They are both grannies but Kylie is the least granniest,so Kylie.

Actually Madonna's children are too young to have kids (well Lourdes could biologically but she hasn't :P) and Kylie has no kids so they aren't grannies.[/pedant] Besides, Kylie is only 43, not 73...

Madonna for the 3rd place! :cheer:

Actually Madonna's children are too young to have kids (well Lourdes could biologically but she hasn't :P) and Kylie has no kids so they aren't grannies.[/pedant] Besides, Kylie is only 43, not 73...

 

Thats what i said though :lol:

Thats what i said though :lol:

You said they are both grannies, but Kylie is the 'least granniest'... Kylie looks in her 30s, which is in no way granny-ish.

Which means she is the least granniest. and i meant granny in music terms. :P

You said they are both grannies, but Kylie is the 'least granniest'... Kylie looks in her 30s, which is in no way granny-ish.

 

In the chaviest council estates, you might find some grannies in their 30's... :P

But as the title of the competiton suggests, it's not *just* about the music - and the 'granny dressing in her teenage grand-daughters clothes' look is enough to make most people cringe. :lol:

 

Hot pants on a middle aged woman also?

 

I see no appeal in the image of either, at least from an attraction point of view. I prefer Madonna's music and she doesn't have the most irksome fans this side of Will Young, so it's a no-brainer for me. Plus I can't ever see myself loathing a Madonna song the way I loathe "Can't Get You Out Of My Head".

On image Kylie wins hands down, on music both are hit and miss. That said, based on both artists recent material I have to go with Kylie and Madonna's latest offering is bitterly disapointing.

Hot pants on a middle aged woman also?

 

Err, Kylie was only 32 at the time of Spinning Around - that's hardly middle-aged! :P

Easily Kylie for me. Madonna had good moments only in the 80s.