Jump to content

Featured Replies

  • Author
I'm worried about many of you. Some of these "opinions" are being thrown about so recklessly though. http://www.trover.com/images/emoji/1f440.png

 

Thank goodness for Joseph, the purveyor of excellent taste! http://www.briskoda.net/forums/public/style_emoticons/default/emoticon-0157-sun.gif

I like 'DNA' and all but it's grossly overrated on this forum. It's quite basic when put up against many of the songs included in this rate. The fact it's ahead of some genuinely better Sugababes/Saturdays/Girls Aloud songs is a bit "eh" but... this is BuzzJack. I should expect stuff like this. http://forum.femina.mk/styles/default/femina/emoticons/0707.gif 'Move' is superior, but is in great danger of outstaying its welcome too.

 

http://thumbnails.eonline.com/p/saturdays_109_highlight_b_203998.jpg

  • Replies 668
  • Views 22.5k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

http://thumbnails.eonline.com/p/saturdays_109_highlight_b_203998.jpg

http://media.giphy.com/media/Hv0WISp2wr9Mk/giphy.gif

 

Lee the purveyor of excellence in general. x

  • Author

14. Girls Aloud - The Show (Average Rating 8.71)

 

I must admit I was completely surprise to see 'The Show' so high as before hand I forgot what the song even was until I heard it over while doing the singles rate. 'The Show' is the second consecutive Girls Aloud song to be eliminated following 'Call The Shots', Poor Jay must be devastated with the last four eliminations / potential winner :kink:. 'The Show' peaked at #67 in Australia while achieving a #02 peak in the United Kingdom and a #05 pea in Ireland. I must admit that doing this rate has made me appreciated Girls Aloud much more because they've got so much more tunes than I first thought. 'The Show' managed fifteen 10's and six 11's. (dead) and despite achieving such high scores it finishes at Wall's favourite number #14.

 

  • Author
http://media.giphy.com/media/Hv0WISp2wr9Mk/giphy.gif

 

Lee the purveyor of excellence in general. x

 

http://i1.mirror.co.uk/incoming/article2179305.ece/alternates/s615/Frankie-Sandford.jpg

http://31.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_m5l86c9XYo1rn95k2o1_500.gif
I like 'DNA' and all but it's grossly overrated on this forum. It's quite basic when put up against many of the songs included in this rate. The fact it's ahead of some genuinely better Sugababes/Saturdays/Girls Aloud songs is a bit "eh" but... this is BuzzJack. I should expect stuff like this. http://forum.femina.mk/styles/default/femina/emoticons/0707.gif 'Move' is superior, but is in great danger of outstaying its welcome too.

 

'Move' and 'DNA' are better than pretty much every Suga/GA/Sats single in my opinion. I don't know how you can say 'DNA' is basic. I guess it's not generic enough for your liking. ^_^

http://dragaholic.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/08/latrice-royale-throwing-shade-gif-2.gif
  • Author
'Move' and 'DNA' are better than pretty much every Suga/GA/Sats single in my opinion. I don't know how you can say 'DNA' is basic. I guess it's not generic enough for your liking. ^_^

 

 

http://25.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_m9iosfF3gS1qjjf4ho3_1280.png

  • Author

14. Girls Aloud - The Show (Average Rating 8.71)

15. Girls Aloud - Call The Shots (Average Rating 8.66)

16. The Saturdays Feat Sean Paul - What About Us (Average Rating 8.66)

17. The Saturdays - All Fired Up (Average Rating 8.64)

18. Girls Aloud - Something New (Average Rating 8.39)

19. The Saturdays - Disco Love (Average Rating 8.36)

20. The Saturdays - Notorious (Average Rating 8.29)

 

21. Girls Aloud - Untouchable. (Average Rating 8.24)

22. Sugababes - Push The Button (Average Rating 8.23)

23. Little Mix - Salute (Average Rating 8.18)

24. Girls Aloud - Love Machine (Average Rating 8.16)

25. The Saturdays - Not Giving Up (Average Rating 8.1)

26. Girls Aloud - Something Kinda Oooh (Average Rating 8.02)

27. Sugababes - Ugly (Average Rating 7.98)

28. Girls Aloud - No Good Advice (Average Rating 7.97)

29. Sugababes - Overload (Average Rating 7.91)

30. Sugababes - In The Middle (Average Rating 7.89)

 

31. One Direction - Story Of My Life (Average Rating 7.89)

32. Girls Aloud - Jump (Average Rating 7.86)

33. One Direction - What Makes You Beautiful (Average Rating 7.86)

34. Sugababes - Stronger (Average Rating 7.81)

35. Sugababes - Red Dress (Average Rating 7.75)

36. Sugababes - Denial (Average Rating 7.73)

37. Little Mix - Wings (Average Rating 7.61)

38. Girls Aloud - Can't Speak French (Average Rating (7.58)

39. Sugababes - Flatline (Average Rating 7.57)

40. Sugababes - Caught In The Moment (Average Rating 7.54)

 

41. Girls Aloud - The Loving Kind (Average Rating 7.52)

42. Sugababes - Run For Cover (Average Rating 7.45)

43. The Saturdays - My Heart Takes Over (Average Rating (7.43)

44. Sugababes - Change (Average Rating 7.42)

45. Girls Aloud - The Promise (Average Rating 7.41)

46. Sugababes - About A Girl (Average Rating 7.39)

47. The Saturdays - Work (Average Rating 7.38)

48. Sugababes - Easy (Average Rating 7.36)

49. Girls Aloud - Wake Me Up (Average Rating 7.27)

50. The Saturdays - Issues (Average Rating 7.25)

 

51. The Saturdays - If This Is Love (Average Rating 7.23)

52. Girls Aloud - Life Got Cold (Average Rating 7.13)

53. Little Mix - Change Your Life (Average Rating 7.13)

54. The Saturdays - Missing You (Average Rating 7.12)

55. One Direction - Kiss You (Average Rating 7)

56. One Direction - Night Changes (Average Rating 6.87)

57. The Saturdays - 30 Days (Average Rating 6.86)

58. One Direction - Steal My Girl (Average Rating 6.80)

59. Little Mix - Little Me (Average Rating 6.65)

60. The Saturdays - What Are You Waiting For? (Average Rating 6.58)

 

61. The Saturdays - Forever Is Over (Average Rating 6.56)

62. Sugababes - Get Sexy (Average Rating 6.48)

63. The Saturdays - Just Can't Get Enough (Average Rating 6.39)

64. One Direction - You & I (Average Rating 6.38)

65. One Direction - Best Song Ever (Average Rating 6.29)

66. One Direction - One Thing (Average Rating 6.29)

67. Girls Aloud - I'll Stand By You (Average Rating 6.28)

68. Little Mix - How Ya Doin? (Average Rating 6.05)

69. Sugababes - Follow Me Home (Average Rating 6.04)

70. One Direction - Live While We're Young (Average Rating 5.98)

 

71. Sugababes - Soul Sound (Average Rating 5.82)

72. Sugababes - Angels With Dirty Faces (Average Rating (5.80)

73. Girls Aloud - Long Hot Summer (Average Rating (5.79)

74. Sugababes - Shape (Average Rating 5.78)

75. Sugababes - New Year (Average Rating 5.69)

76. Sugababes - Wear My Kiss (Average Rating 5.69)

77. Little Mix - Cannonball (Average Rating 5.65)

78. Girls Aloud - Beautiful Cause You Love Me (Average Rating 5.61)

79. Girls Aloud - Whole Lotta History (Average Rating 5.56)

80. Girls Aloud - See The Day (Average Rating 5.51)

 

81. Girls Aloud - I Think We're Alone Now (Average Rating 5.45)

82. One Direction - More Than This (Average Rating 5.12)

83. One Direction - Little Things (Average Rating 4.84)

84. Sugababes - No Can Do (Average Rating 4.83)

85. Sugababes - Walk This Way (Feat Girls Aloud) (Average Rating 4.82)

86. Sugababes - Girls [Average Rating 4.79]

87. The Saturdays - Gentleman [Average Rating 4.77]

88. One Direction - Midnight Memories [Average Rating 4.55]

89. Sugababes - Freedom [Average Rating 4.29]

90. Little Mix - Word Up! [Average Rating 4.03]

 

92. One Direction - One Way Or Another (Teenage Kicks) [Average Rating 3.89]

91. One Direction - Gotta Be You [Average Rating 3.92]

  • Author

Oh I see Jay bringing up his personal chart runs

 

http://thumbnails.eonline.com/p/saturdays_109_highlight_b_203998.jpg

Compared to many of the songs in this rate I do think 'DNA' sounds a bit cheaply produced. I find the repetitiveness and production quite boring tbh now that the dust is settled and it's been around for a couple of years.

 

These results are very give and take. Pleased that "Push The Button" missed the top 20, rather annoying (ditto "Something Kinda Oooh"). "Too Lost In You" is where it's at.

I've decided the 14-20 is actually the results in 4-10. ^_^

 

SKO in 26th place is still killing me a bit. :snif:

Oh I see Jay bringing up his personal chart runs

 

http://thumbnails.eonline.com/p/saturdays_109_highlight_b_203998.jpg

 

Desperate measures! :o

 

I probably should have said of 'DNA' - "it's enjoyable and I like it a lot, but relatively I don't find it as good as some of the GA/Suga/Sats singles that have fallen up to this point", as that's my more extended/honest opinion on the matter. :cry:

 

Maybe "basic" sounds harsh, to the point it sounds like I'm saying I dislike it, but that's definitely not the case. I personally think it should have left a while ago and sat comfortably & respectably somewhere within the 21-40 section, but that's just me. If lots of us who voted consider 'DNA' to be one of the very best on the list then that's great. ^_^ I'm being fairly tongue in cheek with my posts anyway, none of this is the end of the world. It just wildly varies from my own tastes, in places!

 

Although to be fair on myself, a lot of us who are replying haven't been backwards in coming forwards when it comes some of the other groups & their singles, so that was just my own moment of expressing that a particular Little Mix song wasn't completely & utterly incredibly amazing, for me. :whistle:

 

http://static.tumblr.com/3wcstdp/M0rmcpqca/untitled-3p.gif

 

P.S. Just be glad the Spice Girls aren't on the list. I may have had a breakdown if they'd done poorly. :kink:

  • Author
Desperate measures! :o

 

I probably should have said of 'DNA' - "it's enjoyable and I like it a lot, but relatively I don't find it as good as some of the GA/Suga/Sats singles that have fallen up to this point", as that's my more extended/honest opinion on the matter. :cry:

 

Maybe "basic" sounds harsh, to the point it sounds like I'm saying I dislike it, but that's definitely not the case. I personally think it should have left a while ago and sat comfortably & respectably somewhere within the 21-40 section, but that's just me. If lots of us who voted consider 'DNA' to be one of the very best on the list then that's great. ^_^ I'm being fairly tongue in cheek with my posts anyway, none of this is the end of the world. It just wildly varies from my own tastes, in places!

 

Although to be fair on myself, a lot of us who are replying haven't been backwards in coming forwards when it comes some of the other groups & their singles, so that was just my own moment of expressing that a particular Little Mix song wasn't completely & utterly incredibly amazing, for me. :whistle:

 

http://static.tumblr.com/3wcstdp/M0rmcpqca/untitled-3p.gif

 

P.S. Just be glad the Spice Girls aren't on the list. I may have had a breakdown if they'd done poorly. :kink:

 

Would it surprise you?

 

This countdown has been full of shocks and no doubt that 'Viva Forever' would be missing the top 5 what would almost be as big of an injustice as 'What About Us' missing the top 15.

Most likely, I know Jak would have placed a pesky -1 next to that title. <_<!
17. The Saturdays - All Fired Up (Average Rating 8.64)

 

 

'We Make The Party, Super Naughty!'. Finishing at #17 (I see all you haters doing a Rochelle and cracking open the bubbly) is Saturday's most danciest song yet 'All Fired Up'. 'All Fired Up' was the first Saturdays single to go to #01 on iTunes which resulted into major celebrations, bubbly being cracked open and Pixie Lott's 'All About Tonight' to overtake them 15 minutes later following her 'All About Tonight' performance on 'Red Or Black'. It would have been interesting to see where The Saturdays would have been had 'All Fired Up' been promoted on Red Or Black that night? They would have at least managed 80,000 opening week sales which would be for sure. Had they released the week before 'All Fired Up' would have had enough sales to go #01. 'All Fired Up' went 3-4-15 poor flops. 'All Fired Up' managed 14 tens and six (i wrote that as sex oops) 11's which has broken the current record. 'All Fired Up' would have been top 10 had Jahq not trolled and provided it with a -1.

I'm coming for blood. Jahq you better watch your back, cause I'm coming for ya

Jay and I to make a combined ranking and use that as the official one tbh.

 

*.* I'll have to get a rank together!

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.