Treyc on the otherhand is someone who I'm kinda of in love with (along with Aidan and Liam from Wand Erection), that was much better than her last two performances and was hopefully enough to pull her through to next week at least. I do realize she stands no chance of getting much further since Simon sort of has a point but still, she's sort of epic (and a black female, so I was always going to love her really)

Treyc - A very strong vocal....however I probably would agree with Simon that she just needs that extra kick and that something something and she could be ranking up there with Matt and Rebecca. Whether she can do that is another question. 8/10

 

Matt - 9.5/10

Rebecca - 9.5/10

Aiden - 8.5/10

Treyc - 8/10

Paije - 7/10

Katie - 6.5/10

Cher - 6.5/10

Mary - 6/10

Wagner - 4.5/10

Edited November 6, 201014 yr by Sabrewulf

I don't get all the hype about Matt. He's really not as good as everyone makes out... :rolleyes:

 

TreyC sounded a bit flat tonight i thought...

 

Ew, One Direction next. :puke2:

I completely agree. He really didn't deserve the huge reaction from the judges and audience from his performance tonight. -_-

 

For some reason One Direction always seem to be either second to last or last to perform every week? Unfair much?

Up next with Kids Of America it's Liam & One Direction (and possible Zain f***ing up the vocals on the lines he gets)

5 Erections are up now

Not gonna lie, I do love a little bit of Zain me.

Shots of them topless and in underwear, v. classy for barely legal teens. Would they ever do this with females?

One Direction = 8.0

 

Isn't Kim Wilde british? :wacko:

I liked their version of Kids in America but this is not my fave performance of theirs.

 

Matt = 9.0

Rebecca = 8.5

One Direction = 8.0

Katie = 7.5

Mary = 7.0

TreyC = 7.0

Cher = 6.5

Wagner = 6.5

Aiden = 5.0

Paije = 4.5

 

 

5 Erections: I will never will be able to play the original version again after hearing the track been murdered by 5 twats, its a british anthem ffs. 0/10

One Direction- 5/10- they were out of tune and pretty much killed one of my favourite songs, and Louis is spot on- not an american song

guess Simon will praise this as the performance of the night/season/whatever

not a fan.

 

and LOL Louis got it right once :lol:

One Direction, awful as always. :mellow: I don't see how they got a standing ovation from Cheryl (not surprised by Simon).

One Direction: Was very impressed with their vocals tonight, great song choice actually although I am glad Louis brought that up. - 8.5/10

Shots of them topless and in underwear, v. classy for barely legal teens. Would they ever do this with females?

 

OMG X Factor appealing for the Common Sense vote.

 

 

I kind of didn't hate One Direction. Liam is actually a pretty decent singer, and as long as they keep on limiting solo vocal time for Zain, they're fine.

:puke2: HATE them.

Getting a bit sick of Simon coming up with themes disregarding them and chastising Louis when he dares to bring them up! Oh and I didn;t enjoy the performance on any level! :)

Cher Lloyd: Really surprised to see her going first this week. Her vocals were pretty good, but she needs to keep away from the rapping. She is average at best at rapping 7/10

 

Mary Byrne: She really sounded a bit off in parts of that. Nowhere near as good as her previous performances 6/10

 

Katie Waissel: Great styling and song choice this week. Vocals could have been better, but I did enjoy that. What was up with the video on in the background though? 7/10

 

Aiden Grimshaw: I still want to see another performance as good as Week 1, but that was a lot better this week. He seemed to be enjoying it a bit more too 8/10

 

Paije Richardson: That performance was a bit of a guilty pleasure for me. Liked the song choices and the vocals were strong, but I'm not sure he has star quality 7/10

 

Rebecca Ferguson: Predictable song choice, but I loved that and she pulled off a great performance once again. Vocals and the look were spot on 9/10

 

Wagner: I really just want him to leave now. His performances are not fun at all. I really don't get the hype 2/10

 

Matt Cardle: Amazing ! Loved that. Stand out performance of the night. It would be a crime if he doesn't make the final 10/10

 

TreyC Cohen: Love the song and her vocals are always spot on, but she doesn't seem to connect with me at all 8/10

 

One Direction: I liked that and their song choice, but they were better last week. Still waiting for Harry to sing solo 7/10

HA at Dermot cutting off Curly Direction mid-sentence. He's clearly in c**t mood tonight.

One Direction - I love the song...but I didn't really like this. It pales in comparison to the original....maybe it's a bit unfair to be comparing but anytime I think of this being good I remember the original.....so no thanks One direction. 5/10

 

Matt - 9.5/10

Rebecca - 9.5/10

Aiden - 8.5/10

Treyc - 8/10

Paije - 7/10

Katie - 6.5/10

Cher - 6.5/10

Mary - 6/10

One Direction - 5/10

Wagner - 4.5/10

 

Wagner is at the bottom purely on his vocal abilities really...I still really like him....but it might be time for him to go now. :(

 

I'd love to see One direction leave they add nothing to the show....but like hell that'll happen. We're not getting rid of them until at least the final 5/6. If even that....

Mary, Paije and TreyC are in trouble this week me thinks...