Well I loved it, although I'm inclined to agree with those who preferred the Original film.
Some of the gags in Dead mans chest seemed a little contrived, such as them all choursing"Captain" every time Jacks name was mentioned, and although Jacks entrance was funny, I still think his entrance 1 was one of the best ever. It is left hanging a bit and I can't wait now until the 3rd one comes out in May 07 - I think its called Worlds End???
When I went to see the second one there were even people dressed as pirates in the cinema (one of them even had a plank with him, which made me feel quite sane :D )
I'll definitely want to see it again, just to see if I can spot any clues to the plot that I missed first time around