Jump to content

Featured Replies

So that's there excuse for being $h!tter than had the other 2 have made it?

 

Well the whole point of releasing this song is to raise money for Comic Relief. Using the biggest girl bands atm is the best way to sell the records and raise the most money.

I highly doubt they'd choose All Saints who's album has just flopped, when they have a girl band who in the past year have scored three top 10 singles, a number 1 album and a been on an arena tour!

  • Replies 102
  • Views 7.2k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Well the whole point of releasing this song is to raise money for Comic Relief. Using the biggest girl bands atm is the best way to sell the records and raise the most money.

I highly doubt they'd choose All Saints who's album has just flopped, when they have a girl band who in the past year have scored three top 10 singles, a number 1 album and a been on an arena tour!

Yeah I was joking

 

It is cheesy, but it's there to promote Children In Need and I agree using the biggest names will do that the best

The song sounds pretty cheesy, like cheep techno

 

You must be either hearing a different song, or not know what techno is

I'm very disappointed by this. I was expecting an explosive cover as they had a lot to work with but no, bland bland bland...

 

Me too...It was enjoyabe for like 5 minutes but it just hasn't got the power of the original.

I do still like it but I am also starting to feel quite dissapointed as I was expecting it to sound a lot more professional and edgey than it actually is and I am noticing this as I listen to it more, however it's pleasant enough.

Edited by TheOrdinaryArcticBoy

TALK ABOUT THIS IN THE GIRLS ALOUD FORUM PEOPLE :P

I thought this was awful when I first heard it.

 

Its now grown on me massivley though, should be huge. ^_^

I thought this was awful when I first heard it.

 

Its now grown on me massivley though, should ge huge. ^_^

:cheer:

Ooo i must hear this, but i couldn't find it on that website :cry:

For everyone who hasn't heard it yet, go to myspace and search for Girls Aloud, its up on their profile now, the page with the girls in a black and white photo!! (if that helps)

 

I heard i today for the first time and i enjoyed it, hopefully it will sell huge amounts because its for charity, the voices of the girls are more impressive than i was expecting, but it doesn't really have the punch of theoriginal, but there something about that just makes me smile and sing along (cant say the same for my typing skills)

 

will definetly be buying this in March!!!!

 

Can I just say having heard it twice...

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

I think this is arguably the worst cover version of all-time. Musically it is just a total mess, they have taken everything great about the Aerosmith v Run DMC collaboration and have completely and utterly destroyed it.

 

 

 

This is by some distance the worst thing that either band have done in their careers.

 

Which is quite an achievement from two pop bands whom I actually quite like.

 

 

 

In short it is the musically equivalent of Jade, Danielle & Jo thinking that doing CBB would be a good career move.

 

If there is any karma in the world then both bands will split before the end of 2007.

 

Suddenly the comeback All Saints album "Studio 1" does not seem so bad. And if I was Geri Halliwell, Mel B, Mel C, Emma Bunton & Victoria Beckham then I would be laughing my head off at this career suicide of a charity single.

i wish people would stop trying to compare it directly to Run DMC/Aerosmith.

 

They are two pop acts :rolleyes: It was never gonna be the same, and I think there are plenty of covers out there that are far worse ^_^

some are you are over-reacting abit considering its a charity single, dont't get so annoyed!

its not breathtaking, but fun and will do well in my opinion.

 

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.