Now, now, I'm sure someone with a strong throwing arm could lob a dead pigeon quite far. I'm not sure how far you could lob Emily, but the answer will always be NOT FAR ENOUGH.

I was thinking this was all a little too SUBTLE then BAM out come the choir in the second verse. Phew.

God I hate this xmas track, he could have chose another track.

What a dull song choice, having the choir there cheapened the whole thing too.

Typical Matt, really. Vocally on point but so boring.

What a dull song choice, having the choir there cheapened the whole thing too.

 

X factor CHEAP? Never

Butter in a sandwich? That's disgusting

"It was like a sandwich without the butter"

 

:lol:

Oh Simon, let's not talk predictable when you've trotted out 'Mad World' for Little Miss Scottish Village.

 

First time poster, long-time reader. B-)

Matt was good but not brilliant.

Oh Simon, let's not talk predictable when you've trotted out 'Mad World' for Little Miss Scottish Village.

 

First time poster, long-time reader. B-)

 

Welcome to the Forum :D

Oh. Dear.

 

This 'Stars In Their Eyes' backing track mess...

 

Welcome to the Forum :D

 

Thank you. B-)

How are they STILL so bad when they're mostly being DROWNED OUT by backing track

Well that was absolutely hideous.

We need Dannii back to point out all those bum notes. Shocking.

That was awful just sounded like the original.

 

Nicole never heard the song before :mellow:

They really are seriously bad...

That was awful just sounded like the original.

 

Nicole never heard the song before :mellow:

 

East 17 didn't really make it STATESIDE so no real surprise. Far less egregious than Simon not knowing One Sweet Day back in the day.

I'm not sure a high note left their mouths when they attempted it.

That was actually much better than I expected. I quite liked it.