Jump to content

which song do you prefer? 17 members have voted

  1. 1. the original or shakira version?

    • Dance Like This (From Havana Nights)
      1
    • Hips Dont Lie
      16

Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Featured Replies

Posted
i personally perfer the original... who is that girl? :o
  • Replies 25
  • Views 1.8k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Hips don't lie-the original is bland as hell-the woman is Claudette Ortiz from City High who had a No.3 hit in 2001 with What would you do?...I find her voice boring particularly compared to Shakira...

claudette from city high is the singer but i prefer HDL, the contrast between wyclef and shakiras voice works much better plus shakira's unusual lyrics and song title give it that something extra

 

claudette's vocals iare quite boring and generic, her voice bugs me sometimes cause she is trying to sing like aaliyah especially in the second verse she rips of an aaliyah vocal blatantly i think 'back and forth' but there is only one aaliyah!!

 

 

HDL all the way for me.

 

I mean I like the original: it's catchy and a decent enough R&B song, the type id expect from an upcoming R&B singer in the summer, but theres something missing from it, kind of like it's missing the X-factor if you will :lol: and imo Shakira gives it that something which it never had before, something that attracted people to it, which DLT didn't have.

i personally perfer the original... who is that girl? :o

 

Claudette Ortiz, best known from the band City high, they sang 'What Would You Do' she has 2 sons with one of the members now! :o

Ha - I wonder what the answer will be to this question in a Shakira forum?

 

The best part of the song is the "I'm on tonight..." because that's the catchiest bit which isn't even in the original. The original is ok but it's pretty bland and non descript.

Edited by Ashley

LOL HIPS DON'T LIE THAT SONG WAS NOTHING BUT WITH SHAKIRA IT BECAME THE MOST PLAYED SONG IN POP HISTORY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! :wub:

Plus she wrote her lyrics !

 

ok so you xtina fan stop posting things that you obviously don't care! you just want to make a big deal about this !@!!!

 

and why not post something in CHRISTINA'S FORUM???? since aint no other man is a cover of an old song !!!!! i heard the original and i liked it!!!!

Edited by DAVELOVESHAKI

  • Author

Plus she wrote her lyrics !

 

ok so you xtina fan stop posting things that you obviously don't care! you just want to make a big deal about this !@!!!

 

and why not post something in CHRISTINA'S FORUM???? since aint no other man is a cover of an old song !!!!! i heard the original and i liked it!!!!

 

WTF!! :rolleyes:

 

i didnt want anything big at all, recently found out about the shakira cover of 'hips dont lie'!! just bringing it to peoples attention and seeing what they thought, genuine question IDIOT BOY!!

 

over 90% of my posts are in the christina forum so i think you will agree i do post enough there!! 'aint no other man' is not a cover just samples the 'do your thing honey' bit!! :rolleyes:

 

 

no fighting no fighting xtina is a fan of shakira's music and shakira likes xtina too, shakira and xtina fans are on the same team
  • Author
on my behalf i never came in here for a fight, its the dave who is trying to pick one... if he had a problem with the post he should of took it up with the forum moderator!!

I like ANOM ^_^ I prefer Candyman though, its got more oomph :wub: :P

 

no fighting no fighting xtina is a fan of shakira's music and shakira likes xtina too, shakira and xtina fans are on the same team

 

exactly, I personally dont see competition between Xtina & Shakira, there two different artists, but both have made a lasting name for themselves in the industry.

 

If anybody has any problems with the posts in the forum dont hesitate to contact me/Ashley :D

Edited by Exodus

its so easy to p*** off fan bases nowadays with the whole mine is better than yours lol we want peace and friendly competition!!
And each year the most successful artists of that year's fan bases fight none stop

That is a huge lie it not only samples that DO YOUR THING HONEY, it also samples the rhythm,beats music or whatever want to call it I heard the original song by an old jazz artist!!!!!!!!!

 

and don't call me stupid ok !!!!! :angry: :angry: :angry: :angry:

Edited by DAVELOVESHAKI

  • Author

:lol: grow up....

 

find the proof!! its news to the world mate... :rolleyes:

MATE!!!! it may be news for you but that is the truth !!!!!!!! ok whether you like it or NOT!!!!
  • Author
i would like it cause i LOVE the song but until you tell me and the millions of other christina fans to download it i will KNOW its untrue! :)

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.