OH GOD!!!! lmao

It's a fucking terrible song in its original form, it's only going to be made worse. :(

 

Then again perhaps not, seeing as the worst thing about it was highlighting how bad Miley's vocals are on a ballad... she should stick to the uptempos.

not a fan of this, easily my least favourite Miley Cyrus single...hopefully the X Factor winner improve it somehow

My thoughts entirely, although I can hear Danyl singing this a damn sight more than Joe.

Same, possibly because he has a slightly annoying habit of adding an almost American twang to his voice.

 

I actually think this is Miley's best song (excluding remixes), it's got cheesy lyrics, but they're a heck of a lot better than some of her other stuff.

Surprised so many people think Joe will not be good at least, completely disagree that Stacey will walk it as well.

Girl song - she'll get maybe the comparison? I don't think just because it's a girl's song that Stacey's got this - and Danyl do this well? Well i'm yet to see him do anything well, so we'll see. Olly though - not for him at all =[

 

(Obviously this is all my opinion, and no offense is meant)

It's not a bad song, I think Miley Cyrus get's too much flak, it's Hannah Montana that's to blame. Even if they're the same person they both have very different styles.

 

Hannah is bubbly for the kids while Miley is a bit more serious.....

Edited December 4, 200915 yr by Sabrewulf238

Brilliant Song!

I hope Miley's Version Re-enters Top 10, or even Top 5! :)

Edited August 26, 201212 yr by Jay.

I think its stupid to have the climb as the single considering miley has had a hit with in t within the 12 nonths proir to the x factor winning releasiing it, for a competition that is so so huge i cannot figure out why more effort does not go into the winning single, i feel if they gave the winner are proper brand new song written by a good song writing team they would have an even far biggger hit.

So no hope of Joe singing a re-edit of "Fog On The Tyne (It's All Mine)" then. :(

I doubt over 600,000 people or so are going to buy the Muppets single tbh. :P Given that'll probably be how much it takes to beeat X Factor Winner.

 

Do not underestimate the gathered forces of Rockers, Metalheads, Goths and Nostalgia buffs...... :P In fact dont underestimate the fact that at Christmas all bets are off..... Nothing is ever certain.....

 

It got over 7 million hits on Youtube in two days.....

 

And let's face it, the REAL Muppets are better than Cowell and Walsh's manufactured muppets anyday.....

[ermmmm what I meant was that they got the song choice spot on last year because it's a fukking amazing song, I never said the cover was good :lol: ]

 

 

I'd be more impressed if the winners song was a single that they wrote & helped to produce themselves.

Bad choice, I like the song.

Too recent to release as a X Factor singer!

They usually choose a song that is ancient...

 

Hope this is untrue, we will find out next weekend anywaaaay :)

What a great choice :wub:

 

Shame Lloyd isnt there :(

:puke2: I don't even want to think about Joe and Olly's versions of 'The Climb'. :blink:

I'm sure it'd be okay suited to Joe tbh seeing as it's a fairly youthful song. I don't think Olly will be able to pull it off that well though ...

i think ollys version might surprise some people

Ugh, Stacey going tonight means we'll likely never hear her take on "The Climb". :( I don't think the versions by the runners-up have ever leaked. I'm sure it'd have been nothing amazing, but I'd have liked to hear it at least.

Ugh, Stacey going tonight means we'll likely never hear her take on "The Climb". :( I don't think the versions by the runners-up have ever leaked. I'm sure it'd have been nothing amazing, but I'd have liked to hear it at least.

 

Neither Olly's or Joe's versions are a patch on my Miley Cyrus original

 

Next year we'll have:

 

Anything in the version of Glee Cast

Breaking free from High School Musical

Can we fix it? by Bob the Builder

Number 1 by the Tweenies

Ugh, Stacey going tonight means we'll likely never hear her take on "The Climb". :( I don't think the versions by the runners-up have ever leaked. I'm sure it'd have been nothing amazing, but I'd have liked to hear it at least.

 

In Pop Idol, they weren't only leaked, they were blatantly put on the runner-up's debut single as b-sides. :arrr:

 

Joe's version is lovely, imo. :)