October 30, 201014 yr Paije is coming across more and more GAY each passing week. He reminds me alot of Danyl from last year, just not as obnoxious. I dont understand how you can call Danyl arrogant but defend Katie? Their attitudes towards the whole thing are effectivley one in the same!
October 30, 201014 yr This. :D Both of them have their own styles, Paije has that funky-ness and Aiden has that drama side to him. Trec has a great voice but she hasn't really put her own stamp to her songs, they are all so different. The other acts have a similar theme to them. Treyc may have a stronger voice but Dannii is a very talented singer. Just youtube her performance of Live for The One I Love, when she was in the West End. If she wasn't talented then she would never have done that. Kylie has not managed that. She has been in "showbiz" longer than Simon, Cheryl and Louis, over 30 years. She was in a show much like X-factor, singing infront of an audience every Saturday. Rant over :D Not buying it at all Danni has a poor range and her voice could never be compared to Treyc.I stick to my point that every week Paije is playing a big diva female singer and Aiden is mean and moody were is the variety in that it is one dimensional and boring.At the end of the day good singles will make an act it is ridiculous to assume that at this stage Treyc should have a firm identity.At this stage Leona did not Alex did not Joe did not why should it be different for Treyc. Edited October 30, 201014 yr by marrb
October 30, 201014 yr What does she look like :drama: Interesting choice of song though! I suddenly have the urge to watch the old 60's TV show. A childhood favourite of mine :heehee:
October 30, 201014 yr Katie- 7/10- that was again pretty good, I preferred her last week, but it was still solid- but the make up was really :o
October 30, 201014 yr Katie = 9.0 Great performance again. She's still my fave girl, loved her Halloween look. :D Katie = 9.0 Matt = 9.0 Mary = 9.0 TreyC = 7.5 Wagner = 7.5 Paije = 7.0 Rebecca = 7.0 Belle Amie = 5.0 Aiden = 5.0
October 30, 201014 yr Katie - The make-up was quite distracting, but I thought it was a very good performance again, I hope she gets through this week. 8/10
October 30, 201014 yr I didn't say he was arrogant, I said he was obnoxious LOL. Which he was in his stage presence and didn't come across too well in his little interviews with Dermot either if I recall correctly. Simon's ridiculous OTT comments to him each week didn't help at all either. Katie is just a fairly normal girl who made a few screwups which made her public enemy #01 and doesn't seem half as cockys Danyl. I'd say Cher is far far more cocky and arrogant than Katie ... Oh and I loved that performance, didn't like what she looked like but I thought it was a great performance. She seems more comfortable now as well.
October 30, 201014 yr Paije was good, but his voice is really starting to grate on me! OMGWTF at Katie. :mellow: She looks a fool. The song was a lot worse than last week, but better than the prior weeks. The singing wasn't great though. 01. Matt Cardle 02. Treyc Cohen 03. Mary Byrne --- 04. Aiden Grimshaw 05. Rebecca Ferguson 06. Katie Waissel 07. Paije Richardson --- 08. Belle Amie --- 09. Wagner
October 30, 201014 yr Katie - I'm a bit unsure about Katie.....however I really loved that performance....and I think out of every performance tonight it's the one I'm going to remember..... 9/10 Rebecca - 9/10 Katie - 9/10 Matt - 9/10 Mary - 8.5/10 Treyc - 8/10 Paije - 8/10 Aiden - 7.5/10 Wagner - :rofl: Belle Amie - 6/10
October 30, 201014 yr Katie Waissel: Actually love the look however I really didn't think much of her vocals, very weak throughout. Also I can see her singing movie songs or theme tunes each week now making her very uncontempory -_- - 4.5/10
October 30, 201014 yr Katie, okish middle of the road performance 5/10 the only thing that was missing.... a broomstick
October 30, 201014 yr Hope Katie has done just enough to go that was an awful vocal and she looked terrible-just go away with your weird, stage school, insincerity.
October 30, 201014 yr This week has been fairly shocking. There hasn't been ONE amazing performance so far. Paije has been the best but it was strictly an 8/10. Here's hoping Cher delivers...
October 30, 201014 yr Really, liked Paije. Again he's suffering somewhat from not being extremly interesting as proven by the fact most peoples comments on him were about the gender changes in the song. Still really like him, it was probably his best and I hope he can stay for a few weeks yet. And for gods sakes Dannii, give him some Gnarsl Barkley/Cee-Lo songs to sing! Katie is a complete abomination as always. Yeah, sure, fine, the vocals were decent and everything but I wanted to throw my TV out of the window in horror everytime I saw a close-up of her face, it was blooming terrifying. She continues to act like a complete twat as well, and good grief, I should shut up now as I'm probably coming across as being *slightly* insane.
October 30, 201014 yr Katie! What she lacks in vocal ability she more than makes up for in the entertainment factor. One of the few song choices tonight (I too have a hankering now to watch some old episodes of the Elizabeth Montgomery classic TV series) that actually was relevant to the theme. Although her voice is distinctly averag to say the least ... one of my fave performances of the night! Kath
October 30, 201014 yr Steve Brookstein just tweeted from the audience that he has security guards all round him. Thinks he's been rumbled.
October 30, 201014 yr Not buying it at all Danni has a poor range and her voice could never be compared to Treyc.I stick to my point that every week Paije is playing a big diva female singer and Aiden is mean and moody were is the variety in that it is one dimensional and boring.At the end of the day good singles will make an act it is ridiculous to assume that at this stage Treyc should have a firm identity.At this stage Leona did not Alex did not Joe did not why should it be different for Treyc. She has a really good range, better than many singers today. I wasn't comparing her to TreyC, you were. I own all of Dannii's albums and she has a great voice, but i would say that :lol: Katie has a firm identity now, as does Matt and several other acts.
Create an account or sign in to comment