January 31, 200718 yr You haven't actually spent enough time slagging off their actual music than their image and who you think they are. So their image is targeted a certain way - so what. When they're on my mp3 player I am not thinking about what they look like - I appreciate the songs and like the music. And I'll listen to punk songs when I want to hear punk...I just dont take GC as seriously as you do. And I dont need to make anything as I clearly dont have a problem were this topic is, you started attacking them for not being 'punk' - I hope the topic stays here and that young people on Buzzjack now think they are where punk begins and ends it's legacy...now I know it'll annoy you even more. :dance: :dance: :dance: Well, they're not Punk, that's a simple fact, I object to things being mislabelled.... I dont take GC seriously, they are a sh!t band who play sh!tty assed lame-o Yankee c**p that seems to pass for 'alternative' these days.... You just dont have a clue about music do you mate...? And it has no place on a Metal/Punk forum... The only reason John the Mod tolerates this utter sh!te infesting his Forum is to keep the post counts up....
January 31, 200718 yr The only reason John the Mod tolerates this utter sh!te infesting his Forum is to keep the post counts up.... that and i can't be arsed to move it :lol:
January 31, 200718 yr Well, they're not Punk, that's a simple fact, I object to things being mislabelled.... I dont take GC seriously, they are a sh!t band who play sh!tty assed lame-o Yankee c**p that seems to pass for 'alternative' these days.... You just dont have a clue about music do you mate...? I think you take it seriously as you clearly have a lot to say about GC - a band who you dont like. I have loads of friends who like them and we all dont think they're punk - that is having a clue about music surely? And on their Myspace they're labelled as: Good Charlotte Pop Punk / Pop Punk / Pop Punk I don't think they're punk but they obviously know and admit they are pop and have a pop sound so they only people who have issues are the the non-fans. And I wont take anyone on an Internet forum telling me what my musical knowledge is, I'll save it for critics and producers and anyone involved in the music business I have contact with...so that ain't even regestering with me. I can appreciate when something is fun pop punk & not which is what GC are. Again i been hearing this since 2002 and people are still saying the exact same things about them and there's no conlusion. You don't think they're punk then fine repeating it all the time is just not doing anything. Perhaps move the topic to pop as I really like this tune and was hoping to read what people thought of it. :blink:
February 1, 200718 yr Again i been hearing this since 2002 and people are still saying the exact same things about them and there's no conlusion. You don't think they're punk then fine repeating it all the time is just not doing anything. Perhaps move the topic to pop as I really like this tune and was hoping to read what people thought of it. :blink: And I've been hearing since a lot earlier than 2002 that this sort of horrendous Yankee crud is, like, so "fukkin' Punk Rock man" by fukktards such as MTV, the Music Industry and braindead American teenagers who think they're being so shocking.... I can buy that NOFX are pretty Punk, and Rancid as well, and Green Day and The Offspring, up to a point.... But Blink, Sum 41 or GC, naaaaah.....
February 1, 200718 yr Fair enough that would annoy anyone and I cant speak for everyone on here but I'm not an employee of MTV, a part of the Music Industry or a braindead American teenager. It's not that nice that we should read aggressive words like that when it's not actually directed at us as we don't believe that or said that.
February 2, 200718 yr It's ok but they seem to be changing direction after there last disastorous album,but i think there are way too many bands out at the moment that are way better,and i doubt they will be taken serious by most teens,except girls and wee children who think their 'emo' by listeing to this 'pop-punk' band. Edited February 2, 200718 yr by FallPanicBoyApparatus
February 3, 200718 yr Good Charlotte definitley aren't punk and I know that as I am a fan of punk bands such as Sex Pistols and The Ramones but I personally think that GC are good at what music they're making no matter what genre it is. Edited February 3, 200718 yr by TheOrdinaryArcticBoy
February 3, 200718 yr imho they are just another mtv creation. i would say it's sin to call them punk band - just compare gc and the exploited. peace
February 4, 200718 yr imho they are just another mtv creation. i would say it's sin to call them punk band - just compare gc and the exploited. peace 100% Truth... I've no real issue with them as a band (I cant stand their music though..), I just wish people would stop making up outlandish claims that they're 'Alternative' or 'Punk'...
February 4, 200718 yr 100% Truth... I've no real issue with them as a band (I cant stand their music though..), I just wish people would stop making up outlandish claims that they're 'Alternative' or 'Punk'... I just read the whole thread and only 1 person said they were Punk and that was This Charming Man, who admitted he wasn't sure where to put them & was talking of terms of where to this should be on the forum. But we all get the grief anyway. :blink:
Create an account or sign in to comment