Jump to content

SilveryWindowHandle

Forum Moderator

Everything posted by SilveryWindowHandle

  1. Oh my at Kate and Fontaines actually being tied btw although since it was a 4-1 judge vote Kate would have been saved anyway regardless of the expanded judge lineup. (Thanks Jim saving it from being a 5-0 vote at least - I had a feeling Pete would be leaning Kate's way this time so my hope was that I'd get yours and Chris' vote again and then one of the other two would hate both of them but give me the lesser of two evils vote although having said that I still don't actually know who Joanne is so maybe I'm mischaracterising ha). Hmph at being marginally closer to being directly out than to being safe though! Really struggling to see past MARINA winning at this stage, she seems to finish near the top every time even with what I feel are weaker picks, and she has some unbeatable options left which are presumably being saved for the final.
  2. Actually I said in my writeup that I don't know what the audience for 'Televised Mind' would be but I have a feeling that could be quite up your street now I think about it! Otherwise I'd definitely recommend starting with Skinty Fia if you do find the time to check out their earlier albums.
  3. Ok let's do some essaying before I lose the motivation to get all my thoughts out (I knew this would be a long post but it's even longer than I expected lmao - hopefully I've covered everything I wanted to say and hopefully some of you don't TL;DR it) x I actually did not have Fontaines D.C. on my radar for a potential Pop Factor act at all until very shortly before the confirmations thread went up! I had long known that I wanted to send a group to the third edition to complete the set having already sent a solo man and a solo woman in the first two, but I'd not really paid a lot of mind to who I'd go for as a group (although I figured it'd probably be someone rather stretching the "pop" aspect no matter who). When it was announced that it was European acts only that threw me a bit as I thought it would be restricting my options even more so I nearly abandoned the idea entirely but I decided to take some inspiration by just looking through my most scrobbled artists on last.fm and seeing what groups were among those. As soon as I spotted Fontaines on there it was a bit of a lightbulb moment because a) I really did think they have at least a good handful of songs that I could pass off as being sort of pop-adjacent while still being true to my alt taste (although more on that later in the post x), b) they were due a new album to drop some time during the edition (although more on that later in the post x [2]) and c) I had also thought when the theme went up that I didn't want to cop out and just send an act from the UK so bingo that they are Irish, albeit Grian Chatten was technically born in Cumbria but shhh (another of their members was actually born in Spain too, fun fact). I thought there was very little chance anyone else would be trying to send them but I did still go into the competition half expecting I'd be denied them as my first pick because yes I was pushing the boat out more than ever before on what can really be considered 'pop' and I apologise for any ruffled feathers on that account (I did feel a little miffed at being singled out as the most non-pop act a couple of times as I'm not sure I'd say they're thaaaat much less pop than the likes of Sam Fender, and I'd definitely put them closer to 'pop' than M83 or Bladee, but still, fair). Thanks Calum falettinme be mice elf agin anyway! I do think it'd have been a very interesting challenge if I'd had to go with my second choice act as it was one whose discography I am less familiar with than the other acts I've sent to Pop Factor so far - I might still give them a shot in a future edition maybe. I think it'd also be a bit remiss of me not to say following last week's discourse that the dismissive comments have not been a one way street, I have thick skin here so I don't care that much but I got more than my fair share of comments directed Fontaines' way that I'd describe as quite dismissive/snobby as well but hey ho! I suppose this forum is those people's turf x Keeping it positive for the rest now anyway. Here's my thought process on the surprisingly many rounds I lasted (I absolutely did not think when I first confirmed that I'd repeat the final result ROSALÍA got, technically doing mildly better since I didn't have to Hail Mary my way through a Wagner round this time). Round 1 (A Lucid Dream) As my artist pick itself was quite a hurried last minute one, so was this song - but I decided I wanted to start with something high energy as a first impression, also didn't want to go with one of their "big" hits right off the bat as I figured there'd probably be at least one no hoper song among the competition to give me free rein to send something a bit less obvious. And I also thought I probably wouldn't get many chances to highlight anything from the 'A Hero's Death' album unless I was forced to by themed rounds - and indeed, even with me making quite a deep run, this ended up being the only song I sent from that album! 10th place for this pick was fair enough I guess (although makes it remarkable that I ended up coming 10th overall when I made such a muted start from the category that allegedly no one cared about). Round 2 (Jackie Down The Line) Look, I heard the criticism early on of me not sending songs with strong melodies. This was, believe it or not, me trying to make an early pivot to appeasing that a bit more. And I just got even more of the same comments oops! The melody on this song is super sticky, don't know what you're all on about. This is still probably one of my top 5 favourite overall songs by them. Boo hiss. Thank god for Wardy saving me from an early exit here by sending that for Vengaboys because this was clearly a miscalculation and could have spelt a very early exit for me. Round 3: 'should have been a single' (Sundowner) After two straight 10th place finishes I was presented with a theme that didn't really feel like it had any non-risky options for me so again I didn't have high hopes for this round and I was almost certain that I was out when it came to results day! So again bless Chez blocking me from last place hehe. I thought it might be best to go with something from 'Romance' for this round as that is their most pop-friendly album overall, but across all of their albums (at least pre-'Dopamine Chamber') I feel that pretty much all of their viable Pop Factor entry songs were singles already - thought this song might be a good one to try and reach out to a different audience as it is very different to the first two songs stylistically, even kicking Grian out of lead vocal duties. Although, I was quite close as well to just saying screw it and going with my favourite album track from them... and that would have been the non-remixed version of 'In Ár gCroíthe Go Deo' (!), so in a universe where that did get them through and I played the rest of the following rounds the same I would have been utterly fucked when it got to the remixes round. (Typing this up is making me realise how lucky I was at quite a few stages in this edition, and we're not done with that yet...) Round 4 (Marianne) No luck here though. I just wanted a round where I felt safe for once after three straight scrapes so an obvious choice, their biggest hit and a song I already knew was popular enough on here that it should sail through. Not a lot to say here. Except that I did think it was neat I represented each of their second through fifth albums, in that order, in the first 4 rounds. Honestly at the time I sent this I was still at the stage where I wouldn't have said it's one of my own favourite songs by them but it's grown on me a lot more since then! (Still the only song from them I didn't put 1st in my own votes though x). Round 5: '(slight) best' / surprise Six Chair Challenge (Where Is Gone? w/ ROSALÍA) Luck back with a vengeance! As has been pointed out already, I've managed to send a song with ROSALÍA to all three editions so far but I can't emphasise enough how much this was unintentional and pure serendipity - at the time I confirmed not only was this song's existence yet to be announced, but Fontaines D.C. had literally never released a collaboration with anyone (apart from a couple of remixes), when the tracklist for 'Dopamine Chamber' dropped I still had to immediately fangirl about this showing up as a very unexpected first choice of collaboration ever from them but I had to hold back my other immediate thought which was 'ok I'm 100% sending this immediately to Pop Factor if I get the chance to no matter what it sounds like' - I'll take any opportunity to promote ROSALÍA more and the iconicness of getting to send her to a third straight Pop Factor edition was not at all lost on me. The song dropped just barely in time to send it to this round (we had the release date for the album of course so I thought I might be waiting one more week - or a bit more than that if I had to keep it for Wagner - but it was dropped as a final pre-album release right on cue). Sooo this was basically locked in as a choice for me even before I listened to it but I had faith it'd be great anyway and indeed it is, great chemistry between ROSALÍA and Grian and a wonderful Bond theme aesthetic. Kind of word salad lyrics but we can excuse that. In a way it's a shame this ended up not being a public voted round but then if it had been I'm not sure it'd have got through to be fair, I know this song has its other big fans (lucky for me I got one as my judge who solely decided its fate!!!) but I can definitely imagine it might have been quite a niche one and got a ton of last place rankings. Round 6: most streamed (Favourite) This was what I would have sent for the round billed as '(slight) best' if my hand wasn't forced by the timing of 'Where Is Gone?' dropping - I thought this and 'Starburster' were their two potential proper big hitters and that 'Starburster' would be a better choice for the Wagner if I needed one. Later results suggest this was probably not the case so maybe I should have saved this as my Wagner instead (not that I could imagine either of them beating 'Enjoy The Silence') but hey ho, another comfortable qualification, cannot complain. Gorgeous song and was delighted this one appealed to a few people who otherwise weren't fans. Round 7: least streamed (You Miss Me) Would you look at this, I got lucky again with the timing of a 'least streamed on Spotify' round dropping literally days after they released a new album, pretty much forcing me to take the loophole route of sending a song that's just not had any time to rack up streams - out of their bottom 10 streamed songs at the time the round went up (minus alternate versions), 8/10 were the newly released album tracks from 'Dopamine Chamber', with the other two being 'I Was Not Born' (a somewhat underrated but nonetheless definitely doomed 'A Hero's Death' album track) and their cover of Sinéad O'Connor's 'Black Boys On Mopeds' from the War Child Records 'HELP(2)' compilation (pleasant cover but no). Sooo I could have probably afforded to play it even safer by sending one of the bigger and more popular album tracks from the new album but I felt a bit bad about being handed such an obvious ticket to the live shows so I decided I'd go for one of the less popular album tracks, although still one of my personal favourites and another one I thought (perhaps misguidedly) could have a bit more pop appeal than say 'Demolition'. The lack of public votes for this round did shake me a bit, and I was even more shaken by a few people predicting this would be out when results came around, but I didn't have much to worry about with this being another 2nd place finish (albeit in a super tight field all around so it could still have gone wrong pretty easily). Funnily enough I think ROSALÍA also never won a round (except for being the joint winner of the Wagner) but came 2nd twice! Round 8: Golden Wagner and I will never acknowledge any other name for it (N/A) First time I've not had to participate in the Wagner. I did not have a 'Berghain' esque deus ex machina card in their discography this time so thank god. As I said already, would have been 'Starburster' here. Round 9 (Starburster) ...so instead I thought I'd play it as my first live show pick just to, in my mind, safely ensure I wouldn't be out in the first live show, there was no umming and ahhing here, I locked it in as my choice the second 'You Miss Me' was announced as safely though. I may have misjudged how wide appealing this song is, or it may just be that no matter how I played I'd be struggling at this stage, but I was pretty disappointed this only came 12th - it's such a banger!!! But it did the job avoiding the bottom 3 so on I went. Round 10: 'club bangers/remixes' (In Ár gCroíthe Go Deo (Orbital Remix)) As you might imagine, Fontaines D.C. don't really have much in the way of 'club bangers' (maybe 'Starburster' could have fit here too if Sam Fender got away with 'Seventeen Going Under' I guess lol), and they only have three officially released remixes. The other two are ones I've never listened to, both of songs from 'A Hero's Death' (the title track and 'Televised Mind'). If I had gone with the original 'In Ár gCroíthe Go Deo' in round 3 I suppose I'd have had to check those out and pick the more viable of the two but as it were this was really my only realistic option. And on paper it's not even a bad one - Orbital are pretty popular on BuzzJack and this very remix was quite a comfortable winner in Club Bizarre (having got my 12 points there, contributing to it denying my own entry a win as I came 2nd in that edition, although I was more than 12 points adrift and Nate who sent Fontaines/Orbital gave me 12 points back anyway so much of a muchness). I do think this is a gloriously intense song in either version so happy to have sent it. Alas, the Pop forum audience is not the same as the Dance forum audience clearly, and this was still another squeaky bum moment being saved by yet another very fortuitous stroke of luck that Calum happened to add a fifth judge to eliminate the possibility of a deadlock which it would have lost, and said new judge happened to be the one giving this its third vote to survive. Round 11 (I Love You) And here we are, I got to the same stage as I got with ROSALÍA last time and got the same outcome as I've said already - this is my personal favourite song by them (as was 'SAOKO' which kicked me out last time) so even though it was tempting fate I simply couldn't not send it especially after how many times I was bailed out in this edition to keep giving me chances to. Still, I didn't think it was that doomed of a choice as it is by some way their most streamed song, and their highest rated song on Album of the Year - but I guess it's one that's definitely not pop and for all that people have bemoaned this allegedly being 'Alt Factor' that ultimately wasn't going to cut it at this stage. Maybe something from 'Dopamine Chamber' could have kept me going but I am at peace with being out now and just happy I got to share this masterpiece, even if it got the same muted reception as usual from many of the usual suspects. This harks back to their roots as a pure post-punk act a bit more than most of the other songs I sent, but also really brings the intensity and some of their cleverest lyrics ('And I'm heading for the cokeys, I will tell them 'bout it all / ''Bout the gall of Fine Gael and the fail of Fianna Fáil') for those who care about that sort of thing. So... what else could I have sent from them? Honestly nothing that I'm truly kicking myself over, you guys indulged me enough to get pretty much all of my big faves through. Album 1: Dogrel Like with ROSALÍA last time, their first album is a world away from even the rest of their discography in terms of viability for a pop contest, so I was never likely to play anything from this era. Unlike with ROSALÍA last time... I have never actually even listened to this album myself. Lol. I've only heard 2 of its singles as far as I know, and of those 'Boys In The Better Land' is a banger, would never have played it unless a themed round backed me into a very particular corner but I guess I can recommend that song at least. I really ought to listen to the album one day as there are plenty of fans who still complain every time they release a new album that it's not just 'Dogrel' 2.0, and being a big post-punk fan myself I'm sure it should be up my street. Probably never will though, being real. x Album 2: A Hero's Death Again, I only ended up sending the one song from this era ('A Lucid Dream' in the very first round). I have listened to this and all of their following albums at least though - from the other singles, 'I Don't Belong' is a beautiful more lowkey moment that I might have sent if we had a 'ballads' or equivalent round, and actually that might have been what I'd have landed on for the next round if I'd still been in. And 'Televised Mind' is also a banger but I'm not sure it'd have much of an audience here at all, it's quite different to everything I did send. There's not that much going on with the album tracks (this is their least popular album and I think that's with good reason) - but if 'Dopamine Chamber' had dropped either a bit earlier or a bit later I'd probably have sent something from this to the 'least streamed' round, probably 'Living In America' as I think that's my favourite album track. Album 3: Skinty Fia This was my favourite of the three albums I'd heard from them prior to this starting, although I think their new album may have just about surpassed it for me just for lacking any real dud songs - 'The Couple Across The Way' from this album is probably my least favourite song I've heard from them and spoils what is otherwise pretty much all killer no filler. I did highlight my 3 favourite songs from this album already - albeit one of them in remixed form - but I'd also have liked to send 'Roman Holiday', 'Nabokov' (would have been quite a polarising one but I think that'd be one of my main recommendations out of songs I didn't send, another stormer) and perhaps the title track and 'Big Shot' if the time felt right for any of them. Album 4: Romance Their poppiest and most successful album, again I shared 3 songs from this era, the two big(gest) singles and 'Sundowner' getting my pick for the album track round. Sorry to Rich and Mango but 'Bug' is not really up there with my personal favourites (not that I don't like it x) so I don't think I'd ever have sent it, it would have been one of my safer options I suppose but would feel inauthentic even moreso than when I sent 'Marianne'! 'Here's The Thing' and 'In The Modern World' on the other hand I think might have got a spin out of the limited options if I somehow did get through any further, and I'd also have liked to play 'Desire' and possibly 'Death Kink' (although that's in a similar category to 'Nabokov'). This album in its deluxe edition also contains what was their only UK top 40 hit prior to the current era in 'It's Amazing To Be Young' - but I don't think anyone was clamouring for me to send that despite its commercial achievements. It was actually quite a bit less popular overall than much of the rest of the album and really just benefited from being the first new release from them after the slowburning success of the album's other singles. I do really like it myself but was never really one I considered sending as I remember it not getting a particularly enthusiastic reception even among their fans on here at the time. Album 5: Dopamine Chamber I also sent 3 songs from this album so a pleasingly even split between their three most popular/viable albums, not entirely intentional there. There are a few other songs here that I could have sent - if it existed in time for the album tracks round I'd definitely have picked something from this over 'Sundowner', perhaps 'Demolition' or 'Mimesis' (although I was kind of purposefully avoiding sending the latter while New Order were still in the contest as it's pretty similar to them stylistically). 'Happy For You' is another stormer for me that I nearly went with instead of 'You Miss Me' in the least streamed round. And then 'Six Shot Morning' is also brilliant, and I guess 'Japan' might have been a smart choice as another more wide appealing pick although again I think it'd be a bit inauthentic for me to go for it when it's one of the weaker songs on the album for me personally (although it has grown on me quite a lot now). I've named almost all of the album now! 'One Man' is probably the only song here that I absolutely would never have sent but even that is better than the lowest points on the previous 3 albums. 'Tongue' I probably also would never have sent, I love it myself but it is kind of just a less good version of 'Starburster' and it's another one I'm aware got a less than glowing reception even from their own fans. There's not really any other notable releases from them outside of their albums, I already briefly touched on 'Black Boys On Mopeds' which is probably the closest thing they have to a significant non-album release. and breathe x
  4. Thanks Rollo - can take that off my list of 'things I said I was going to do but realistically not sure when I'll ever get around to doing them'.
  5. 'Hype' literally doesn't mean anything x (although it's nice to get it sometimes)
  6. Well done whoever sent Darin being the last non UK act standing by the way! And kudos to @DaTilt for surviving through some quite risky picks as already pointed out many times (including by myself) - some of those I did already know anyway, either through popping up at the weekly 80s top 40 hits sessions or in the case of the 'Confusion' remix having been a previous song contest entry, but there were some great discoveries along the way too, 'Crystal' in particular got the honour of being (iirc) the only song I ranked ahead of one of my own picks the entire edition! <3 We can only speculate if they could have made a truly deep run if they'd survived this one more time and you finally brought out the big guns from the next round onwards. Sorry that I just denied you a spot in the overall top 10 but yay for a PB for you nonetheless, 'Careless Whisper' was absolutely robbed last time!
  7. Don't think I could have gotten away with claiming they are European unfortunately! (Although Bearface is Irish...) There's an idea for the future though. (If I ever fancy being eliminated very early) Never felt more clocked
  8. I do find it slightly amusing that for a second edition in a row there were multiple people thinking my act was sent by Jade haha. (Although I think my cover was only kept this time by the fact that there weren't many people speculating about who I sent at all, until it was obvious who mine was anyway!) Jade did guess me correctly before anyone else did iirc but ofc she had the advantage of knowing Fontaines wasn't herself xx
  9. I'll write up a little essay a bit later but I am kind of torn whether or not to be disappointed by being out today - at the start of the round I was 100% expecting this to be an exact repeat of the last season where I go out in the third live show with my actual favourite song from my artist (and... that is what happened indeed, even down to it being a judges' decision, 10th place twice in a row!) but I actually thought I'd got enough high rankings and not-entirely-terrible rankings from those who were never going to rank me highly anyway that I could have avoided the bottom 3 this time. Could be a third time in a row that the judges have gone against the will of the voters unless I am off base? (But fair enough if so, as if it weren't for the judges I would have been out in the last round anyway ) I got to share pretty much all of the songs that I really wanted to anyway so I'm not quite sure what I'd have done if I'd survived any further, can't really complain! (Especially with the vague sounding brief for the next theme round so I guess good that I won't have to think about if I have anything that fits it well hehe). I'll post some more song recommendations in my later essay anyway tho x
  10. I'm most interested to see what from Darin could fit that brief x
  11. Sadge. Well, intrigued to see who it was that sent Fontaines and fooled you all! (I am happy that Kate got through as this song didn't deserve to be the one that knocked her out but these two in the judges' votes were literally my top 2 of the round oop)
  12. Wait are the judges' votes not just based on their ranking?
  13. Did they bring pineapple? x
  14. I was about to say before your edit - this is both Fontaines' most streamed song and probably their most acclaimed (and also their best song imo x) so it still losing out to some mid tier picks from the poppier artists here is really proving that you can't get that far with alt acts here! These two acts/songs should have fairly similar appeal I'd think so the judge decision could really go either way.
  15. Fontaines D.C., Kate Bush and New Order being the bottom 3. Alt Factor in full swing!
  16. The Nanas still having plot armour. Very surprised they're not even bottom 3 here!
  17. Wow, that feels very unexpected again - I thought if there were to be an "Alt Factor" artist in danger of being directly out it'd be Kate Bush, I hadn't really had my eyes on New Order at all. One too many slightly risky choices from them at this stage I guess but I really liked 'Temptation' (more than I remembered) so that's a shame!
  18. I feel a bit more optimistic than I did last time. I don't think I will have come last at least ('Send My Love (To Your New Lover)' was surely quite a safe choice!) so should be matching how ROSALÍA did at worst x
  19. I doubt I'll get around to catching up with the songs I missed from last week in time to vote for tomorrow (there are still 2 previous weeks I've not got around to listening to as well, have got some time off work coming up so I'll try and get caught up x), but I'll vote for 'Take On Me' for the tiebreak.
  20. So it did. I forgot that oop. My memory of Bop Idol songs keeps being exposed as inadequate lately. (looked back and I ranked it 13th there so just short of my votes - I think that was a round I enjoyed a fair bit more overall than the one with the Dido and M83 songs which I voted for but still forgot about before they appeared in Pop Factor. also dug back to the original thread and I see I did include it as a commiseration x)
  21. SilveryWindowHandle posted a post in a topic in UK Charts
    1997 #1 Aqua - Barbie Girl 1998 #2 Steps - Heartbeat / Tragedy 1999 #3 A1 - Everytime / Ready Or Not 2000 #4 Artful Dodger - Please Don't Turn Me On (feat. Lifford) 2001 #5 Alicia Keys - Fallin' 2002 #6 Blazin' Squad - Love On The Line 2003 #7 Blazin' Squad - Flip Reverse 2004 #8 Eric Prydz - Call On Me 2005 #9 Sugababes - Push The Button 2006 #10 Bodyrox - Yeah Yeah (feat. Luciana) 2007 #11 Craig David - Hot Stuff (Let's Dance) 2008 #12 P!nk - So What 2009 #13 Chase & Status - End Credits (feat. Plan B) 2010 #14 Nelly - Just A Dream 2011 #15 Kelly Clarkson - Mr. Know It All 2012 #16 Disclosure - Latch (feat. Sam Smith) 2013 #17 Fatboy Slim and Riva Starr - Eat, Sleep, Rave, Repeat (Calvin Harris Remix) (feat. Beardyman) 2014 #18 Parra For Cuva - Wicked Games (feat. Anna Naklab) 2015 #19 R. City - Locked Away (feat. Adam Levine) 2016 #20 Jonas Blue - By Your Side (feat. RAYE) 2017 #21 J Balvin and Willy William - Mi Gente 2018 #22 James Arthur - Empty Space 2019 #23 Harry Styles - Lights Up 2020 #24 Meduza - Paradise (feat. Dermot Kennedy) 2021 #25 Juice WRLD - Already Dead 2022 #26 Stormzy - Firebabe (feat. Debbie) 2023 #27 Chase & Status - Selecta (feat. Stefflon Don) 2024 #28 One Direction - Night Changes 2025 #29 Gorillaz - Feel Good Inc. (feat. De La Soul) 2026 #30 STELLA LEFTY - Boston Gross. Was not far off this almost being right... 'No Scrubs' at #31 is a 27 year throwback (and 'Not Over Yet' at #37 is a 31 year throwback).
  22. That would make sense then! (and there are only a few websites that are set up to embed on here so those recap links aren't going to)