thats true,they cant really say this one and that one copied them although cheery dear is prob only doing it for promo which is understandable

Has someone shoved something up her ass recently?

 

Hmm, I dunno, maybe her husband...? :lol: :lol:

 

Girls Aloud have done some fantastic songs... but they're hardly original, are they?

 

the show. one of the best songs ever!!!

the show is agood song and a strong POP song,no good advice was the best girls aloud song for me though

Cheryl has a point, the first time I heard it I thought it sounded like Girls Aloud-esue, maybe she only heard it the once then commented. It doesn’t mean she’s saying All Saints old stuff sound like them.

 

Girls Aloud seem to be getting a backlash now so they should bow out…as they have tried their best. Chemistry was a masterpiece, I have much respect for them releasing an album that’s diverse, that’s genre bending, that has really fantastic pop grooves and showed the style clearly developed with them and their partnership with Xenomania. But it obviously isn’t what the people wanna hear…so they’ve went all out for a commercial hit with Something Kinda Oooh…which is gonna do quite well I reckon.

 

They have their own style and I’m sick of the Spice Girls comparisons. My arse! Their songs sound nothing like Spice songs and they don’t sound like Steps or Atomic Kitten…or even Sugababes.

 

All Saints were hardly pioneers of pop either. One urban pop album and a 2nd William Orbit-y one going with the ‘in sound’ of the time…ohh lovely. Not to say they aren’t good just Girls Aloud work equally as hard, especially making sure they bring out their new songs.

 

if anything all saints were far to over rated in there day,some songs were good but some were c**p to

if anything all saints were far to over rated in there day,some songs were good but some were c**p to

 

I'll never forgive them for trashing the Chili Peppers' "Under the Bridge"....NEVER!!!!! <_<

 

A poignant and heartfelt song about drug addiction and deep personal loss rendered pop pap by a bunch of bimbos..... <_<

 

Have you seen All Saint's response?

 

http://www.thesun.co.uk/article/0,,2004580...6470414,00.html

 

:lol: hilarious.

Have you seen All Saint's response?

 

http://www.thesun.co.uk/article/0,,2004580...6470414,00.html

 

:lol: hilarious.

 

Good response. Melanie Blatt chose her words well it has to be said...

 

Still dont like the music though..... :P :lol:

 

Love it :lol:

It gets better...

 

http://www.mtv.co.uk/channel/mtvuk/news/12...swer_all_saints

 

Nadine and Sarah are letting Cheryl take on the Saints alone. :lol:

if anything all saints were far to over rated in there day,some songs were good but some were c**p to

 

I agree. People are confusing the novelty of All saints returning with their actual songs. They weren't that amazing and their new song is going for whats popular now. I dont know how they can attack Jump (which isnt a GA song) when they brought out covers themselves and milked their frist album dry. <_<

I agree. People are confusing the novelty of All saints returning with their actual songs. They weren't that amazing and their new song is going for whats popular now. I dont know how they can attack Jump (which isnt a GA song) when they brought out covers themselves and milked their frist album dry. <_<

If they're going for what's popular now name ONE hit song from this year that 'Rock Steady' sounds like.

 

I don't think you - or Cheryl - can.

 

I also don't think it's fair to see they attacked 'Jump' when Cheryl (who is yet to write a #1 hit herself) began this war of words.

Rock Steady isn't that far from Sugababes or even Girls Aloud.

 

All Cheryl said was sick of bands reforming. I agree with her, it's a novelty and a bandwagon thats becoming too full and it sounds like they're going for whats popular. All Saints replying by calling them "stupid silly girls" - thats hardly a good argument!!!!!!

 

They're trying to be patronising "Jump for my love - thats where I wanna be" when where GA are at the minute is Biology, Whole Lotta History etc - fantastic lyrics and fantastic songs. Not have a dig at a song and also an image from 3 years ago. :rolleyes: Shows how much they know about them. Anyone actually think about when All Saints came out, baggy combtas. Woo thats where it's at. :rolleyes:

 

And Cheryl isn't a writer, doesnt mean she doesn't work hard within Girls Aloud and shes clearly pissed of (as am I) that the general public cannot see fantastic, innovite, fresh pop music they've released especially over the last 2 years then All Saints come back and go for whats in. She obviously thought they'd rip off their style...which I doubt is true but she has every right to criticize another band when shes in the music industry working hard.

Cheryl from Girls aloud is an idiot! She thinks she is better than everyone else. All Saints were an original girl band and started way before them and produced alot of greats songs. Girls aloud haven't and are nothing but annoying waste of space in the charts! They should get rid of that twity singer! The Sugababes are way better than Girls Aloud!

 

LONG LIVE ALL SAINTS!

Cheryl always starts it and she just can't face the fact nobody gives a**** about her. She's not Victoria Beckham and marrying a frickin footballer doesn';t make you queen of the world you stupid wretched slag.

 

Long live Charlotte Church, Lily Allen, the All Saints and anybody else who puts this two bit piece of $h!t in her place - she makes me feel sick. :puke:

 

She thinks she IS Girls Aloud and she has an ego bigger than Rik Waller.

I hate the All Saints - always did - they were $h!te - Girls Aloud's music wipes the floors with them anyday imo but Cheryl needs a good kick up her saggy little skinny arse.

as much as I :wub: Cheryl :lol: they're completely different.

 

It's the Sugababes that should be quaking

Rock Steady isn't that far from Sugababes or even Girls Aloud.

 

All Cheryl said was sick of bands reforming.

 

she has every right to criticize another band when shes in the music industry working hard.

I asked you to name one hit song this year - by any band - that 'Rock Steady' was a little too similar to. You said the song was intentionally like 'whats popular now'. Yet you can't name any popular song it's like.

 

You just named two other girl bands.

 

Cheryl's comments were not solely about bands reforming. She claimed the All Saints sound was deliberately similar to that of Girls Aloud.

 

Cheryl said - in the opening post of this thread - "The new All Saints sound just sounds like us," Tweedy complained. "They must have looked at what's working at the moment and thought we'll go that way,"

 

So the All Saints responded. If she has the right to criticise, they have the right to respond.

 

No matter how hard she works or how 'pissed off' she and you may be that Girls Aloud are not lauded enough, I think Cheryl could afford to be a little more humble.

Edited October 12, 200618 yr by Tim

I asked you to name one hit song this year - by any band - that 'Rock Steady' was a little too similar to. You said the song was intentionally like 'whats popular now'. Yet you can't name any popular song it's like.

 

You just named two other girl bands.

 

I named bands because I dont think and never said it it sounds like any other song - you said that. A sound is a sound, doesn't have to be narrowed down to a song if it was then it'd be saying "this is a rip of that song". Which is exactly what "looking at what works at the minute and going with it" means.

 

As for Cheryl being humble, she comes across that way in the documentry and interviews. She doesn't owe All Saints anything & thats what I like about any band is if they speak their minds. She didn't come out and say "All Saints are c**p, they're stupid girls who know f*cking nothing" that would be not worth defending.

i agree that she was a bit harsh on all saints, she only feels threatened by them... just a normal reaction i think!! BUT i do agre with eveyrthing she says about charlotte church... 'FAT HEAD'!! :lol: LMAO