Its between Avril, Rihanna and Leona for me can't make my mind up!

Edited October 21, 200717 yr by Andy.

I shocked myself for voting for Alicia Keys :o

 

She has a fantastic voice ^_^ And it's a great song :wub:

Alicia, easily. How on earth is Leona a comeback? You need to have an album before you can make a comeback. :/ She wasn't even gone long either.

 

Leona Lewis - Bleeding Love Doesn't count.

Rihanna - Umbrella Was fun/good at the time, awful now.

Kelly Clarkson - Never Again Terrible.

Alicia Keys - No One Brilliant, easily the best here.

Kylie Minogue - 2 Hearts Passable. Better than her normal stuff.

Kelly Rowland - Like This Terrible.

Avril - Girlfriend Terrible.

Jennifer Lopez - Do It Well Flush.

Britney Spears - Gimme More Terrible, badly managed comeback.

Mutya - Real Girl Terrible.

 

M.I.A, Feist or even Roisin Murphy should have been included.

i have voted kylie but to be honest every one of them for me have made hugely disappointing comebacks

It's not much of a Diva comeback (that'll be next year). But from that list, Avril has the best album out of the bunch (even though Girlfriend is an awful song) so I'll pick Avril. ^_^

Rihanna or Leona.

 

Mutya's has been good.

 

Kylies has been the most talked about and yet one of the most disappointing.

Leona Lewis - AMAZING comeback. Everything about it has been amaze.

Rihanna - Good long term. I don't think anyone expected Rihanna to come back with a 10 week #01 :lol:

Kelly Clarkson - Nowhere near as good as her previous stuff and was a bit messy.

Alicia Keys - Amazing song and one of her best of her career so far. I really hope it makes Top 10 here.

Kylie Minogue - Meh. Nowhere near as good as her previous stuff. It's okay though.

Kelly Rowland - Eugh, terrible song. Bland bland bland. Nowhere near as good as ''Stole'' or ''Dilemma'', and she seems to have disappeared.

Avril Lavigne - Really good in the long run. One of her best eras.

Jennifer Lopez - Great song, not as good as her previous stuff but still great. Don't understand the flop at all though.

Britney Spears - The song itself, amazing. Everything else, terrible.

Mutya Buena - Boring. :(

Please can someone change my vote from Bleeding Love to No One? Lol.

Wouldn't call them all divas or include Leona tbh but :lol:

 

Hmm well Girlfriend was great at the time but Avril's album really disappointed me.

I'm torn between Alicia and Kylie but I'll go for the latter.

I'd count Leona as a comeback as alot of people said she flop like other reality TV contestants after a "Moment Like This". I went with Rihanna in the end!

Mutya - Real Girl

Mutya for me.

Mutya for me.

 

Still like the Sugababes but they were better with her.

 

Half of those aren't even comebacks, but I went with Alicia Keys.

Avril. I wasn't even waiting for her to come back, but she returned with her two best singles so far and made me a fan, so I have to go with her ^_^

Leona followed by Rihanna then Britters :heart:

I'd like to say Kylie, but no... Rihanna.

 

Where is Sophie Ellis-Bextor? She'd get my vote if she was here.

I voted Leona! But almost went for Britney.

As much as I complain about X Factor, I can't deny Leona's amazingly talented ... but I'm just not fond of Bleeding Love :( So I went for Brit.

That was hard. I voted for Britney, but I also give high praise to Kylie, Rihanna, Leona, Avril, Jennifer, and Alicia. I really hate Kelly Clarkson and Kelly Rowland's comeback singles, if there were better choices made, I think the comeback would have been stronger for both.