Jump to content

Featured Replies

I'd say;

 

01 Marina & The Diamonds

02 Little Boots

03 Ellie Goulding

 

 

 

 

 

04 Florence + The Machine

 

 

The first three are amazing, Florence + The Machine only has one good song in 'Rabbit Heart' imo, the rest are all pretty mediocre. Shame she's got the most success really.

  • Replies 71
  • Views 9.4k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

I really dont think this is a good choice of single. Her image and promo so far has tried to portray her as n indie/alrernative artist with a few radio friendly pop songs so it has to be asked why she's releasing this, a perfectly fine song but it just sounds like a Taylor Swift/Miley Cyrus record with slightly more mature lyrics.

I would say:

 

1. Marina

2. Florence

 

 

3. Little Boots

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

4. Ellie

 

Ellie Goulding is the most over-rated singer around at the moment.

If we're really doing this, then...

 

Little Boots >> Marina + The Diamonds >>>>>>>>>>>>> Ellie Goulding >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Florence + The Machine

 

I don't mind Florence, she's alright. Just a tad overrated.

I am so tempted to move everything to do with this into the pop forum as that is what this song is.

 

Nothing to do with Indie/Alt at all. Another artist using Indie coattails to move into the mainstream.

Should have learnt after Little Boots.

If we're really doing this, then...

 

Little Boots >> Marina + The Diamonds >>>>>>>>>>>>> Ellie Goulding >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Florence + The Machine

 

I don't mind Florence, she's alright. Just a tad overrated.

TBH Florence is probably the most alternative of the four of them as Little Boots is definitely pop, Ellie is heading that way and even Marina is veering towards it as well with tracks like Shampain and Oh No!

Video is pretty. The location (Happisburgh) is about 45 minutes away from me, in the lovely Norfolk ^_^

 

She's front of our main regional newspaper due to the video as well! :lol:

 

Love this song, although certainly not the best on the album.

TBH Florence is probably the most alternative of the four of them as Little Boots is definitely pop, Ellie is heading that way and even Marina is veering towards it as well with tracks like Shampain and Oh No!

That's got nothing to do with his preference of it, just because Florence is more 'indie' doesn't make her any better. She's thrown out two lazy covers of the same song to get a hit as well, which definetly is a pop song.

That's got nothing to do with his preference of it, just because Florence is more 'indie' doesn't make her any better. She's thrown out two lazy covers of the same song to get a hit as well, which definetly is a pop song.

I never said that makes her better. Nor did I say it had anything to do with his preference. Have to agree about You've Got The Love though.

I never said that makes her better. Nor did I say it had anything to do with his preference. Have to agree about You've Got The Love though.

Why did you quote him then?! :heehee:

That's got nothing to do with his preference of it, just because Florence is more 'indie' doesn't make her any better. She's thrown out two lazy covers of the same song to get a hit as well, which definetly is a pop song.

You Got The Love was at first only a b-side to Dog Days, she also did another a cover of Hospital Beds for the b-side of her first single Kiss With A Fist too, so she didn't record it just for the sake of having a hit. It only got a single release due to how many people cherry picked it off the album and the positive reaction the song got when she performed it on tour. She was just giving the people what they wanted.

Edited by Daniel Gleek

Why did you quote him then?! :heehee:

I could have quoted any of the posts comparing the four of them. Probably shouldn't have quoted him at all TBH.

1 Marina - 5 or 6 great tracks on her album. Her second one better be amazing.

2 Ellie - not great but I really like production plus there are three great songs on the album, he acoustic live stuff is good too.

3 Florence - I really don't get her at all - apart from Rabbit Heart and Cosmic Love

 

 

 

 

 

4 Little Boots - Remedy aside, she's average

 

Florence is definitely the least pop sounding of the 4.

Edited by tonyttt31

Best song after This Love Will Be You Downfall :wub:
I'd say;

 

01 Marina & The Diamonds

02 Little Boots

03 Ellie Goulding

 

 

 

 

 

04 Florence + The Machine

The first three are amazing, Florence + The Machine only has one good song in 'Rabbit Heart' imo, the rest are all pretty mediocre. Shame she's got the most success really.

 

Florence kicks ass! Lungs is so much better than Lights and i don't even like Hands. Marina is Florence's only competition and even then :o

Edited by CianS

This song is so beautiful. Definitely my favourite from the album.

 

Oh, and:

 

Florence >>>> Marina > Ellie >>> Little Boots

If anyone is overrated that is Florence.

 

I like Marina the most and also Ellie. Why is Little Boots here?

I love Marina, Ellie and Florence!!! I think Florence edges it just for me tho!!

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.