No-one has attacked anyone either way, it's perfectly fine that some people don't like the song no matter how baffling you may think their opinion is! It might be The Saturdays forum but in the same way as the rest of the forum, discussion is key to this forum and a range of opinions is part of that.

 

It IS the best option whether you like it or not though, really the only sensible choice even if it will only be manage success on the level of in between Gentleman and Disco Love, but that's not bad for a 5th single released post album.

 

This is sense in a sentence! :heart: I love you LIAM :wub: ;)

No-one has attacked anyone either way, it's perfectly fine that some people don't like the song no matter how baffling you may think their opinion is! It might be The Saturdays forum but in the same way as the rest of the forum, discussion is key to this forum and a range of opinions is part of that.

 

It IS the best option whether you like it or not though, really the only sensible choice even if it will only be manage success on the level of in between Gentleman and Disco Love, but that's not bad for a 5th single released post album.

 

Yet.....

http://i.imgur.com/EzKDx4Z.gif

 

 

 

:)

I don't mind different opinions, I love a good discussion.

But let's express our thoughts as opinions and less as facts.

Saying "Its the worst song on the album" and "It won't smash" isn't being realistic, it's just being a spoilsport. :P

Don't write a song off just because you don't like it! You don't know that it won't do well, just like you don't know that it will!

 

And what I meant by us all being in The Saturdays forum is not for everyone to express their love and not being allowed to say anything negative...

But more to appreciate the fact that there's going to be a sense of 'loonism' because there will be more lovers than haters.

Edited January 24, 201411 yr by Scherz

This is so weird, I swear after everyone heard Not Giving Up for the first time everyone was all "Should have been released instead of Gentleman!" "Needs to be the next single", "Their best recorded song to date!", now I see it's pretty much 50% with opinions, what happened? I hope The Sats managment don't see negative feedback like with The Way You Watch Me then cancel it. I'm thrilled we're getting another single, video and b-side.

I don't mind different opinions, I love a good discussion.

But let's express our thoughts as opinions and less as facts.

Saying "Its the worst song on the album" and "It won't smash" isn't being realistic, it's just being a spoilsport. :P

Don't write a song off just because you don't like it! You don't know that it won't do well, just like you don't know that it will!

 

And what I meant by us all being in The Saturdays forum is not for everyone to express their love and not being allowed to say anything negative...

But more to appreciate the fact that there's going to be a sense of 'loonism' because there will be more lovers than haters.

 

I'm a lover. LOVER!

I don't mind different opinions, I love a good discussion.

But let's express our thoughts as opinions and less as facts.

Saying "Its the worst song on the album" and "It won't smash" isn't being realistic, it's just being a spoilsport. :P

Don't write a song off just because you don't like it! You don't know that it won't do well, just like you don't know that it will!

 

And what I meant by us all being in The Saturdays forum is not for everyone to express their love and not being allowed to say anything negative...

But more to appreciate the fact that there's going to be a sense of 'loonism' because there will be more lovers than haters.

 

No. It's having an opinion. I don't give a rat's ass if you all like it or not.

This is sense in a sentence! :heart: I love you LIAM :wub: ;)

*3 sentences :smoke:

No. It's having an opinion. I don't give a rat's ass if you all like it or not.

Charming, as ever!

 

 

Anyway, we're going slightly off topic.

Like it. Love it. Either way, it's the next single and we'll have to live with it!

 

I hope we get a new song as the b-side. They very rarely let us down on that front :wub:

:yahoo:

 

Just now reading the great news. I think about 90% of folks who frequent the Sats forum love Not Giving Up. The naysayers just tend to be more vocal :)

 

Ultimately this is their best (and possibly only) chance at another hit off LFTW. I think it is catchy and gender neutral enough to do big things for them. Now to see how they handle the release...

Oh I can't wait!!!! :dance:

*3 sentences :smoke:

 

??? :(

I'm hoping for Top 5, because every year since they've been "active" they have had a Top 10 single, that's kind of impressive! No?

 

Top 5s:

2008: Up

2009: Issues, Just Can't Get Enough, Forever Is Over

2010: Missing You

2011: All Fired Up

2012: What About Us

2013: Disco Love

2014: Not Giving Up & Amazing new single from 6th Album/Greatest Hits

I'm hoping for Top 5, because every year since they've been "active" they have had a Top 10 single, that's kind of impressive! No?

 

Top 5s:

2008: Up

2009: Issues, Just Can't Get Enough, Forever Is Over

2010: Missing You

2011: All Fired Up

2012: What About Us

2013: Disco Love

2014: Not Giving Up & Amazing new single from 6th Album/Greatest Hits

 

2012 didn't have one.

2013 was what about us and Disco Love :)

Oh yeh stupid me, I was looking at wikipedia discography and thinking I was well clever! Hahaha!

2012 didn't have one.

2013 was what about us and Disco Love :)

 

I'm confused one second it says top 5, then top 10. If it's top 10, at least 2012 had '30 Days'. 2008 would then also have 'If This Is Love', 2010 'Higher' and 2011 'Notorious'.

I'm confused one second it says top 5, then top 10. If it's top 10, at least 2012 had '30 Days'. 2008 would then also have 'If This Is Love', 2010 'Higher' and 2011 'Notorious'.

 

I meant top 5 sorry I'm very confused, but "IT" that's well mean :o (Joke I knew what you meant really ;)) Yeh sorry I meant top 5, but we have actually had a top 10 each year which is still good!

Edited January 24, 201411 yr by Juliano

I meant top 5 sorry I'm very confused, but "IT" that's well mean :o (Joke I knew what you meant really ;)) Yeh sorry I meant top 5, but we have actually had a top 10 each year which is still good!

 

I was referring to your post as 'it'. :lol: Maybe we could get them a #1 streak started though! "I feel like something startin' startin'" :P

I was referring to your post as 'it'. :lol: Maybe we could get them a #1 streak started though! "I feel like something startin' startin'" :P

 

Yeh I know really! But my goodness, I really need to start reading my posts a couple of time before actually posting them! I messed up a couple of times during that immune game too because I just didn't think before pressing post! Sorry everyone! <_<

I swear on the poll for this album NGU won by quite a distance? I might be wrong.

 

To be 100% honest I don't LOVE the song - though I do love Frankie's bridge. But I think it's definitely the most radio friendly song on the album (after WAU), so I'm glad they're releasing it. I think their best chance of pulling in sales. With good radio backing and some decent promo slots, I don't see why it can't be he second highest selling song on the album.

 

I too hope they have a single version for people to pre order etc.

Edited January 25, 201411 yr by joepassmore

??? :(

You said 'sense in a sentence' but I wrote more than one :P I was just being jokingly pedantic :lol: