NOTE: btmw :lol: Mikey Way made a two page news feature in K! this week, no MCR records made the top 50 indie classics in the NME.

Obv as forum areas are put in control of people without a firm guideplan of whats what obv most is down to personal taste. But really it shouldnt be down to personal taste it should be more of a customer service role there just to oversee the area, so if people think MCR should go in here as they have got that mindset from K! so be it!!!. Its only a guide of finding things easily for fans, and those cliants are the people mods should be there for. remember moderate is an adj 1. not extreme 2. self-restrained etc etc so i suppose if people are being moderators they should do it in moderation, not stamp there ideas all over the place. you are not getting paid for being here so why make a big fuss for the sake of a couple of bands some real metal dudes might not think as 'pure' (and this goes for both sides both forums both indie and metal)

 

Well, at the end of the day, it's not up to me, it's up to John ultimately.... I just think that if you dont draw a line somewhere otherwise you'll be deluged by all sorts of c**p that has nothing to do with Metal or Punk music.... HIM and Evanescence are fine they can be clearly identified as Hard Rock, but MCR are clearly nothing to do with Hard Rock, certainly not anymore at any rate, they're just Busted with eyeliner and vaguely 'dark' lyrics as far as I'm concerned... K! are giving people a totally false impression as to what Metal actually is, I dont think we should compound the error....

 

And Gerard Way is just proving what an utter tit he is if he genuinely believes any of MCR's songs have any right to be included in a Top 50 Indie Classics poll.... Yeah, MCR right up there with Joy Division, The Cure, Stone Roses, My Bloody Valentine, The Smiths, etc, aint they.....? NOT!!!!

Well, at the end of the day, it's not up to me, it's up to John ultimately.... I just think that if you dont draw a line somewhere otherwise you'll be deluged by all sorts of c**p that has nothing to do with Metal or Punk music....

 

as mod you gotta be there for your 'clients/public' rather than just yourself even if you users are not v well informed/stupid, and so rather tan confusing them and not knowing where to loook if they think it should go there let them have it. I doubt by letting in MCR there you gonna have people posting things about Sophie Ellis Bextor.

 

http://news.bbc.co.uk/olmedia/875000/images/_879261_sophie_theaudience150.jpghttp://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/thumb/7/79/Theaudience-Theaudience-125748.jpg/200px-Theaudience-Theaudience-125748.jpg

 

HIM and Evanescence are fine they can be clearly identified as Hard Rock, but MCR are clearly nothing to do with Hard Rock, certainly not anymore at any rate, they're just Busted with eyeliner and vaguely 'dark' lyrics as far as I'm concerned... K! are giving people a totally false impression as to what Metal actually is, I dont think we should compound the error....

 

And Gerard Way is just proving what an utter tit he is if he genuinely believes any of MCR's songs have any right to be included in a Top 50 Indie Classics poll.... Yeah, MCR right up there with Joy Division, The Cure, Stone Roses, My Bloody Valentine, The Smiths, etc, aint they.....? NOT!!!!

 

then move this thread to pop as obv its not indie and its not metal and the mods in the pop section dont give a damn what gets put in there as long as it makes their section the most popular.

Back on the actual topic rather than where it should be, I'm glad Teenagers is going to be the next single ^_^

Back on the actual topic rather than where it should be, I'm glad Teenagers is going to be the next single ^_^

 

Yes, that's right. ^_^ I'm also happy because of Teenagers. :cheer:

I don't disagree with that at all... Which is why I find it perplexing that you seem to want the Metal/Punk Forum to be as full of the same sort of mainstream bollocks for 12-year olds you're objecting to in Indie/Alternative....

 

Indie/Alternative Forum IS a joke

Dance Forum IS a joke

Metal/Punk IS being kept pure and within the actual genre conventions

 

so..... if 12 year olds started listening to one of your so-called metal underground bands - that band would be moved to the pop forum ??

 

The popularity of a band surely can't influence its classification??? I'd never even heard of the term 'emo' when I first listened to Black Parade and it sounded like heavy rock to me :unsure:

 

My Chem's first two albums are much more soild. It's just because they've gone commerical now and the teenage girl sluts have latched onto them that everybody starts to hate them. :rolleyes:

Anyway nuff said, I'm here to ask peeps to vote YES for their forum so we can avoid this c**p everytime somebody wants to post about them. ^_^

 

http://www.buzzjack.com/forums/index.php?showtopic=36880

Rubbish album, nothing going for it.

 

The lead singers name even sounds like a chocolate bar you can eat between meals.

so..... if 12 year olds started listening to one of your so-called metal underground bands - that band would be moved to the pop forum ??

 

well seeing as a new wave band such as the b-52s are in there, M.I.A's in there and Butch Vig's Garbage is in there, rule of thumb seems to be if it becomes pop it stays pop. however these might be in there because they feature girl vocalists. and obv girl vocalist can never be indie :lol: :lol:

this is the album that got me into MCR. Note to self, buy own copy insted of borrowing it all the time :o

this is the album that got me into MCR. Note to self, buy own copy insted of borrowing it all the time :o

Same ^

 

I bought the Black Parade and that persuaded me to buy their last album too

i love the black parade song and also this doll that i found http://gallerydolls.blogspot.com/2007/09/black-parade.html

well seeing as a new wave band such as the b-52s are in there, M.I.A's in there and Butch Vig's Garbage is in there, rule of thumb seems to be if it becomes pop it stays pop. however these might be in there because they feature girl vocalists. and obv girl vocalist can never be indie :lol: :lol:

 

 

I'm glad this thread has been bumped it reminds me that you are the biggest PRICK on this forum and that's a fact.

Airing your opinions again :lol:

 

Though I do agree