Tim

Vogue 23- Oh Father 30+ You Must Love Me 20 Frozen 27 Beautiful Stranger 34

Vogue 23- Oh Father 29+ You Must Love Me 20 Frozen 27 Beautiful Stranger 35

Final Five Week: Sharon on Leona: "Your voice is absolute perfection. You are a young Mariah Carey. But we have Mariah Carey. I want to see Leona" Nice to know someone realises Mariah does not need replacing. (And what was with changing the lyrics to 'Lady Marmalade'? "Sleep with me" in French is obviously far too rude for our fragile ears.)

Josh thinks 'Mimi' was a bad album. His opinion is void :P

PS They played 'Anytime You Need A Friend' during Robert's "X Factor journey" footage.

1 Rihanna - S.O.S 2 Razorlight - America 3 Red Hot Chili Peppers - Dani California 4 Sandi Thom - I Wish I Was A Punk Rocker (With Flowers In My Hair) 5 Robbie Williams - Lovelight 6 Rogue Traders - Voodoo Child 7 Scissor Sisters - I Don't Feel Like Dancing

Bit of a Tesco Downloads binge: Mary Costa 'I Wonder' Nerina Pallot 'Sophia' and 'Confide In Me' Agnetha Faltskog 'If I Thought You'd Ever Change Your Mind' 911 'Bodyshakin" Bette Midler 'Wind Beneath My Wings' Donna Summer 'I Feel Love' Ryan Adams 'Wonderwall'

Vogue 20 Secret 5- Oh Father 28+ You Must Love Me 25 Frozen 25 Beautiful Stranger 31

Honey Forever My All Sweetheart

The next vote does it

Vogue 20- Justify My Love 8 Secret 10 Oh Father 28+ You Must Love Me 25 Frozen 25 Beautiful Stranger 18

Vogue 22 Justify My Love 15 Secret 9- Oh Father 26+ You Must Love Me 23 Frozen 25 Beautiful Stranger 14

Vogue 22- Justify My Love 15 Secret 10 Oh Father 25+ You Must Love Me 22 Frozen 25 Beautiful Stranger 15

Maybe that's a good thing? It is a bit sappy and very self-indulgent. Maybe you've just not been conned like the rest of us? (That said, I love it. Though I was 14 when it came out so that may explain why I felt such a connection to it. I was so very angsty then.)

Vogue 23 Justify My Love 15 Secret 9 Oh Father 24 + You Must Love Me 22 Don't Cry For Me Argentina 1 - Frozen 25 Beautiful Stranger 15

Vogue 23 Justify My Love 15 Secret 9 Oh Father 22 You Must Love Me 22+ Don't Cry For Me Argentina 3 - Frozen 25 Beautiful Stranger 15

I thought you were against all re-releases? :unsure: That said, I think the reason it does so well is because it's not on the Best Of albums. If it was, it wouldn't be this huge hit every year. It's now 28! Wham, Shaky, Slade, John & Yoko (etc.) are still yet to chart.

It's because people don't usually say what song they've voted for. Means we don't all gang up on the song likeliest to go.

Do you not love the naff keyboard strings at the beginning?

Vogue 23 Justify My Love 15 Secret 8 Oh Father 22+ You Must Love Me 21 Don't Cry For Me Argentina 5- Frozen 25 Beautiful Stranger 15

Top Ten. I love this song but I'm worried it will get a bit lost in the run-up to Christmas. Is it getting much airplay?

Butterfly Always Be My Baby

Another bloody tie. It's only been a day. This round will stay open until there is a definite loser.

Vogue 19 Justify My Love 14 Secret 4 Oh Father 21 You Must Love Me 20+ Don't Cry For Me Argentina 13 - Frozen 25 Beautiful Stranger 18

Vogue 19 Justify My Love 14 Secret 3- Oh Father 21 You Must Love Me 19+ Don't Cry For Me Argentina 15 Frozen 25 Beautiful Stranger 18