Jump to content

Featured Replies

Lady GaGa

Madonna

 

First is a foregone conclusion, second might change in a few years but as of now Madonna's back catalogue is far too large and illustrious.

  • Replies 69
  • Views 4.2k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Lady Gaga (both are good, but despite a smaller discography, Gaga's is stronger on the whole)

Madonna (not very hard, Madonna's legacy and better back catalogue prevail in the end)

 

 

Kylie Minogue

Rihanna

 

Lady Gaga

Rihanna

 

Where've all Kylie's fans gone from the previous rounds? :cry:

 

IMO she's *far* more attractive than Lady Gaga!

 

******

 

However, leaving that aside - will there be a 3rd/4th place run-off as well as the final? That's something I'd like to see - but what do others think of the idea?

 

Edited by vidcapper

Lady Gaga Vs Kylie Minogue

Madonna Vs Rihanna

Where've all Kylie's fans gone from the previous rounds? :cry:

 

IMO she's *far* more attractive than Lady Gaga!

 

******

 

Last time I checked this was a competition to find Buzzjack's favourite female singer and not a competition of 'who is the most attractive singer'. Kylie may look more attractive than Gaga but Gaga has better songs (imo, of course - and in a lot of other peoples' opinion too) Fair enough if you think Kylie is a better singer than Gaga but it's not about who is more attractive. :P

Last time I checked this was a competition to find Buzzjack's favourite female singer and not a competition of 'who is the most attractive singer'. Kylie may look more attractive than Gaga but Gaga has better songs (imo, of course - and in a lot of other peoples' opinion too) Fair enough if you think Kylie is a better singer than Gaga but it's not about who is more attractive. :P

 

If it's *just* about the singing, then why is the term 'Babes' used, which implies physical appearance is definitely an important factor?

Where've all Kylie's fans gone from the previous rounds? :cry:

 

IMO she's *far* more attractive than Lady Gaga!

 

******

 

However, leaving that aside - will there be a 3rd/4th place run-off as well as the final? That's something I'd like to see - but what do others think of the idea?

 

No. We're looking for the favourite, not the third favourite.

  • Author

Babes was used as it's alliterative and they're all female. I used favourite so that people can use their own criteria (I have pointed this out in a previous round) if you want to use perceived fitness it's up to you but be aware others are obviously not using that factor. There isn't any right or wrong criteria, many factors normally contribute to a favourite.

 

Hope that clarifies.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.