14 hours ago14 hr Confirmed (again).It’s amazing how many songs I consider instrumentals do have some sort of small vocal element to them.Or they use a vocal sample as an ‘instrument’ even when lyrics are not discernible, like my first confirmation.
14 hours ago14 hr Oh if we're counting non-lyrical vocals as vocals still then the song I am maybe sending to the next BJSC might have not been allowed here either oop xo (as it does have substantial contribution of... sounds made by a human's mouth, but I'd definitely still consider it to be an instrumental)No such issue with the song I did send here though.
14 hours ago14 hr 37 minutes ago, gooddelta said:It’s amazing how many songs I consider instrumentals do have some sort of small vocal element to them.Or they use a vocal sample as an ‘instrument’ even when lyrics are not discernible, like my first confirmation.Both of these scenarios happened with two of my entries. My second entry however was most definitely an instrumental so am shocked it was disallowed tbh.
13 hours ago13 hr 13 minutes ago, earthisturning said:Both of these scenarios happened with two of my entries. My second entry however was most definitely an instrumental so am shocked it was disallowed tbh.I don’t know which ones you sent (we are sent the song list without usernames to remove any bias) but my reasoning is that anything with significant vocalisations (even if not lyrics) doesn’t qualify as an instrumental in keeping with how the theme has been described in the OP
13 hours ago13 hr 2 minutes ago, danG said:I don’t know which ones you sent (we are sent the song list without usernames to remove any bias) but my reasoning is that anything with significant vocalisations (even if not lyrics) doesn’t qualify as an instrumental in keeping with how the theme has been described in the OPEh I guess mine falls into that category. I accept full liability for my first entry being disallowed though as I didn't realise how vocal it was at first.
Create an account or sign in to comment