October 28, 200618 yr Hmm I'm scottish and most people I've spoken to hate the MacDonalds - and if it were the scottish vote that were saving them then Kerry wouldnt have been the one that left tonight.
October 28, 200618 yr Thank god Louise sent Kerry home. She was a mile better than the McDonneld Bro's but nowhere near as good as Ashley -_- Who is Louise?
October 28, 200618 yr Oh! I thought we may of had a new judge! :P So Simon now has 4 acts left while Sharon and Louis have 2. Does anyone think if one of Simon's acts end up in the bottom 2 then sharon and louis will do there usual thing and vote simon's act out even if they are better than the other one in the bottom two. As i recon all of simons acts exsept maybe Ashley are better than both Eton RD and the MacDonald Brothers. Also all 4 are better than Robert, but I think Ben is the best. Edited October 28, 200618 yr by martyn
October 28, 200618 yr Omg :o How acts like Kerry and Ashley can be in the bottom 3 when acts like Mcdonald Brothers and Robert are still in, I fail to comprehend.
October 28, 200618 yr Oh! I thought we may of had a new judge! :P So Simon now has 4 acts left while Sharon and Louis have 2. Does anyone think if one of Simon's acts end up in the bottom 2 then sharon and louis will do there usual thing and vote simon's act out even if they are better than the other one in the bottom two. As i recon all of simons acts exsept maybe Ashley are better than both Eton RD and the MacDonald Brothers. Also all 4 are better than Robert, but I think Ben is the best. I daresay the producers of the show will encourage the judges to keep the number of acts more even, so more judges are in the competition for longer.
October 28, 200618 yr Omg :o How acts like Kerry and Ashley can be in the bottom 3 when acts like Mcdonald Brothers and Robert are still in, I fail to comprehend. Unbelieveable :( Democracy is a bad thing at times when you consider some of the acts that are surviving phone votes
October 28, 200618 yr Unbelieveable :( Democracy is a bad thing at times when you consider some of the acts that are surviving phone votes I know :( Simon is just so right, McDonald Brothers are completely forgettable - who would buy their albums? Robert is more memorable and entertaining but he just does not have that star quality. I usually think Ashley is $h!t but he's growing on me, he did an alright job tonight. Louis was right to get rid of Kerry because all her performances so far have been rather boring. She did better in the auditions.
October 28, 200618 yr It is because they are attractive young men and the majority of voters are young females.
October 28, 200618 yr ^^ Attractive.....debateable. This is the problem with shows like this, the voting audience does consist of young females, so it's blokes who tend to win them. But then their records don't sell and they flop :( ...Except Steve Brook$h!te, he flopped becuase he was $h!t and a t***
October 28, 200618 yr ^^ Attractive.....debateable. This is the problem with shows like this, the voting audience does consist of young females, so it's blokes who tend to win them. But then their records don't sell and they flop :( ...Except Steve Brook$h!te, he flopped becuase he was $h!t and a t*** Steve was quite a good singer I thought, just that he was given the wrong material in the album, when he wanted to choose his own songs Cowell dumped him
October 28, 200618 yr It is because they are attractive young men and the majority of voters are young females. Sad but true, looks are more important than talent these days :( The likes of Alison Moyet and Mama Cass etc would not have lasted past 2 rounds of X Factor
October 28, 200618 yr ^^ AI does have a higher level of talent. And 6 times the population to choose a talent pool from American Idol should just be Country Idol though as to succeed in it you seem to have to be good at singing country ballads
October 28, 200618 yr ^^^ That comment is completely false, but this isn't a discussion about AI. I personally think that the Mcdonald workers should have gone 1st week, and why they are still here I fail to comprehend.
October 28, 200618 yr ^^^ That comment is completely false, but this isn't a discussion about AI. I personally think that the Mcdonald workers should have gone 1st week, and why they are still here I fail to comprehend. Kelly Clarkson and Carrie Underwood were both essentially country ballad singers The best reality tv music series so far has been Rock Star INXS I loved that
October 28, 200618 yr Author Sharon and Louis have both lost 2 acts, Simon is bound to lose an act next week, I reckon Nikitta or Ray will go next week.
October 28, 200618 yr I'm shocked that Dionne went tonight, why?! she's brilliant, what is wrong with the people voting? the McD brothers are much worse they should've gone ages ago. <_<
Create an account or sign in to comment