my thoughts:

 

 

Matt- OK , I guess- but he could have so much better,I would've loved to see him do a Muse song or More Than A Feeling by Boston :(

Rebecca- I think she could be pretty good with both of these

Katie- she could do the first one good, but the second one will be a disaster

Cher- oh dear :( she could do them well, but SO predictable, plus their both upbeat- I thought it was one ballad and one upbeat

Mary- I dont know either of these, so not sure

Wagner- the first one will be pretty good, the second one I really dont know :o

One Direction- they werent even born then :lol: I think they'll do good with both, but not different to any other week

 

Edited November 27, 201014 yr by chart wizard

Semi final next week :o so soon

Someone wants to get rid of Wagner. He is first tonight! :o

Yes Rock Week has been such a glorious sucess in previous years hasnt it. I have no doubt this will continue tonight.

Wagner = 8.0

 

Yes, Wagner your skin makes me cry but you're so fu**in' special!

THAT WAS GOOD :lol:

Wagner- 7/10- :o :o :o :o :o :o :o he was good! I guess thats his downfall :(

Wagner Actually taht was good :o 7/10

It's widow... not winner...

Wagner - I really liked that, and not for the silly factor but for the actual singing performance. :o He does actually have a pleasant voice when he's not dancing around so much. 7.5/10

Wagner in ACTUALLY KIND OF ALRIGHT SHOCKER. How CRAZY!

hahaa that was suprisingly good atleast for him anyway. loving dannii's comments too :P

Poor BRAVE Wagner. Doomed to go home this week after that probably. Possibly the best song choice in the history of this show aswell.

 

His growing resemblence to the ratcatcher as the weeks go by, and his lack of an entire cheap ITV2 show being represnted in a performance do mean I dont think he'll be here next week.

I want Creep jumping like a rocket on iTunes right now. :dance:

Beyonce looked very hot in that ad :o

WAGNER WAS AMAZING

Wagner Performance 1: Far better than usual, there were actually some bits in tune. - 5.0/10

On a scale from absoulte $h!te to bloody brilliant, Wagner was not half bad! Definitely a 7/10 and for him an 8/10 (woulda been a 9 if he showed he could stay in tune all the way through)

Wand Erection: Firstly I hate this track with passion, and that didn't do anything for me. 1/10

One Direction = 7.0

 

What a silly boring song choice. Why not a modern song instead?

One of their weakest performances to date.

 

Wagner = 8.0

One Direction = 7.0