Giselle

^^ Cheers guys! 8.5 What Makes You Beautiful 2 Gotta Be You 5 One Thing 7.5 More Than This 6 Up All Night 6 I Wish 5 Tell Me A Lie 6.5 Taken 7.5 I Want 5 Everything About You 4 Same Mistakes 5.5 Save You Tonight 7 Stole My Heart 5 Stand Up 8 Moments 6 Na Na Na 5 Another World 3 I Should've Kissed You 5 Live While We're Young 8 Kiss You 6 Little Things 5 C'mon, C'mon 4 Last First Kiss 3 Heart Attack 6 Rock Me 5 Change My Mind 5 I Would 3 Over Again 5 Back For You 6 They Don't Know About Us 7 Summer Love 5 She's Not Afraid 5 Loved You First 6.5 Nobody Compares 4 Still the One 6 Truly Madly Deeply 5.5 Magic 5 Irresistible 7.5 One Way Or Another (Teenage Kicks) 6.5 Best Song Ever 8 Story of My Life 8.5 Diana 8 Midnight Memories 9 You & I 8.5 Don't Forget Where You Belong 7 Strong 7.5 Happily 6 Right Now 5.5 Little Black Dress 7 Through the Dark 7 Something Great 5 Little White Lies 6 Better Than Words 5 Why Don't We Go There 5.5 Does He Know? 7.5 Alive 5.5 Half A Heart

Closed? I haven't rated yet! What's the rush?

His spokesman has denied it. I know it was a load of rubbish straightway as what he's allegedly wanting is what they've just done with MM anyway!

Haha same here! I haven't seen This Is Us but have seen some of their video diary stuff and interviews and he's just so unfunny while Harry is just so deadpan funny without trying. And then Louis pokes fun at Harry insinuating that he's boring! SMH.

No - preferred Reggie. Though Scott Mills is the best of the lot; shame he's too old for the permanent gig.

LOL at this result :lol: Everyone knows that Harry is the only one that matters in One Direction. The rest are just bookends.

Stole my heart sounds too much like Taio Cruz's Dynamite, they'd have been laughed out of the charts if they'd released it as a single.

150 Daft Punk feat. Pharrell Williams - Get Lucky 140 Justin Timberlake - Mirrors 130 Robin Thicke feat. T.I. & Pharrell - Blurred Lines 120 Macklemore & Ryan Lewis feat. Wanz - Thrift Shop 110 Lorde - Royals 100 Eminem feat. Rihanna - The Monster 90 Pharrell Williams - Happy 80 John Newman - Love Me Again 70 One Direction - One Way or Another (Teenage Kicks) 60 Icona Pop feat. Charli XCX - I Love It 50 Naughty Boy feat. Sam Smith - La La La 40 Ellie Goulding - Burn 30 will.i.am feat. Britney Spears - Scream & Shout 20 Avicii - Wake Me Up 10 Miley Cyrus - Wrecking Ball -10 Katy Perry - Roar

Yes I do - I play them in my car as I have a bog standard single CD player in my old banger. I buy from amazon and have everything in amazon cloud, then transfer the music to various devices before sending them to their retirement home i.e. my car boot.

Was it? Makes sense then that it wasn't a single. Stuck in the deluxe version - madness!

At the TMH tour they performed 21 songs. I think a good strategy will be half MM and the other half everything else. So 11 from MM. One cover. 5 from UAN, 4 from TMH. Cover: Something like Let it rock by Kevin Rudolf, without the rap (as they're playing stadiums and have enough ballads) From UAN: WMYB I want (as it didn't feature in TMH) Moments More than this One thing or Up all night From TMH: Kiss you One way or another (not technically TMH but from that era) 2 from Cmon Cmon, Rock me and I would From MM: Best song ever Story of my life Midnight memories Diana Don't forget where you belong Alive Happily You and I Little black dress Something great Strong

Has she done something to her lips? Seems so!

Did you miss out Moments from the list? I can't see it. That's the obvious one from UAN - on tour it got the best reaction (I didn't go, but I keep up with their antics via twitter). This continued on the TMH tour. My personal favourite thought from UAN is More than this, which really should have been a single. Moments should have been single number 2, then I want Single number 3 as One thing felt too much like a poor cousin of WMYB. With MTT as the 4th single. God knOws why they only stick to 3 singles. Probably worrying about chart positions :rolleyes: I don't know the non-single songs from TMH as I didn't really care for the 2 lead singles so never really bothered with the album. LWWY was pretty dire though.

Definitely Gotta Be You - the horror (what were they thinking? I see it's been swiftly deleted from their tour setlist, lol)

Yum yum pig's bum. Gorgeous pics!

I'd like to see Harry do stuff with someone else, like Nathan Wanted did. Rihanna will be my first choice and he'd love it as he's a huge fan. For the group I'd say someone like Stromae - would help both artists better penetrate each other's market.

There should be a poll for worst 1D single too! Definitely WMYB - still not tired of it :cheer: Imagine if they'd released the ghastly GBY as their lead single??!

Diana. Does it remind anyone else of a Sting song?

I bought this album a couple of days ago - my first 1D album! I had heard UAN all the way through on youtube, but wasn't tempted enough to buy it. I tried doing the same for TMH but really didn't like any song at the halfway stage and therefore abandoned it. I did the same for MM and liked it so much that I bought it! I never thought I'd buy a 1D album, lol. Harry's voice was 95% responsible for the purchase as it really suits this sort of music. Still early days but faves so far are SOML, Diana, DFWYB, Happily and Alive. I like MM too but it does sound a bit rock-by-numbers, especially now it's confirmed to be a single. Will rate the songs when I've had a few more listens!

I love Harry. For me, One Direction = Harry Styles. Without him they'll be another Union J or District 3 to me. I can't fault him - great raspy voice, looks fantastic, fab personality, great sense of style. Actually I can fault him - those prison tats!! But I've got used to them and now can't imagine him without them. 1D's money-grabbers have missed a trick; they could make available whole albums featuring each member's voice, and I'm sure it'll sell well. I won't say I'm a 1D fan, but as i adore Harry I recently purchased "Midnight Memories" as I've been longing to hear him let loose on rockier, folkier music. I love the songs he features in especially the ones he starts (he makes the annoying "best song ever" listenable) and I never listen to "Through The Dark" as it appears he has no solo on it. A 1D song without a Harry solo? That's like christmas without turkey... can be enjoyable, but there's always a sense of something missing.

I like Niall, and his voice has really improved! It really suits the folky songs. Wish he could find a really good guitar teacher as it'll be great if he could learn to play more than 5 chords. My 2nd favourite member. Great personality!

The worst member. Paper-thin reedy voice, and horrible attitude to match. Used to be funny, now just tries too hard. And whatever happened to his looks? I wish I could pay him to never sing a solo on their 4th album. He can position himself as the group's songwriter, even though we know he probably only changes a word or adds a line. But please, no more solos. I was driving home earlier today listening to "story of my life" and his solo on it is really jarring.

Zayn has become boring and annoying. Even his voice which showed such promise on album 1 and 2 seems too R&B for their new sound. He's way too thin, and those hideous tattoos... He used to be the best looking member to me, but I've downgraded him to a distant 2nd place.

Dumb as f*ck. Have you seen his tweets? Lol. I can't take him seriously, and his voice seems to have got worse over the years. Remember that awesome "cry me a river" audition?

Harry 11 Niall 8 Zayn 5 Liam 1 Louis -1