thats where we disagree, i dont. i dont see anything about them that will last like girls aloud and the sugababes. there song is nothing special, their name is awful, they failed to perform a simple song and routine live... they aint kids, they HAVE to do these tasks in order to 'make it'.

 

ill be happy to be proven wrong m8 :)

 

You probably thought the same about Girls Aloud when you they did their first performance as a band- now have 18 Top 10's! Gosh, are you ever positive about anything? If you don't like them fair enough, but why be so negative all the time? They have decent voices as you would find out if you watch their performance of Issues.

 

They haven't been together and performing for ages! Like Girls Aloud, their live vocals have improved drastically over the years!

 

And you say Frankie and Rochelle have been doing it for years :rolleyes: they've sung live ONCE on t.v! Give them a chance ffs.

 

Anyways, absolutely love it :wub: hope it's a success ^_^

You probably thought the same about Girls Aloud when you they did their first performance as a band- now have 18 Top 10's! Gosh, are you ever positive about anything? If you don't like them fair enough, but why be so negative all the time? They have decent voices as you would find out if you watch their performance of Issues.

 

They haven't been together and performing for ages! Like Girls Aloud, their live vocals have improved drastically over the years!

 

And you say Frankie and Rochelle have been doing it for years :rolleyes: they've sung live ONCE on t.v! Give them a chance ffs.

 

Anyways, absolutely love it :wub: hope it's a success ^_^

 

its not negative, its REALISTIC.

 

i dont think anyone thought girls aloud would be a long term success, however they did have a degree of talent which is something that seems to be lacking in the saturdays. if you had read the thread then youd see that indeed i did praise their rendition of 'issues'.

 

frankie and rochelle HAVE been performing for years, 6 to be exact, and it was frankies part in the live performance that was the worst! no excuse! she had a few lines to sing and failed to deliver... if this was pop idol or summut she'd have been out. that performance was awful... they HAVE to do bettter and i think they will.

Entered the tv airplay chart at #48.

Ozmead, I'm not judging her music for the fact she's an awful whore - I'm judging it for being absolutely hideous. Fashion in particular makes me want to cry.

I think Heidi's song is best out of the three

Ok, Ok, OK ... if we are judging the songs right here in 2008 i HAVE to say The Saturdays is the best. Heidi's is ok, but the vocals and actual lyrics and general performance are much worse than them.

 

But whilst were on the Montag subject ... the rest of her songs are HIDEOUS!!

"Body Language" is a much better song than "If This Is Love". Better chrous, better production. Just much cachier in general. And the sample works better in the song. My oppinion at the end of the day.

 

I'll try and leave this as its not a Heidi topic :/ lol But I don't really rate her. I like her songs. I think to hate her is a bit extreme though. People often talk about celebrities like they know them.

Edited June 30, 200817 yr by Ozmead

I hope If This Is Love goes number 1!

I hope If This Is Love goes number 1!

 

I wish but lets face It, top 5 at very highest!

Montag compared herself to jesus <_< the whore

Montag compared herself to jesus <_< the whore

 

... so she doesnt exist , but if she did shes be crucified?... :lol:

^:lol: i wish!

She said that she was very religious and when asked about her alleged sex tape, she said that Jesus was being percecuted and like him, so is she.

I agree with Mushy, if these are the next big thing my name is Alfred Hitchcock. 'If This Is Love' is OK (and I will probably grow to love it because it's poppy) but I honestly cannot see them having a second hit, if the first one even becomes a hit. I obviously want Frankie and Rochelle to do well though.

I agree with Mushy, if these are the next big thing my name is Alfred Hitchcock. 'If This Is Love' is OK (and I will probably grow to love it because it's poppy) but I honestly cannot see them having a second hit, if the first one even becomes a hit. I obviously want Frankie and Rochelle to do well though.

 

steady on... i wouldnt have given 'steps' the time of day either! :lol:

 

 

I heard my favourite Steps song today :wub: 'It's The Way You Make Me Feel' :dance: :wub:

This thread has got alot of attention haha!

If This Is Love now on Radio 1 C-List, which is great since i dont think a lot of people had any hope of it getting playlisted.

... its only c listed though.... :)

Better than not being playlisted at all though.

considering its Radio 1 i'd say its a big achievement ;)

Better than not being playlisted at all though.

 

agreed :)

 

there will be no excuse though when... erm... IF it flops! :lol: