Posted March 22, 200718 yr Promises Vs. Freedom It Only Takes A Minute Vs. Old Before I Die I Found Heaven Vs. Lazy Days A Million Love Songs Vs. Angels Could It Be Magic Vs. Let Me Entertain You Why Can't I Wake Up With You Vs. Millennium Pray Vs. No Regrets / Antmusic ReLight My Fire Vs. Strong Babe Vs. She's The One / It's Only Us Everything Changes Vs. Rock DJ Love Ain't Here Anymore Vs. Kids Sure Vs. Supreme Back For Good Vs. Let Love Be Your Energy Never Forget Vs. Eternity / The Road To Mandalay How Deep Is Your Love Vs. Somethin' Stupid Patience Vs. Feel Shine Vs. Come Undone Four Minute Warning (Mark) Vs. Something Beautiful Child (Mark) Vs. Sexed Up Clementine (Mark) Vs. Radio Makin' Out ( Mark) Vs. Misunderstood Forever Love (Gary) Vs. Tripping Love Won't Wait (Gary) Vs. Advertising Space So Help Me Girl (Gary) Vs. Rudebox Open Road (Gary) Vs. Lovelight I've left out Sin Sin Sin, Shes Madonna & South Of The Border, this is to even it out and they didnt make top 10 anyway. Edited March 22, 200718 yr by Andy.
March 22, 200718 yr Freedom Old Before I Die Lazy Days Angels Let Me Entertain You Millennium No Regrets / Antmusic Strong She's The One / It's Only Us Rock DJ Kids Supreme Back For Good Vs. Let Love Be Your Energy Eternity / The Road To Mandalay Somethin' Stupid Feel Come Undone Something Beautiful Sexed Up Radio Misunderstood Tripping Advertising Space Rudebox Loveliight This was just too easy :lol:
March 22, 200718 yr Author Promises Vs. Freedom =??? It Only Takes A Minute Vs. Old Before I Die I Found Heaven Vs. Lazy Days A Million Love Songs Vs. Angels Could It Be Magic Vs. Let Me Entertain You Why Can't I Wake Up With You Vs. Millennium Pray Vs. No Regrets / Antmusic ReLight My Fire Vs. Strong Babe Vs. She's The One / It's Only Us Everything Changes Vs. Rock DJ Love Ain't Here Anymore Vs. Kids Sure Vs. Supreme Back For Good Vs. Let Love Be Your Energy Never Forget Vs. Eternity / The Road To Mandalay How Deep Is Your Love Vs. Somethin' Stupid Patience Vs. Feel Shine Vs. Come Undone Four Minute Warning (Mark) Vs. Something Beautiful Child (Mark) Vs. Sexed Up Clementine (Mark) Vs. Radio Makin' Out ( Mark) Vs. Misunderstood Forever Love (Gary) Vs. Tripping =??? Love Won't Wait (Gary) Vs. Advertising Space So Help Me Girl (Gary) Vs. Rudebox Open Road (Gary) Vs. Loveliight Take That = 12 Robbe = 10 Edited March 22, 200718 yr by Andy.
March 22, 200718 yr Yea, I would imagine most of us are primarily robbie fans, so we may not be the most biased group to vote, LOL! Just mark me down for 25 for Robbie! :lol:
March 22, 200718 yr Author ^ He was in Take That though so you dont have to vote for every Robbie song just because hes your favorite artist? Just be fair..:unsure:
March 22, 200718 yr I was never a TT fan though. And I'm still not. It's not really gonna be much of a contest :lol: Shine v Come Undone? :blink: :lol:
March 22, 200718 yr Freedom Old Before I Die Lazy Days Angels Let Me Entertain You Millennium No Regrets / Antmusic Strong She's The One / It's Only Us Rock DJ Kids Supreme Back For Good Eternity / The Road To Mandalay Somethin' Stupid Feel Come Undone Something Beautiful Sexed Up Radio Misunderstood Tripping Advertising Space Rudebox Lovelight Take That have some good songs like Back For God, Never Forget, Babe, Everything Changes... But imo those songs aren't better then Robbie's singles. I only choose Back For God.
March 22, 200718 yr Freedom Old Before I Die Lazy Days Angels Let Me Entertain You Millennium No Regrets / Antmusic Strong She's The One / It's Only Us Rock DJ Kids Supreme Back For Good Never Forget How Deep Is Your Love Feel Come Undone (by so many country miles :lol: ) Four Minute Warning Sexed Up Radio Misunderstood Tripping Advertising Space Rudebox Lovelight Robbie: 21 Take That: 4 TT have had some classic pop songs, but comparing them like this just shows that the majority of Robbie’s singles are just in a completely different leugue for me. I am suprised I picked 4 for TT, but it just happened that their best one's were up against my least fave Rob singles :lol:
March 23, 200718 yr What a daft topic I know all of TT songs as much as I know Robbie's and they are in a totally different league, and I don't think fairness comes into it. Taste does. How can you say Pray is a better track than No Regrets, or Could It Be Magic better than Let me Entertain You. LMEY has become a signature tune, Could it be Magic is more associated with Barry Manilow than TT. I Found Heaven against Lazy Days totally different concepts and composition. jeez - you have got me going now lol..you even have a cover over an original song for crying out loud, no comparision. I do like Never Forget and Everything Changes but the latter is Robbie anyway. But how the hell you can put the god awful Shine over the brilliant Come Undone says it all really. Come Undone is pure class. Popcorn against credible gritty rock I am afraid I do not know any of the Gary Barlow singles so cannot compare those at all. So here is my score. I think you will get the responses you favour more on the TT forum Andy. Take That = 1 Robbie = 24 Edited March 23, 200718 yr by Susie
March 23, 200718 yr Promises It Only Takes A Minute Lazy Days A Million Love Songs Let Me Entertain You Millennium Pray ReLight My Fire Babe Everything Changes Kids Supreme Back For Good Never Forget How Deep Is Your Love Patience Shine Four Minute Warning Child (Mark) Clementine Misunderstood Forever Love Love Won't Wait So Help Me Girl Open Road
March 23, 200718 yr I will do this as I'm bored. <_< Old Before I Die Lazy Days Angels Let Me Entertain You Millennium No Regrets Strong She's The One / It's Only Us Rock DJ Kids Supreme Back For Good Never Forget How Deep Is Your Love Feel Come Undone Four Minute Warning (Mark) Sexed Up Radio Misunderstood Trippi Advertising Space Rudebox Loveliight There. ^_^
March 23, 200718 yr Freedom Old Before I Die Lazy Days Angels Let Me Entertain You Millennium No Regrets / Antmusic Strong She's The One / It's Only Us Rock DJ Kids Supreme Let Love Be Your Energy Eternity / The Road To Mandalay Somethin' Stupid Feel Come Undone Something Beautiful Sexed Up Radio Misunderstood Tripping Advertising Space Rudebox Lovelight All 25 go to Robbie...although i dont mind Back for good and Could it be magic
March 23, 200718 yr Yes Robbie was in Take That and they did have some good songs but compared to Rob's solo work they don't even come close to how absolutely amazing Rob's own songs are. Sorry Andy, Rob's songs will always win out with me.
April 4, 200718 yr Promises Vs. Freedom It Only Takes A Minute Vs. Old Before I Die I Found Heaven Vs. Lazy Days A Million Love Songs Vs. Angels Could It Be Magic Vs. Let Me Entertain You Why Can't I Wake Up With You Vs. Millennium Pray Vs. No Regrets / Antmusic ReLight My Fire Vs. Strong Babe Vs. She's The One / It's Only Us Everything Changes Vs. Rock DJ Love Ain't Here Anymore Vs. Kids Sure Vs. Supreme Back For Good Vs. Let Love Be Your Energy Never Forget Vs. Eternity / The Road To Mandalay How Deep Is Your Love Vs. Somethin' Stupid Patience Vs. Feel Shine Vs. Come Undone Four Minute Warning (Mark) Vs. Something Beautiful Child (Mark) Vs. Sexed Up Clementine (Mark) Vs. Radio Makin' Out ( Mark) Vs. Misunderstood Forever Love (Gary) Vs. Tripping Love Won't Wait (Gary) Vs. Advertising Space So Help Me Girl (Gary) Vs. Rudebox Open Road (Gary) Vs. Lovelight I never was a TT fan....sorry :cry:
