October 13, 200618 yr Girls Aloud, so many classic pop songs like 'No Good Advice', 'Wake Me Up', 'Biology', 'Jump' (although it was a cover). I do like All Saints, I just prefer Girls Aloud's catchy bubblegum pop stuff.
October 14, 200618 yr They're hardly similar. All Saints V Spice Girls would at least be a reasonable poll. I love Girls Aloud for their infectious, darn right dirty pop music of enternal greatness.
October 14, 200618 yr This is literally the easiest decision ever Gils Aloud = Bubblegum pop with very little talent. Songs all sound the same IMO All Saints = One of the few talented girl groups ever IMO, and actually wrote their own material (well at least one of them did) They had their own sound and made some great songs :D Absolutelly no contest for me. :smoke:
October 14, 200618 yr This is literally the easiest decision ever Gils Aloud = Bubblegum pop with very little talent. Songs all sound the same IMO All Saints = One of the few talented girl groups ever IMO, and actually wrote their own material (well at least one of them did) They had their own sound and made some great songs :D Girls Aloud have their own sound though.
October 15, 200618 yr GA all the way for me .. I've never really 'got' All Saints, I've always found their stuff pretty forgettable....
October 15, 200618 yr girls aloud by far,never ever and pure shores were the only 2 all saints songs i actually liked
October 15, 200618 yr Girls Aloud have their own sound though. It's not really their's though since they don't write the singles ;) I have no time for manafactured acts and don't get me started on their singing ability <_<
October 15, 200618 yr Well they can obviously sing if thousands of people voted for them. I wonder if All Saints would have the same effect if they were on reality tv. Urban pop and William Orbity sound isn't them writing their own stuff either. They do the lyrics so credit where credits due. It's Xenomania I'm a fan of. I like Girls Aloud a lot but I think if another band was releasing these songs I'd like than band too - theyre a good outlet for the tunes.
October 20, 200618 yr I couldn't decide so i didn't vote. Both are okay in their own way. okay but not great then?
October 20, 200618 yr It's a tough decision - All Saints have a lot of classic songs that I love listening to for memories and stuff, whereas Girls Aloud have some really good modern pop songs! ^_^ I vote GA.
Create an account or sign in to comment