i think it's a very bad idea...

When Nelly Furtado did it, it was fine since she wasn't that successful... but Madonna collaborating with Timbaland and Justin after the career she's had!!!! it's definitly a low point for her...

Give her a break man! This talk is getting boring....

sounds like someones singing along haha :P

sounds pretty good. :o

I think it's a bad idea too. But I would wait for the album, to listen to the songs and we can talk about it only then.

 

4 Minutes sounds good to me though! :cheer:

Good, something different. What's next? Country?

Can we hear the damn CD before people already start guessing if it will be good or bad? How the hell can you judge without hearing it?

^^ THANK YOU!!!

I really don't care which direction she goes. all I want are songs that are brilliant! :)

Defo good!!!

Bad. It could be good music, but it doesnt fit her

Good...Madonna is great in any kind of music.

Going by 4 minutes, AMAZING idea :D

Bad, 4 minutes is ok but a bit dissapointing really, the difference here between Nelly Furtado and Madonna is Nelly did it and brought something new to the table, and now Madonna has just jumped on board with Timbaland like every other artist out there and her new sound is just rather generic so its a bit dissapointing.

4 Minutes doesn't even sound like an r&b song to me. =/ It's pop, pretty much. So I don't think this is much of a drastic chagne tbh. It's just less disco and more urban, but it's still pop.

I like her new style, whatever she does I still buy her material

for a song by three of the worlds biggest singers/producers, 4minutes is rubbish. probably the worse song ever released by madge. its a shame really

It's Madonna. She reinvents and changes, it's her thing. Plus it's almost like going back on herself, did nobody listen to Bedtime Stories?

Good good good!! :D

Oh CHER, not again <_<

i love madonna and she knows that if she wants to have another hit in america she should collaborate... and now she decided to collaborate with americas most loved r&b artist justin... so the half of its success belongs to him...

i hope the album is better than 4 minutes!