely not... FkkdkQ6XJ80 :lol: :lol: :lol:
  5. Yes, though I think they will play the censored version. I never said it wasn't a good song, though not everyone is downloading because of the song. The campaign has succeeded because of what the song and the band stand for, but you can't deny this hasn't been helped by the anti-Cowell stuff and the swearing in it.
  6. No other song would have come close to getting the same amount of people joining a Facebook group as KITN has, but that isn't necessarily because it's a good song - most people like it because of the name, the agenda against X Factor, and because of a guy swearing. It's a pity that the same amount of people won't get behind an actual Christmas song, but that'd be a non-starter because they won't get to act "cool".
  7. Some overseas members are getting round that though and it IS counting. My point still stands; too many people pretend to care but don't actually do something about it. Even if everyone living in the UK who had signed up to the campaign had downloaded the track just the once, then people living overseas wouldn't have to get involved and no-one would have to download the track dozens of times to give it a chance of the No.1. It would be guaranteed already.
  8. If everyone who signed up to the Facebook group actually downloaded the track then it wouldn't matter what Cowell did - RATM would easily be No.1 on Sunday.
  9. I never said people didn't buy multiple copies of physical singles, but I don't think it would be to the same extent of buying if the RATM song was only available on physical. It is easy for someone to just sit there at a computer and download the same track dozens of times than actually go out and buy it in a shop. There should be measures in place to stop people who buy more than one copy of something having all the sales contribute to the chart, and download sites should share sales data so that people aren't able to download the same track dozens of times. People supporting the RATM campaign go on about the charity when they are confronted about mass downloading, so can they not just download the track the once and donate what they would have spent on other downloads to Shelter, or is that not rebellious enough for them? I'm not saying downloads are all bad, but people will only buy what they are listening to, and that is pretty much the same thing as stations continue to play the same music over and over again - at least with X Factor there is a variety. The Big Top 40 manipulates people into thinking that those 40 songs are the most popular and highest bought songs of the week, but it only gets its data from one source (Itunes), physicals aren't included (to stop uncool acts getting in the chart rundown) and airplay stats are included (surely not an indication of what people are buying?).
  10. X Factor is only what TOTP was in its day. That too only gave a small number of acts a platform every week, but the influence on the charts is much greater here because people don't have to trek to a shop to own the song. It may give artists like Journey who wouldn't be in the charts anyway a boost as a result of a contestant performing their song, but the bigger problem for me are songs that are overplayed on radio and stay in the charts for weeks because stations stick to the same playlist. Stations offer very little in the way of diversity in the fear that people will turn off if they're not hearing a familiar artist or song every five minutes. WHIT??? DESERVED??? People downloading the same song three times from each online retailer, repeating that process across several sites, blatantly carrying it out because they have been told that they can get away with it, and that is "deserved"? Sorry, but it is chart-rigging whatever way that you look at it. I wouldn't have so much of a problem if the 800,000 people who actually joined the Facebook group downloaded the song just the once to prove a point. I agree. At least with a physical single it is off the shelves within a couple of weeks, but a download enables people to buy the same song week after week and it still counts towards the chart. The Xmas re-entries are a blessing to what would otherwise be a very boring chart, but they have been bought by the same people a year earlier. Downloads are more susceptible to chart-rigging because no-one has any way of knowing who is buying what, and how many - you would be found out pretty easily if you tried to buy dozens of the same single from shops across town. There needs to be more sharing of sales figures and where they come from across download sites, so that people aren't allowed to manipulate the charts to this extent.
  11. I was fully behind the campaign to start with, and have no reason to believe that whoever is running it is being paid for it, but when I hear of people downloading the RATM track dozens of times because nowhere near all of the people who promised to buy it have actually done so, I find myself not really caring if it makes No.1 on Sunday. If whatever the amount of people only downloaded the track just the once I would see it as a victory over X Factor, but the sales figures are being heavily manipulated with people being told that they are allowed to buy so many times from each online retailer, and are further exploiting this loophole by using different email addresses, card details, etc every time they do it. I have to admit the campaign has been very well run, and no other song would have come close to getting the same backing, but it's gotten out of hand now. Anyone who thinks there can be a regular occurrence of this (i.e. next Christmas vs the X Factor), then they can think again. Most of the people who are involved this time won't keep on spending their money on something they really aren't bothered about anyway (the charts), and there won't be another song that will match up to the anti-Cowell, rebellious nature of KITN. For all people say that they want an actual Christmas song at the top of the charts despite the fact that there have been tons released in the last five years, they don't actually want it because a Christmas record would be cheesy and fun for everyone, instead of "cool" and sweary words abound, which is one of the main reasons this campaign has been so successful.
  12. I think it is a coincidence. It's no surprise why he went for Rick Astley last year, then RATM this year. For these campaigns to work you have to have a gimmick to keep people interested, and the whole anti-Cowell / anti-commercialist angle has paid off. No-one cared last year if Sony were getting the money for the multiple versions of Hallelujah in the charts, and it's the same this year - it's all about the No.1. If he picked a Christmas song to promote then it wouldn't have got anywhere near the same backing because it's just a Christmas song, and no matter how good it is there's no angle there. Even if that had been on Sony, would you have still accused of him getting paid for promoting it? No, it's because of how well run a campaign it is and the attention it has received that you suspect it could only be the work of someone bigger or higher up in the music industry. Were those who promoted Jeff Buckley in any way affiliated with Sony? Be careful you don't pick a Sony act or you'll be accused of getting brown envelopes passed your way. :teresa:
  13. The 40p minimum is the DEALER price (the amount Amazon pay for the track), not the RETAIL price. Amazon can charge what they want for a track and it still counts towards the chart.
  14. Muppets and Gaga are out there to make as much money as they can, which is one of the reasons why some people are against X Factor having the Christmas No.1. That and the fact that the race for the Christmas No.1 shouldn't be as clear-cut and predictable as it has been for the last four years. No.1's in the past haven't been musical brilliance but about novelty and something diverse, instead of cover versions of songs that have already been successful in the charts. If the X Factor is as good as it is made out to be, why can't they have an original winner's song? The answer is that they won't make as much money because it has no history to it. The same reason why Lucie and Danyl were put in the bottom two this series, even though they were the best performers on the night on each of their songs - because the public want to hear something tried and tested. As I said, if the protest is to be anti-commercialist then Muppets and Gaga aren't the way to go. Disney have fast-tracked a single release purely and simply to make money, and Gaga is played all the time on radio. RATM was chosen partly because of the band's anti-commercialist ways, but equally partly because of the name of the band and the name of the song. Those behind the campaign tried last year with Rick Astley and failed, so this time they had to come up with something which sounded better, more rebellious and was more of a personal attack towards Cowell - so Rage Against The Machine (Cowell) was it. It may be a gimmick, but it's no more gimmicky than a bunch of puppets singing along to a Queen song, or a girl climbing out of a bathtub to perform her latest single. So what if the guy ran a similar campaign on Facebook last year? It wasn't the one that had the majority of people getting behind it, so because he's doing it this year again shouldn't be cause to suspect him of benefitting himself or a record company. I have run campaigns in the past to get songs into the charts, but it wasn't about me or anyone else getting financial rewards.
  15. My first post on this thread, but for anyone that says that a big hitter should have been picked or "download The Muppets instead", isn't that the point of why people are against the X Factor having the Christmas No.1 in the first place? It's the only time of the year when having a No.1 means something more because it is Christmas - a time when anything should have a chance at the top spot and it isn't necessarily about making money. X Factor completely destroys any notion of a fair chart battle. Backing Gaga, Robbie or even the Muppets for No.1 wouldn't be making a very good case because they too are only in there to make money, and are played on radio all the time. RATM aren't mainstream and are available to download as a result of the band wanting their fans to have access to their music, and not about them wanting to make money. They are an ideal candidate to protest against the X Factor. They may not be everyone's cup of tea, but they are about the only non-commercialist artist that could have gathered the support needed to have any chance at the No.1. Whether that's because it's all in the name is up for debate, but it's no different to the gimmicks that the other artists I mentioned use to sell their records. As much a con as the Big Top 40 is, making people think those 40 songs are the most popular songs that week, when they don't include physical sales and instead use airplay figures for stations that make money from playing those songs. Don't get me started on downloads - as much a positive they have been to the charts in that they have boosted sales, someone can download the same song in multiple weeks and it gets counted every time. If singles were still only available on CD, I don't think people would be in such a rush to bulk buy with the amount of CD's they would end up with! Music is so disposable nowadays and people download willy-nilly without thinking about what they are buying. Shows like X Factor exploit people, and shouldn't end up with honours such as the Christmas No.1 because of it.
  16. Alcohol_Prone posted a post in a topic in UK Charts
    Can anyone confirm if a band is able to sell singles at gigs, and those sales would count towards the chart?
  17. Alcohol_Prone posted a post in a topic in UK Charts
    Perhaps we should start a campaign to get Who's Crying Now (also by Journey) to No.1?
  18. N/A

    Alcohol_Prone posted a post in a topic in UK Charts
    N/A
  19. Rolf Harris with Rick Parfitt from Status Quo - Christmas In The Sun (Nov 29) http://www.amazon.co.uk/Christmas-In-The-S...037&sr=1-18
  20. N/A

    Alcohol_Prone posted a post in a topic in 20th Century Retro
    N/A
  21. N/A

    Alcohol_Prone posted a post in a topic in 20th Century Retro
    N/A
  22. N/A

    Alcohol_Prone posted a post in a topic in UK Charts
    N/A