Posted October 17, 200717 yr Both woman have both battled and survived cancer, and returned back to music with big comebacks. But who has the best and who'll have the biggest comeback? Anastacia - LOA. 250k Anastacia - Anastacia (album) - 1.1 million Will Kylie's comeback be more sucessfull then what Ana's was in 2004?
October 17, 200717 yr No i dont think it will sell A Million. Kylie's album should easily go 2x Platinum though. Nelly Furtado's Comeback can now be officially named the best one EVER.
October 17, 200717 yr nah i very much doubt Kylie would sell that much plus the Anastacia track was alot better
October 17, 200717 yr Yeah but Nelly didn't have breast cancer... I think Kylie's 2000 comeback was bigger - I mean she went through the second half of the 90s with so many flops and then wham right back and top and she's been right back up there again since. Doubt this comeback will do as good as Anastacia's one.
October 17, 200717 yr Author Cant Get You Out Of My Head era was when she shined the most. 2 Hearts is to much like Golfrapp, not that there's anything wrong with that but she should stick to disco!
October 17, 200717 yr 'Left Outside Alone' is the much better song of the two. I think with songs like 'In My Arms', if Kylie releases that and has more in the same calibre as that on her album she has the potential to make this a HUGE comeback and a big seller in the longrun.
October 18, 200717 yr No i dont think it will sell A Million. Kylie's album should easily go 2x Platinum though. Nelly Furtado's Comeback can now be officially named the best one EVER. Single wise def Anastasia. I think Kylies album will do well though. Hopfully 3x platinum And what has Nelly Furtados comeback got to do with Kylie and Anastasia Post-Cancer comeback lol. Cant Get You Out Of My Head era was when she shined the most. 2 Hearts is to much like Golfrapp, not that there's anything wrong with that but she should stick to disco! Why should she stick to one type of music. Id hate it if she did that. Even if a style doesnt work, I prefer artists to try all sorts of different styles.
October 18, 200717 yr I'd just like to say that I hadn't even HEARD of Anastacia till I joined Buzzjack. xD Not that I dislike her or anything; I still haven't heard enough to fairly judge, but...I had heard of Kylie much before. Can't Get You Out Of My Head was a huge hit in the US. As for Kylie's new comeback? Well, I guess we'll see. ;P I want 2 Hearts to do better than Left Outside Alone, and I like the song a whole lot more, but a lot of people just dislike it cuz it isn't disco. =/
October 18, 200717 yr Thing is even before the cancer Anastacia had just had two albums which had both sold very well. Kylie's last studio album was Body Language which if I remember correctly had just the one week in the top 10. I can see Kylie's having a huge No1 single easily. The album will probably also make No1, but I don't see it being a long running success.
October 19, 200717 yr well anastacia has an advantage on the singles front in a way as single sales were higher in general in 2004, i hope kylie can beat her sales of course which she may well do but she will out peak her as in 2 hearts will be a definite top 2 hit with number 1 more likely
October 20, 200717 yr As much as I like "2 Hearts", "Left Outside Alone" was one of the best songs of 2004, no question :D
October 20, 200717 yr I'd just like to say that I hadn't even HEARD of Anastacia till I joined Buzzjack. xD Not that I dislike her or anything; I still haven't heard enough to fairly judge, but...I had heard of Kylie much before. Can't Get You Out Of My Head was a huge hit in the US. As for Kylie's new comeback? Well, I guess we'll see. ;P I want 2 Hearts to do better than Left Outside Alone, and I like the song a whole lot more, but a lot of people just dislike it cuz it isn't disco. =/ I was the same as you were, never heard of Anastacia pre-BJ. (I live in America too) You should definetely check her out, she's AMAZING. I also voted for LOA. :wub:
Create an account or sign in to comment