So given the choice between the opinions of a jury and a judge who heard all the evidence and a few people - who were not in court for any of the evidence - prepared to share their ignorant opinions on the internet, you'd go with the latter? I really do despair sometimes.

 

 

Agreed mate... The facts are that the testimony given by Carr in court was pretty crucial to securing Huntley's conviction, that's what the Tabloids and the ignorant masses baying for her blood actually ignore... Yes, she made a mistake (for which she rightly did the time for), but she did the right thing in the end by testifying against him in court, also, she was by no means the only one that Huntley was able to manipulate or fool, he manipulated the MEDIA :lol: :lol: They gave him an interview on TV... Hmmm, maybe that's why they're so pissed off, they were made to look like utter tw@ts by Huntley, so they're taking it out on Maxine Carr....

well thankfully we dont live by 'mob rule' <_<, where would the lawlessness stop?...

 

she was a dimwit, and was easily manipulated by huntley, she is guilty of being dumb, and in those circumstances how do any of us know how we would have acted?...

 

remember, she DID NOT KILL THE GIRLS , i wouldnt support her one bit if she did, but thye law of the country states that she has paid her dues for her part....

 

I'd be willing to bet the likes of CrazyChris would balk at the idea of Sharia Law, but if you ask me, the way in which he would want to deal with Maxine Carr is right up that alley....

 

Stone the b**ch to death in the streets, eh Chris.....?

 

You utter PLANK, get a real source of news and stop believing everything the gutter press spouts..... -_-

 

Thats the kinda f***ed up $h!t that is making this country go to the dogs at a fukkin rate of knots, they are probably the same ignorant f***wits that attacked homes of paedeatricians :manson: not a fukkin brain cell between them

 

The one 150 yards away is probably TOTALLY innocent, she can join the elusive club as listed down below

Since Carr's release there has been much speculation throughout the UK regarding her whereabouts, often leading to people being wrongly identified as Maxine Carr:

 

In August 2004, Irene Lyttle, an East Kilbride woman, had to be escorted from her home by police and housing officials after death threats were posted on the internet and a mob of vigilantes gathered outside her house.[10]

 

In October 2004, Candice Peberdy and her family from Blaby, Leicestershire were "under siege" for a week from a gang of 25 people who threatened to firebomb their house.[11]

 

In April 2005 Diane Carraro, a South African student on a working holiday in Cheadle, Staffordshire had to go into hiding after being targeted by gangs who threw things at her house, screamed at her in the street, and placed posters of her picture around the town.[12]

 

In March 2006 a woman on the Isle of Wight was mistaken for Carr and subjected to intimidation and abuse, leading local MP Andrew Turner to ask police to end several months of speculation. The police said they could neither confirm nor deny the rumours, due to the Association of Chief Police Officers advising against any statements regarding Carr's location. The local council even put up a sign stating "Please note that Maxine Carr is NOT working at Ryde Library, or any other library on the Isle of Wight."[13]

 

In August 2006 Karen Meek of Coleraine, Northern Ireland, received threats and her husband's van was damaged by people believing her to be Carr. MP Gregory Campbell appealed for her to be left alone.[14]

 

Also in August 2006 Suzette Kapp, a South African woman living in Bonnyrigg, Scotland was incorrectly identified as Carr on local websites with police receiving calls claiming the same.[15]

 

In January 2007 Falmouth police in Cornwall issued a statement denying that Carr was living in the Penryn area after rumours reached "fever pitch", including posters being put up and local police being inundated with calls.[16]

 

All innocent women targeted by thick as pig $h!t inbreds who thought there was a slight physical resemblance to Maxine Carr

 

Pathetic isn't the word :manson:

 

This post quite succinctly puts the need for Carr and her (alleged) baby to be protected by law.... The arseholes who would do any of these women or indeed Carr herself harm frankly deserve to be locked up for a very long time.... We need to start making examples of so-called "vigilantes", they're nothing more than thugs and criminals who would rule this country by terror and fear if, god forbid, they had a mandate to do so..... Remember the French Revolution? Started out with good intentions and then just descended into pure Terrorism.... Uneducated, ignorant people should never have any kind of power.... -_-

 

I'm quite shocked at some of the reactions to her on this forum.

 

YES, she fell in love with a murdering scumbag.

YES, she was wrong for lying to the police and being an alibi for Huntley

YES, she made a mistake and I'm sure she's going to feel the depth of people's angers, and it's going the guilt will eat her up for the rest of her life.

 

But NO, she doe'snt deserve the treatment she is getting. She a was a naive girl who was properly scared witless by Ian Huntley, hence her lying for him.

 

IF she is pregnant, and there's no way we can ever be sure because it could be the press chatting c**p, then I say good luck to her in the future. It show's she's moving on- or attemping to- move on with her life and put Ian Huntley scumbag out of her mind.

Sorry, but you my friend are the perfect example of the sort of person I'm talking about - a sanctimonious, self-righteous, hypocritical vigilante goon on some sort of ridiculous crusade.... I bet you'd go around beating up "paediatricians" thinking they were "paedophiles" wouldn't you...? Get this through your skull mate - MAXINE CARR DID NOT COMMIT ANY ACTS OF MURDER, NOR WAS SHE A WILLING ACCOMPLACE BEFORE, DURING OR EVEN AFTER, THE FACT. SHE LIED TO THE POLICE BECAUSE SHE HAD BEEN MANIPULATED BY HUNTLEY OR ELSE WAS IN FEAR OF HER LIFE.. You're just symptomatic of how the vast majority of this country believe any old c**p the tabloids tell you hook, line and sinker.... Thank fukk people like you dont run the country that's all I can say, I'd bloody well emigrate to somewhere much more civilised if that ever happened, you'd probably want to put me in prison for having long hair and dressing a "bit weird"..... <_< Does it make you feel like a man to threaten the life of frail little woman...?

 

People like Huntley are as successful as they are (and there is every evidence that he'd been responsible for a string of sexual offences) because they are plausible, because they can manipulate people... He fooled a lot of people, not just Carr - he fooled the police for long enough (on his previous offences as well as the initial investigation), he fooled the media (who gave him an interview ffs!!!!!), he fooled his employers, he fooled the parents of Holly and Jessica to an extent as well, in other words, he managed to fool a LOT of people much smarter than Maxine Carr.... This guy is an out and out evil, twisted, depraved b/astard, and yet the meeeeedjaaahhhhh and fools like you choose to focus instead on Maxine Carr instead of scumbag who is the perfect example of a sociopathic sexual predator, he fits every psychological profile to a T, and yet managed to operate for years without any consequences... No, society is to blame for people like Ian Huntley, society is to blame for not stopping him before he killed Holly and Jessica, and Christ knows the Pigs had plenty of chances to put the b/astard away, they also had the chance to prevent him from even getting that job in the school in the first place just by maintaining effective record keeping, they fukked THAT up as well..... <_<

 

 

I never said I was a vigilante did I? That's because I'm not as I value my freedom and not being in jail. Even you can't get away from the fact that Carr is hated by most but not all. Agreed she's not a killer but I bet you most of the general public see her as just as responsible as Huntley. Look at a previous post where it says people mistaken for her have been besieged and attacked.

Sorry, but you my friend are the perfect example of the sort of person I'm talking about - a sanctimonious, self-righteous, hypocritical vigilante goon on some sort of ridiculous crusade.... I bet you'd go around beating up "paediatricians" thinking they were "paedophiles" wouldn't you...? Get this through your skull mate - MAXINE CARR DID NOT COMMIT ANY ACTS OF MURDER, NOR WAS SHE A WILLING ACCOMPLACE BEFORE, DURING OR EVEN AFTER, THE FACT. SHE LIED TO THE POLICE BECAUSE SHE HAD BEEN MANIPULATED BY HUNTLEY OR ELSE WAS IN FEAR OF HER LIFE.. You're just symptomatic of how the vast majority of this country believe any old c**p the tabloids tell you hook, line and sinker.... Thank fukk people like you dont run the country that's all I can say, I'd bloody well emigrate to somewhere much more civilised if that ever happened, you'd probably want to put me in prison for having long hair and dressing a "bit weird"..... <_< Does it make you feel like a man to threaten the life of frail little woman...?

 

People like Huntley are as successful as they are (and there is every evidence that he'd been responsible for a string of sexual offences) because they are plausible, because they can manipulate people... He fooled a lot of people, not just Carr - he fooled the police for long enough (on his previous offences as well as the initial investigation), he fooled the media (who gave him an interview ffs!!!!!), he fooled his employers, he fooled the parents of Holly and Jessica to an extent as well, in other words, he managed to fool a LOT of people much smarter than Maxine Carr.... This guy is an out and out evil, twisted, depraved b/astard, and yet the meeeeedjaaahhhhh and fools like you choose to focus instead on Maxine Carr instead of scumbag who is the perfect example of a sociopathic sexual predator, he fits every psychological profile to a T, and yet managed to operate for years without any consequences... No, society is to blame for people like Ian Huntley, society is to blame for not stopping him before he killed Holly and Jessica, and Christ knows the Pigs had plenty of chances to put the b/astard away, they also had the chance to prevent him from even getting that job in the school in the first place just by maintaining effective record keeping, they fukked THAT up as well..... <_<

 

100% scott... totally agree.

I never said I was a vigilante did I? That's because I'm not as I value my freedom and not being in jail. Even you can't get away from the fact that Carr is hated by most but not all. Agreed she's not a killer but I bet you most of the general public see her as just as responsible as Huntley. Look at a previous post where it says people mistaken for her have been besieged and attacked.

 

you talk the language of a vigilante, hate, viscious threats, like some moron on a hero cruisade, maxine carr knew ian huntley so shes fair game.... and you value your freedom.... you dont want to go to jail, well maxine carr has paid her dues for her very very minor offence and is now also entitled to her freedom. all she did was lie to the police, who hasnt?...lol

 

its the very fact that 'most' of the public see her as equally culpable WHICH SHE ISNT means that we have to pay for her protection!

 

plus the very fact that innocent women are being mistakenly attacked PROVES how stupid the 'haters' are.

 

what a fcuked up world this is.

you talk the language of a vigilante, hate, viscious threats, like some moron on a hero cruisade, maxine carr knew ian huntley so shes fair game.... and you value your freedom.... you dont want to go to jail, well maxine carr has paid her dues for her very very minor offence and is now also entitled to her freedom. all she did was lie to the police, who hasnt?...lol

 

its the very fact that 'most' of the public see her as equally culpable WHICH SHE ISNT means that we have to pay for her protection!

 

plus the very fact that innocent women are being mistakenly attacked PROVES how stupid the 'haters' are.

 

what a fcuked up world this is.

 

 

See now I just think he's stating a fact and you're all piling on him for it.

 

No I don't see her being worse than Ian, all I'm moaning about is the money could be spent better. But people do see it as he's saying it. People get hunted down everyday killed/beaten up, none of these people get protection.

I never said I was a vigilante did I? That's because I'm not as I value my freedom and not being in jail. Even you can't get away from the fact that Carr is hated by most but not all. Agreed she's not a killer but I bet you most of the general public see her as just as responsible as Huntley. Look at a previous post where it says people mistaken for her have been besieged and attacked.

 

 

That's not really what you implied mate. At all... You were quite clear in your support for vigilanteism, therefore you do NOT support or value freedom.. Vigilante "justice" is the very antithesis of freedom because it can make the totally innocent fair game... People are being mistaken for Carr and attacked because of the irrational hatred and sense of mob rule... People probably do see her as being just as responsible, but they are utterly WRONG, and their opinions have been directed and manipulated by the media.. Maxine Carr is no more responsible for what Ian Huntley did than Sonia Sutcliffe is responsible for her husband Peter going around carving up young women, but I suppose someone like you would argue that she is wouldn't you....?

 

 

I don't give a toss how you see it frankly. Everyone I know hates her just as much if not more than Huntley. Think that's probably the general opinion around the country judging by threads today on other forums.

What sort of moron hates the person who covers up for her lover more than the actual murderer? :mellow: I have to say it comes as no surprise you frequent tabloid forums...