I thought Homesick was ineligible for Worst Single, I’m so confused. It’s neither a single nor an album track

It was, but things got complicated in that round and we've established a definition of what a single is that is being applied consistently to everyone. We should've established it sooner but didn't anticipate the Calvin Open Wide drama.

 

It'd be unfair if we allowed Homesick in non-single rounds having established this definition.

You might just all have to vote for Garden :(

I refuse!

 

ROB PLEASE RESCUE US

ROB PLEASE RESCUE US

 

#JusticeForHomesick

 

It can't be an album track one round and then a single the next! It was only a single in Belgium and The Netherlands, and an album track everywhere else!

 

 

To be honest I do think it is slightly unfair, but I don’t know how differently Homesick would perform

To be honest I do think it is slightly unfair, but I don’t know how differently Homesick would perform

The only thing that's unfair was that it wasn't available for use in the "worst single" category, before we established the rule

To be honest I do think it is slightly unfair, but I don’t know how differently Homesick would perform

I honestly don't see us qualifying without Homesick. The other choices are tragic

I think what qualifies as a single changing each round is unfair but ok?

I think what qualifies as a single changing each round is unfair but ok?

It's not changing each round. The definition was established as a result of some controversy, and the same definition has been in place since (and will continue to be for the rest of the competition). I'm sorry this created mixed messages for Dua, but ultimately we have to apply it consistently or other forums will accuse us of being unfair.

I think what qualifies as a single changing each round is unfair but ok?

It is unfair! Not our fault that there have been criteria errors and inconsistencies!

I personally prefer Garden to Homesick so I’m good, I don’t think either would do well tbf, PrayForDua please xoxo

I personally prefer Garden to Homesick so I’m good, I don’t think either would do well tbf, PrayForDua please xoxo

We're going to have to get a promo schedule together for this round!

 

I suggest the following

- Promote in the Shoutbox

- Promote in The Lounge Promo Thread

- Change User Names to #VoteGarden

- Change signatures with a link to #VoteGarden

- A Garden Listening Party Thread

- Garden Appreciation Thread

- Listen To Garden 5 Times Challenge

make sure you shazam Garden!!

 

We're going to have to get a promo schedule together for this round!

 

I suggest the following

- Promote in the Shoutbox

- Promote in The Lounge Promo Thread

- Change User Names to #VoteGarden

- Change signatures with a link to #VoteGarden

- A Garden Listening Party Thread

- Garden Appreciation Thread

- Listen To Garden 5 Times Challenge

Why not! We love to see it

I honestly don't see us qualifying without Homesick. The other choices are tragic

You could send a spoken word track of Dua saying she hates the gays and she'd probably still qualify x

You could send a spoken word track of Dua saying she hates the gays and she'd probably still qualify x

it’s actually spelt dualify

Go vote for all time classic and era-defining ballad album track Garden!!!

listening to the playlist now and we definitely could have sent Genesis comparing it to Unusual You by Britney Spears :)

The results in the flash poll.

 

Either way, thank you to all the people who submitted there and don't forget to vote for "Garden" in this round.

Garden finished top 3 after all :cheer:

 

06/07 Dua Lipa [X-05-01-07-02-02-03]

 

Dua is safe through next round :cheer:

 

Question though, she has only one era while second era is still going but does Break My Heart applies to this round since it's the last single of the current era?!!

 

We don't know if we are going to get further singles etc. etc.