Promise Me gets too much hate on here. It was one of my instant faves, but it's got a bit tired over time.

Yeah, Promise Me hasn't aged very well for me either. Crazy to think it's already 3.5 years old!

No real losses so far, I do really like DIYE but it's not among my faves or anything. It's behind the singles, One Shot and Karma on Headlines for me.

Promise Me gets too much hate on here. It was one of my instant faves, but it's got a bit tired over time.

 

Agreed - aged horribly and those Rochelle vocals :puke:

42. For Myself 36.25 Average
Highest Marks: #16 (Tim) #17 (Liam) #20 (Joe)
Lowest Marks: #55 (Cameron) #52 (Hurricane) #47 (Will)
And yet I can't resist you when you're kissing my face off sings SultrUna in this On Your Radar album track. The verses in this song are lush while the chorus is somewhat grating. I think it ended up in the correct position, although there are some tracks ahead of it that are arguably worse (see below). Cameron somehow finds this to be their worst song while Tim, Liam, and Joe all place it in their Top 20.

41. Somebody Else's Life 35.94 Average
Highest Marks: #7 (Joe) #15 (Tim) #23 (April)
Lowest Marks: #55 (Zach) #54 (Will) #53 (Juliano)
Make it stop! This song is repulsive and how it managed to get ahead of 14 other songs I have no idea. Both in acoustic and uptempo form, Somebody Else's Life is a mess. The acoustic version is boring as all get out and the album version is painful to the ears. The filtering over Mollie and Frankie's voices is strange and unnecessary. I think this may be the only Sats song that I actually despise. I know it's probably not that bad, but for me it's a big NO.

I love Somebody Else's Life, Zach! It is not repulsive. I wouldn't have minded it if were a single over that atrocity known as "Gentleman".

Tim, is your favourite album On Your Radar by any chance? :kink:

I love Somebody Else's Life, Zach! It is not repulsive. I wouldn't have minded it if were a single over that atrocity known as "Gentleman".

omg I love you even more now :wub:

Marry me pls

Tim, is your favourite album On Your Radar by any chance? :kink:

How did you know that :thinking:

On Your Radar is one of the best dance/pop album's I have heard

omg I love you even more now :wub:

Marry me pls

 

http://33.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_m24veeTzRx1rt9z55o1_250.gif

Don't act like you don't want to

GET A ROOM

40. Lies 35.88 Average
Highest Marks: #19 (Totto) #21 (Hurricane) #26 (Calum Hood)
Lowest Marks: #52 (Lee) #51 (April) #47 (Liam)
Well, the quality is definitely picking up as we move into the Top 40. Lies is a solid album track and is deserving of its spot in the Top 40. The production and instrumental is quite good, especially when compared with the rest of Chasing Lights. Lies makes me miss the days when Frankie could flawlessly execute an entire verse on her own.

39. Don't Let Me Dance Alone 35.63 Average
Highest Marks: #11 (Tim) #20 (Joe) #21 (Zach)
Lowest Marks: #52 (April) #51 (Martyn) #50 (Ultraviolence)
I DIDN'T PUT THIS DRESS ON FOR YOU TO TAKE IT OFF. Don't Let Me Dance Alone is one of the better Living For The Weekend album tracks and could have been even greater had it not been produced by The Jam. This song is a grower and it took a while for me to properly get into it. I was surprised that they ended up performing this on their Greatest Hits Tour but it was a nice addition. April somehow prefers Somebody Else's Life to this diamond in the rough. Praying for you April.

38. Set Me Off 33.38 Average
Highest Marks: #8 (Sean) #8 (Hurricane) #18 (Totto)
Lowest Marks: #50 (Lee) #47 (Tim) #46 (Joe)
Up next is Set Me Off, which I find to be the catchiest Chasing Lights album track. It's a very upbeat song and the production is cool albeit cheap. This is our first song to get two Top 10 rankings, coming in 8th for both Sean and Hurricane. Make sure you watch the gem of a video above which has some great pics of the girls in their early days.

These three are so so so good, though....What a shame.

 

For Myself should have been out way before that, it's awful.

 

Somebody Else's Life is a mess studio wise, but acoustically, it's decent. Especially live with the harmonies on the middle-8. :wub:

47. You Don't Have The Right 37.25 Average

Highest Marks: #9 (Totto) #18 (Calum Hood) #19 (Cameron)

Lowest Marks: #52 (Juliano) #52 (Jonjo) #51 (Martyn)

Let's all pray for Totto as he put this non-event in his Top 10. You Don't Have The Right is one of the girls' underwhelming ballads. When I heard they were working with Diane Warren I wasn't really that excited and that reaction ended up matching the level of excitement that this song brings. The song limps along until Una catches my attention while singing the line messing with my mind in a Mary J. Blige type voice. Then it limps along some more until the last minute or so where Vanessa breathes some much needed life into the song. Too little too late unfortunately.

 

46. Fall 36.88 Average

Highest Marks: #3 (Sean) #18 (Juliano) #20 (Joe)

Lowest Marks: #53 (Zach) #52 (Tim) #52 (Will)

Fall is the next song to drop out of the competition. Not many Chasing Lights album tracks remain now. This surprises me as Fall is their 20th best selling song and 3rd best selling non-single, but this is a countdown based on quality rather than success, and Fall is surely lacking in that department. The song isn't offensive but is somewhat of a snoozefest and is quite forgettable. It sound like something that would've been on Una's pre-Saturdays EP. Sean is a big fan of Fall, putting it at #3 and substantially helping its average.

 

45. Died In Your Eyes 36.63 Average

Highest Marks: #19 (Sean) #20 (Joe) #22 (Calum Hood)

Lowest Marks: #52 (Zach) #51 (Martyn) #49 (Juliano)

Glad we are knocking out all these boring ballads! The Sats have come up with some really amazing downtempo tracks so it's shocking that they are capable of stuff like this. Died In Your Eyes is the first Headlines! track to fall out and deservedly so. The song was also recorded by Kristinia Debarge and both versions are bland.

 

 

You Don't Have The Right is good thanks to Rochessa, Una ruins all of it. The only injustice is that Frankie's voice couldn't shine more.

 

Rochelle's ad-libs :drama: :wub: :heart: :heart: :heart:

 

Also a bit too drunk to even react to some of yall disgusting posts :( :(

Don't Let Me Dance Alone has grown on me slightly since I did this, but still not massively.

My love for DLMDA comes in waves. I happen to really be feeling it right now :P

37. Anywhere With You 32.81 Average
Highest Marks: #10 (Tim) #11 (Juliano) #18 (Cameron)
Lowest Marks: #50 (Ultraviolence) #49 (Jonjo) #42 (Liam)
Next to leave the countdown with an average of 32.81 is Anywhere With You. It's a nice song but many believe it sounds like a watered down Katy Perry track. Anywhere With You didn't receive many ultra-low scores, with only three members ranking it outside of their Top 40. It's certainly a hard one to hate!

36. Keep Her 32.69 Average
Highest Marks: #9 (Juliano) #14 (Totto) #19 (Sean)
Lowest Marks: #54 (Tim) #53 (Cameron) #46 (Lee) #46 (Hurricane)
Uh oh, where's Jay? Keep Her, which many wanted as a single off of Chasing Lights, is out next. I really love Keep Her and it's actually my most played track off Chasing Lights. Keep Her is a really great representation of all the early Sats material and is still a tune to this day. Sad to see that so many of you gave it low scores!

35. Gentleman 31.38 Average
Highest Marks: #7 (Totto) #12 (Sean) #16 (Zach)
Lowest Marks: #54 (April) #51 (Joe) #48 (Jonjo)
So 1999! Gentleman becomes our first single to drop out. I can't say I'm surprised that this is the least liked single but I am surprised it isn't a bit higher up. We all know what a disaster of a single Gentleman was, but the song itself isn't bad bar the flat production. The sad part about Gentleman flopping is had it been released any other week it would've been a solid Top 10, having sold 29,000 copies in its first week. It's a shame they can't figure out how to release on slower weeks.

I know everyone hates Gentleman so that's not a surprise, but Keep Her... guys come on.

 

Shut up Hurricane.

Edited April 27, 201510 yr by Totto

Biggest Gentleman hater! Slay! :cheer:

Quicker results please.

 

Don't make me pull out :frankie: