February 13, 201015 yr I found his screaming off putting. Each to their own. I find so many parts of the terrible EH off putting so we will agree to disagree.
February 13, 201015 yr Now that is a good charity song :wub: I agree, having listened to WATW25 now it is actually a really nice song ^_^ despite Wyclef's wailing :mellow:
February 13, 201015 yr Having heard it, I don't think this will be troubling the no. 1 spot. I think Wyclef Jean semi-tarnishes the track with his "vocals". What exactly is Wyclef Jean singing? :blink: His vocals are quite horrendous and by towards the end his warped wailings end up sounding more hilarious than serious. Also odd how all the US rappers who sing get the vocoder treatment. Are we to assume they can't sing and had to be autotuned? Oh, and there's a really off key ad lib 5.41 "joys we're making" <--- ouch!!! Surely that could've been pitched into tune. :lol: Overall I think it's ok but, unlike others opinions, I'd say this is on par with 'Everybody Hurts'. No one track is better than the other - they both just ok and nothing more than that.
February 13, 201015 yr Having heard it, I don't think this will be troubling the no. 1 spot. I think Wyclef Jean semi-tarnishes the track with his "vocals". What exactly is Wyclef Jean singing? :blink: His vocals are quite horrendous and by towards the end his warped wailings end up sounding more hilarious than serious. An authentic Haitian pronounciation?
February 13, 201015 yr That was actually good, cheesy maybe, but nonetheless, a moving effort- I do think it is better than EH, but my opinion is similar- I hope both do well also, Wyclef is singing from his heart, hes part Haitian and this is heartbreaking for him- People shouldnt mock him
February 13, 201015 yr That was actually good, cheesy maybe, but nonetheless, a moving effort- I do think it is better than EH, but my opinion is similar- I hope both do well also, Wyclef is singing from his heart, hes part Haitian and this is heartbreaking for him- People shouldnt mock him I agree people are mocking him for no apparent reason. He clearly is putting emotion into the song. If Lady Gaga was wailing the same lyric the majority of people on here complaining about Wyclef would proclaim it was the best vocal EVER.
February 13, 201015 yr I agree people are mocking him for no apparent reason. He clearly is putting emotion into the song. If Lady Gaga was wailing the same lyric the majority of people on here complaining about Wyclef would proclaim it was the best vocal EVER. No they wouldn't. I fon't think anyone has said that this is rubbish because Lady GaGa and Beyonce aren't on it like you've been saying people have. All people have said is that they thought they were going to be on it like the rumours suggested and they were disappointed that they weren't. It could just be a coincidence that they don't like the song.
February 13, 201015 yr No they wouldn't. I fon't think anyone has said that this is rubbish because Lady GaGa and Beyonce aren't on it like you've been saying people have. All people have said is that they thought they were going to be on it like the rumours suggested and they were disappointed that they weren't. It could just be a coincidence that they don't like the song. There were never any rumours to suggest they were on it.
February 13, 201015 yr nice to see michael getting the best parts once again. just the way it's supposed to be :)
February 13, 201015 yr I agree people are mocking him for no apparent reason. He clearly is putting emotion into the song. If Lady Gaga was wailing the same lyric the majority of people on here complaining about Wyclef would proclaim it was the best vocal EVER. Haha :lol: tbh I could see this being true Edited February 13, 201015 yr by chart wizard
February 13, 201015 yr also, Wyclef is singing from his heart, hes part Haitian and this is heartbreaking for him- People shouldnt mock him We're not mocking him, but it sounded awful. It was painful for the ears. I'm glad that he's singing from the heart, but it was freaking awful.
February 13, 201015 yr I hope this does really well in the UK aswell as America, it was always a great song in my opinion and that was nothing to do with the fact it was a charity single,so the fact its a great song i really want it to do greatly well!
February 13, 201015 yr I think it's a good version, apart from the rap bit which was also the worst bit of Band Aid 20. But they've done a great job and i'm sure it will raise a lot of money for haiti.
February 13, 201015 yr We're not mocking him, but it sounded awful. It was painful for the ears. I'm glad that he's singing from the heart, but it was freaking awful. well I guess everyone sees things differently- I actually thought it was very good
February 14, 201015 yr Well i just saw the video it was aired here in ireland at 12.15 its my first time hearing th ebrand new version i full and im not too impressed, the original is a million times better ad in a way im completly dispointed with the new version, i hope it does well because its for a good cause but i hope when the cd single its released that it contains the original version.
Create an account or sign in to comment