Posted November 7, 201014 yr Last Week: Predictions: Belle Amie & TreyC Demands: Belle Amie & Wagner Results: Katie & Belle Amie Departure: Belle Amie Edited November 7, 201014 yr by CianS
November 7, 201014 yr Think: Katie & Mary Want: Katie & Cher I dunno though, Mary fits the whole 'shock week 5 exit' thing well but she unlesahed the sob-story on us, and will the judges really send it to deadlock over Katie in her third bottom 2 appearance. Paije and Treyc remain at risk but both have given much more forgettable performances in the past and gotten through, plus Paije stepped it up a lot this week. Katie I'd say must be a definate though.
November 7, 201014 yr Is it not a Double Elimination this week? Want: TreyC & Wagner Think: Katie & TreyC & if its Double: Want: TreyC, Wagner & Katie Think: Katie, TreyC and Aiden Leaving: Katie & TreyC
November 7, 201014 yr WANT: Mary & Katie THINK: Treyc & Katie EDIT: Oh, I put them in on the poll the wrong way round :snif:
November 7, 201014 yr Since it's a double elimination... WANT: Wagner (1st choice) / Rebecca / Katie (I like her but she's done as well as she's going to in this contest) THINK: Katie / Wagner / TreyC
November 7, 201014 yr Oh yeah, it is a double, thanks Sabrina :) I'll change to: Want: Wagner & Mary Think: Wagner & Katie
November 7, 201014 yr Good idea :D would like: Treyc, Mary think: Katie, TreyC if its a double, throw Mary into the 'think' and One Direction into the 'want' :D
November 7, 201014 yr Single Want: Cher Llyod and Katie Waissel Think: Katie Waissel and TreyC Cohen Double Want: Cher Llyod, Katie Waissel & TreyC Cohen Think: Cher Llyod, Katie Waissel & TreyC Cohen Edited November 7, 201014 yr by Daniel II
November 7, 201014 yr I can't believe anybody honestly thinks Cher will be bottom 2/3. Contemporary song, decent vocals, display of variety in her performances... no way is she in trouble.
November 7, 201014 yr Who WILL Be There TreyC and Katie Who Do You Want There? Wagner and Katie Katie butchered 'Don't Speak' whereas at least TreyC did justice to Aerosmith's song. These two just don't connect with the public - at least TreyC is the better singer. Really does make you wonder how the hell Katie got herself a record contract in the first place. :blink:
November 7, 201014 yr Who WILL Be There TreyC and Katie If it is TreyC and Katie ... who do you think the judges will get shut of? I'm certain Cheryl will save Katie. I think Simon would go for her too. I'm certain Danni would go for the better vocalist (TreyC). If this is what transpires ... please let it go to deadlock. Really does make you wonder how the hell Katie got herself a record contract in the first place. :blink: I've been wondering that myself. She's butchered (almost) every song she's sung ... although in her defence ... she has been one of the contests most interesting and entertaining figures. She's like female Jedward. I actually now think that these 'deals' she had were just small 'minnow' affairs and the press just bigged them up to make Katie even more of a hate figure than she'd already become. Kath Edited November 7, 201014 yr by Kathyp
November 7, 201014 yr If it is TreyC and Katie ... who do you think the judges will get shut of? I'm certain Cheryl will save Katie. I think Simon would go for her too. I'm certain Danni would go for the better vocalist (TreyC). If this is what transpires ... please let it go to deadlock. I've been wondering that myself. She's butchered (almost) every song she's sung ... although in her defence ... she has been one of the contests most interesting and entertaining figures. She's like female Jedward. I actually now think that these 'deals' she had were just small 'minnow' affairs and the press just bigged them up to make Katie even more of a hate figure than she'd already become. Kath Knowing Cheryl, she probably won't choose. -_- So I reckon regardless of what happens it'll go to deadlock and it'll be the public vote. Hopefully TreyC will get an edge over Katie and remain in the competition. It doesn't matter who stays out of these two, the one who survives will most likely be bottom two again next week. I just think it'd show up The X Factor if Katie (who has been extremely inconsistant) lasts longer than TreyC (who has been more consistant). She isn't even interesting. She came across terribly in her first audition (thanks to editing) and became known as "the one who never remembers lyrics". I thought it was a build up to Katie having this powerhouse performance in Week 1 of the finals. As it was 'We Are The Champions' was limp. She was ok singing 'Bewitched' and the Etta James song. Everything else has smacked off "trying too hard".
November 7, 201014 yr I can't believe anybody honestly thinks Cher will be bottom 2/3. Contemporary song, decent vocals, display of variety in her performances... no way is she in trouble. Aside from the song being contemporary, they are all subjective points you've made about the performance. Her fanbase I should imagine are the younger viewers, who tend not to vote anyway, and that smaller demographic would most likely be hoovered up by One Direction, so I don't see her being the unstoppable force everyone else seems to. Also if rumours are to believed, bar last week, she hasn't been doing as well in the voting as has been the general assumption thus far. Not to mention she went on first and her performance was swallowed up in the crapness that was the first half of an overall underwhelming week. I think she may have got an inital surge when the die hards vote for their respected favourites the moment lines open; but despite that she won't get many casual votes tonight as Mary (has a bigger voting fanbase then her) and Wagner (performed latter than her) will, and will therefore fall down to the bottom three. Of course this is a long shot, and my intense dislike for her might be clouding my judgement: but that was my gut instinct, and I decided to go with it, instead of choosing the safer option of Mary/Wagner as the third contestant (that will join the inevitable Katie and TreyC) at the bottom. Edited November 7, 201014 yr by Daniel II
Create an account or sign in to comment