Martin.

It is in my opinion...and there are people out there who have said much worse about it. And um, so what?! I don't care what music it is. That's no excuse for her to be lending her vocals to cheap trash like that.

Naw, you included in the seven too. One of 'em dropped out because they thought it was "Fallin" by Alicia Keys.

You and seven other people. That type of music doesn't suit her raw, soulful vocals and dressing like a $2 ho isn't her either. And she was a member of one of Britain's biggest girl group. How the HELL did she fall so hard? I do feel for her. It must be tough being popular one minute and barely recogniseable the next.

No one is going to take notice when you're dressed like a tramp singing awful songs like "Falling". A break would be good for her. Re-group her thoughts and make a good record. No more reality TV and cheap/tacky singles/videos. But like I said - no one cares about any of the Sugababes solo. Keisha has a shot depending on the production & collaborations. But I'm not even sure about that. Time will tell.

She won't quit. Let's call this "taking a break from music" instead. She's probably fed up of flopping and it's getting to her. Can't say I blame her.

Wow @ them singing the old songs. It just doesn't look right. I have to say though, Jade is the strongest vocalist out of the three. She's good.

Are they promoting this?

I was asking on a technical basis though. Someone can have a nice tone but not be a great vocalist. Or you may not like someone's tone, but they could be a terrific vocalist regardless.

Someone with sense. Thank you. Some of you are just rating on your favourites, which is not what I asked. Siobhan is a better singer, technically speaking, than Heidi. Her voice has more range and depth to it. How the hell they think Heidi is better is beyond me. She can hold a tune, but she's pretty limited (or so it appears from what we've heard of her). Maybe they haven't heard her 'Ghosts' album. I dunno. But ignore the tone, Siobhan, the music style, etc and listen to how she uses her voice, it's obvious this girl isn't a 1/10. WTF?!

yeah, i've been hearing it on the radio quite a few times this week. i guess christmas has arrived...

It was alright, I guess.

Ah, I see. Why do they call her Heidi Beige?

Her name is Heidi Beige? For all these years, I've been thinking it's Heidi Range. Wow.

Y'all really think Siobhan & Heidi are the same vocal range? I think Siobhan displays a more wider range than Heidi, personally. Heidi plays it safe and sticks somewhere in the middle for the most part.

Do you think they could survive another line-up change? Especially if Heidi got her ass kicked out?

That's why I said they need to talk face to face instead of to a camera. Siobhan said they made a lot of quotes up when she first left the group which only added to the animosity between her and Keisha. But I hope this gets sorted out so all parties can move on.

Put your opinions on each lady to one side, how would you rate their vocal ability? Remember, the type of music may not be suited to you...but we're talking about their vocal ability, so it doesn't matter if you like their music/tone or not. * Siobhan Donaghy - 9 * Keisha Buchanan - 8 * Mutya Buena - 9 * Heidi Range - 6 * Amelle Berrabah - 7 * Jade Ewen - 8

I know that, but I'm saying that's typical teenage girl behaviour. Especially when you literally spend 24 hours, 7 days a week with them. I just feel it was unnecessarily exaggerated. I'm sure Siobhan gave as good as she got, too.

The thing regarding Siobhan is a little different to Amelle's. Siobhan & Keisha were kids back then, and I honestly believe that Siobhan felt she was being bullied. I don't believe she said all this for the press or attention because she doesn't care about any of that. She's content with making and releasing music. However, I think because of their age that things were blown out of proportion and girls at that age spending that much time together are bound to get into bitch fights. The media didn't help either and I said right from the break that they need to speak to eachother instead of the press. The wonderful thing - and I really didn't think this would happen - is that they have both met up and have now sorted all that crap out. Siobhan's had the chance to explain how & why she felt she was being picked on and Keisha has had the chance to explain to Siobhan why she didn't like her. Both ladies have crossed a bridge and now wish eachother well in their music career & life. Amelle is a grown ass woman who is probably exaggerating what went down. Keisha probably gave her the stink eye, called her a few names and stopped talking to her, but that isn't bullying. Has Amelle used the word "bullying"? Anyway, I understand Keisha's point. Who wants to be called a bully? Who would work with a bully or someone who causes so much $h!t? I'd be fed up of it too.

They are acting like children. I think all involved need to shut up and not say another word about this mess.

This is all depending on if that article is even true, obviously. I mean, for what it's worth, it's probably false.

And? Siobhan has ACCUSED Keisha of being a bully. JUST like Amelle is doing now. How is that different? The accusation is still the same. Keisha still maintains that she never bullied Siobhan. Now Amelle, too. Yet she's sueing Amelle's ass and not Siobhan's who talked more $h!t about Keisha than anyone.

I know, but Keisha always said she never bullied Siobhan.

I can see Keisha's point. HOWEVER... Siobhan has been calling Keisha a bully for 10 years and Keisha did nothing but deny it (which she had to)...SOOOO, I'm sure there are people out there thinking "why didn't Keisha do anything about Siobhan accusing her if THAT was false too?"...It kinda supports Siobhan's accusations even more. Anyway, I think Keisha is overreacting a little. I mean, Siobhan would call Keisha all the names under the sun. I even read an interview where the guy asked her her thoughts on Keisha and her response was "her name alone makes me want to be sick" (rotfl). I mean, Amelle has said/done NOTHING in comparison to what Siobhan has done over the years.

Yeah, me too. That's not to say it isn't good, because it is and I do like it. I love the dark, moody feel of the song. I just loved the other singles more. "New Year" is my favourite, "Soul Sound" is really nice & mellow and shows off their vocals nicely and "Overload" just goes HARD. I also think the "Overload" video is the best from that era. It was really different and immedietly set them apart from all other girl groups. I'd even go as far as saying it's one of their most iconic. When anyone thinks of "Overload", you think of the video too - just three girls shot against a white background, edited with some nice shots, dressed in jeans & t-shirts. No gimmicks or anything.