Jump to content

Kylie vs Spice Girls: Who is more deserving at #1 (12/Nov)? 85 members have voted

  1. 1. Kylie vs Spice Girls: Who is more deserving at #1 (12/Nov)?

    • Kylie - 2 Hearts
      46
    • Spice Girls - Headlines
      37

Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Featured Replies

  • Replies 44
  • Views 2.6k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

The Kylie single is an identical re-work of the Kish Mauve original - exactly the same, down to the breathy 'ahhhh's'. Totally unoriginal.

 

TALK ABOUT UNFAIR critiscism, you make out the original was some kind of hit(when it never charted) therefore little talent in such a sure fire, ready made hit when nothing could be further from the truth - basically it was equivalent to ANY DEMO the general public haven't heard before that a popstar would record (eg EXACTLY the same situation as CGYOOMH which was initially offered to Sophie EB whose team rejected it - bet you weren't hurling the same UNORIGINAL accusation at Kylie when she released that :nocheer: ).

 

 

....and for any more IGNORAMUSES out there ; Kish Mauve is basically a front name for producer/songwriter Jim Eliot’s work, Kylie's team enquired if he had any material for a new Kylie album and he sent them 2 Hearts. Both Kylie AND Parlo etc were VERY keen to record it and Jim Eliot worked with Kylie on his track to produce (vocals + instrumentation) the version thats now in the public domain - ie exactly the same proccess that happened with the original demo of CGYOOMH (with Rob Davis + Cathy Dennis being the producers,writers and Cathy(an ex pop star and old peer of Kylie) also doing the demo vocals) - OBVIOUSLY the demo would sound similar to the released version if it was produced by the same team who didn't want the hit potential of the original diluted.. :manson:

 

I'm not keen on either song but Kylie's is alot more credible than the Spice Girls, so I voted for her.
Both are very poor in my opinion and I would much rather Leona stayed at #1 and beat both them. :heehee:

Leona will get a 4th week!

Kylie #2, Spices #3 with them going to #1 the week after.

 

Both songs are quite poor compared to their previous efforts IE some of the best pop records of all time.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.